Playing the saxophone Jambalaya - versions and keys

Here is "Jambalaya" with some whistling. Banjo, accordion harmonica, fiddle ... it's jambalaya but can also be gumbo, nasi goreng, pytt i panna ..... or maybe some Memphis Soul Stew as well. Forget the key or form ... just play.
View: https://youtu.be/YMnhh1PFSTw
Lots of versions here, personally I really like the fats Domino version. Im trying to learn a bit about transposition and will move onto playing by ear next..ill have to do a bit of scale learning first tho...I bought the sheet music which had a lovelly picture of the carpenters on the front but the song is in c major. Doesnt fit with fats domino or the carpenters..fits hank williams tho..lol..have to transpose it but unsure to what key...
 
Hi does anyone know what key the original was in. I bought a copy transposed it but it didn't sound right against the carpenters version. Google is giving d major or G major music notes c major another site G major...

cant see that the questions answered yet...lol

A quick Wikipedia search tells us that the song was written by Hank Williams.
And the Williams recording in an earlier post is in concert C.
Therefore it seems reasonable to assume that the song was originally in C.

But frankly, why do you care? You can play it in any key you like.
 
tho...I bought the sheet music which had a lovelly picture of the carpenters on the front but the song is in c major
If Pete's backing is in concert C, you are almost there

You have the sheet in concert C, so you can create a transposed version, two semitones higher*, a number of ways... Quick and easy is to photocopy your sheet, and write a letter above each note to show the transposed note value

So for C you write D, etc. Use the original notes for the rhythm of the melody and use the letters to play the transposed note value

Alternatively, transpose the sheet longhand with a pencil onto a new, blank music manuscript, in D major

*Assuming you are playing tenor
 
Thanks @nigeld but its the wrong key for the carpenters..

Your opening question was about the original key (concert C), so that is what I have answered.

However, the Carpenters version is in concert G, which means that you want notes in the key of A for tenor sax.
So you can use the alto (Eb) sax notes for concert C - they are in A. When you play from these notes on tenor, you are in concert G.
 
Your opening question was about the original key (concert C), so that is what I have answered.

However, the Carpenters version is in concert G, which means that you want notes in the key of A for tenor sax.
So you can use the alto (Eb) sax notes for concert C - they are in A. When you play from these notes on tenor, you are in concert G.
yep sorry @nigeld... my bad...lol...It was I bought a copy of the song which had the carpenters on the front..so I assumed it was their version...it had hank williams name to it and was in concert c...I wasn't clear what I meant so apologise for that...I transposed the original to d major but it was still much to low...
 
ok so the version I bought was in C major I can get it transposed but am a little confused...The site sells the song in A major which it says is c major -3 which implies is lower than c major. Or C major plus 9...is this just an octave above Cmajor -3 ??
 
Don't understand how D can be much too low for tenor ?
Here's a version from Rockin' Dopsie - it's in D - could be John Hart on tenor - not sure.

Jambalaya Rockin' Dopsie
Hi @spike...mucked up my original post. The score I have in in C major sounds fine for tenor in D major against the original Hank Williams recording. I wanted to play the caarpenters version which i was rightly told in post 2 is in g major....
 
Just occurred to me that sometimes you might be playing stuff an octave lower.
If it's written too low for you - take it up an octave.

It's such a simple melody - you always seem to make life very difficult for yourself. :doh:
 
LoL I know @jazzdoh...think it will continue to be this way til I understand..In my defence I like to play the right key to the original...It is complicated for me at the mo...will get easier for me, and hopefully you patient lot too...
I can understand that, when you in the future play with singers you will have to play the key the singer wants, for instrumentals it usually the original key that counts.
 
Just occurred to me that sometimes you might be playing stuff an octave lower.
If it's written too low for you - take it up an octave.

It's such a simple melody - you always seem to make life very difficult for yourself. :doh:
Hey it must be soooo easy when you know what you're doing lol ...no one to bounce of or ask =s difficult times...Really do appreciate the patience on here....its so much harder via posts gradually getting the hang of transposing, great advice re the octave....
 
A transposing tip that you may or may not know.
Use numbers for the notes - for instance the first three notes of Jamba are 3 5 6 regardless of what key it's in.
So in the key of C Major the notes are in fact E G A
since the Key of C is D Major on tenor those notes in D are F# A B
So - Doesn't matter what key always the 3rd 5th and 6th notes of that key.
Those numbers also won't change with a chord change.
If you think in numbers you won't have to worry about the note names.
 
A transposing tip that you may or may not know.
Use numbers for the notes - for instance the first three notes of Jamba are 3 5 6 regardless of what key it's in.
So in the key of C Major the notes are in fact E G A
since the Key of C is D Major on tenor those notes in D are F# A B
So - Doesn't matter what key always the 3rd 5th and 6th notes of that key.
Those numbers also won't change with a chord change.
If you think in numbers you won't have to worry about the note names.
Big thanks @spike really valuable advise I wouldn't have learnt anywhere else....
 
LoL I know @jazzdoh...think it will continue to be this way til I understand..In my defence I like to play the right key to the original...It is complicated for me at the mo...will get easier for me, and hopefully you patient lot too...
Well, the ORIGINAL is the key of C, since Hank sang it in that key and he wrote the song and was the first person to record it.

If you want to play it in G concert (apparently the Carpenters did it in G) then play it on tenor in A. The melody's simple, there can't be but about 5 notes to it, just learn it by ear in A. In A, the first three notes of the verse melody are C#-E-F#, just take it from there.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,635
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom