Playing the saxophone I've hit a wall with my practice

I don’t understand that. They are enharmonic. To me, as explained by James Moody, a bebop scale is just a diatonic scale with a passing note added. So on a C7 or Gm7 I might play C B Bb etc adding the B as a passing note. It generally helps you target a chord note. But I’m not thinking about major 6 or diminished 7, seems a bit complicated and I just don’t understand what those have to do with a bebop scale.
Go check out Barry Harris. He called it a diminished 6th scale (made up of a diminished and a major 6th - the way he was thinking of it).

Rarely in jazz do people play linearly, instead highlighting arpeggios. The bebop scale is made up of two components: the major 6 which is the root, and then a diminished which provides tension to the root.

E.g. if we're in Bb, you have Bb, D, F, G for the major 6, and then C, Eb, Gb, A as the remaining notes of your bebop scale, which form a diminished 7th.

Diminished 7ths are interchangeable with dominant chords, and you have a series of great half step resolutions back to that major 6 chord.

The diminished 7th sets up tension, the major 6 is resolution.

This is one of those things that if you sit down and play it it will make sense. It sounds like bebop. Playing up and down a bebop scale kinda doesn't (especially UP a bebop scale).

And even the term "bebop scale" wasn't introduced until 1988 in David Baker's book. Guys like Barry were actually playing this in the 40s and 50s.... whilst David Baker had great ifeas I'll probably take the input of the guys that played it at the time.
 
Last edited:
No idea what you’re talking about here. Classical music? They value aural ability very highly and you’ll find that every musical style has musicians who have fantastic ears.
Just music education in schools in the 90s. I' not besmirching classical music at all, but definitely the way it was taught to me. And the way my instrument was taught to me: focus on playing notes from a page, regardless of whether the music sounded good and suited the instrument, in order to pass grades.
 
Rather like the OP then. She’s voicing her concerns now, and is going to run them by her teacher. Perhaps you can be happy for that as it must remind you of yourself all those years ago.

Your goals are not everyone’s goals. Other people do learn in different ways. I went a long way in classical clarinet. I loved playing chamber music and miss it very much since deciding against a career in classical music in favour of pop/jazz.
My jazz/improvisation learning, from a young age, was self-taught and also a “blind leading the blind” with a few mates. I don’t regret the classical stuff - it’s still relevant to me as it made me the musician I am (and it’s good stuff) - someone who can dip a decent enough toe in most musical styles - which I’m more than ok with as I’d get bored with one style of music.

If asked, we can inform on what did or didn’t work for us, what we think might be better ways to absorb knowledge more quickly or effectively. Our way might not always be the best way, or perhaps just not the best way for everyone.
You do realise I'm not talking about my goals? I'm offering positive encouragement. A "hey you can do this, and here are some ways that might help".

Rather than the majority who stating "no, this is crazy this is simply too hard for you!"

😉
 
You do realise I'm not talking about my goals? I'm offering positive encouragement. A "hey you can do this, and here are some ways that might help".

Rather than the majority who stating "no, this is crazy this is simply too hard for you!"

😉
Yes, it's about placing yourself in someone else shoes.

I'm not a believer in having a go at anything, no matter the difficulty. I think that effective learning should be about giving a student material where "little triumphs" are almost guaranteed with a modicum of practice. The more serious the student becomes, then the amount of practice needed to achieve any gain is increased.

My biggest gripe with graded exams - at grade 7 and 8 all choices are too difficult and for the vast majority of students it will entail hacking through and playing them awfully.

Many of us had to play the game re music college entry requirements. A few of my friends fell foul of the grade 5 piano as a 2nd study requirement back in the day. A shame, terrific players. Grades might not be a great way to go about it, but it's a measurement of attainment and of knowledge - far better than the predicament some of my friends find themselves in now when faced with degree music students who have rather large gaps in their knowledge of music theory.
 
You do realise I'm not talking about my goals? I'm offering positive encouragement. A "hey you can do this, and here are some ways that might help".

Rather than the majority who stating "no, this is crazy this is simply too hard for you!"

😉
The problem is that I don't find it to be "real world". You go about practice as a professional player does - you're presuming a level of commitment to be normal.
 
So I don't disagree with most of what you're saying.

On the empathy side, I've been in those shoes. I've been told "you just need to transcribe", or "you just need tonplay the omnibook". Without the guidance on how to do, or why doing those things is beneficial, they're very daunting tasks. Which is why I've suggested methods for going about doing it, that seem like they're challenging and require a lot of effort but actually if you sit down and do them, take a lot less time than is imagined: and then imagine the sense of achievement when something that seemed daunting was achieved in small steps and relatively short time?

I'm terrible at practising scales and I'm also very lazy; they're monotonous, don't sound like music and bore me to tears; I've yet to find a way to unlock that and so... I just don't practise scales. But listen to a phrase on a record , jazz or otherwise, that I like, I can sit down and run that through 12 keys.

Yes it does require some commitment; but I don't see presuming that as a bad thing: that someone is asking for help is a sign of some commitment, if they weren't they'd just quit after hitting that wall.

As I said right at the start, if the OP doesn't like the particular solo, pick something else, communicate with the teacher and say so; say that they think it's all too much at the moment. But alongside that here are things that help me do the task that's been assigned, and I think they will help anybody who comes across those problems, and I for one wish someone had gone through this with me when I was younger!
 
@mrblackbat sounds just like my teacher, and I do agree with what he's saying.

I've had my teacher sit back on my Sofa and belt out an improvised solo demonstrating the use of only 6 notes, and I'm just gawping at him in awe. He'll calmly announce, how he's just doing exactly what he'd explained to me... however he's a lifetime of practice and experience however, he then explains how to best approach learning it, exercises, and for me, most importantly WHY. Rather than just sending me away to practice something, and come back in a few weeks.

I'm probably the opposite of Matt too, in that I'd rather do a scale/arpeggio exercise than transcribe a solo, my recognition of patterns in written music is pretty pants. But there's only so many hours I can practice.

I'm all for the small wins... especially if you're investing hours of practice, in what can be quite a monotonous, tedious task, it's only when you get that AHA! moment, it all seems worthwhile.

If it was easy, everyone would be blowing horns, and jamming like Dexter & Cannonball :sax: Enjoyment is key!
 
I like transcribing - a bar or two at a time. Find something in a solo that catches your ear, and transcribe it.

Then take that phrase/lick/pattern/whatchamacallit and practice it in all 12 keys. (Mr. Pedantic would say 15 keys…) But if that’s too boring, or challenging, figure out a place where that pattern fits in, say, a 12-bar blues. Put iRealPro or the backing track of your choice on a loop, and play the blues for a half hour - sticking that lick in every chorus. If you can play in more than one key, add those into the practice.

For me that works better than transcribing an entire solo, but I’m lazy. I also dislike “rote practicing” - mindlessly running the same scale over and over, inching the metronome up click by click. It’s so easy to get distracted, thinking about dinner or your girlfriend or whatever. I probably dislike it because I was taught to do it, and did it religiously for years. I’m not really sorry I did, I can play the hell out of my scales, but I practice patterns now, and tunes.
 
Then take that phrase/lick/pattern/whatchamacallit and practice it in all 12 keys. (Mr. Pedantic would say 15 keys…) But if that’s too boring, or challenging, figure out a place where that pattern fits in, say, a 12-bar blues. Put iRealPro or the backing track of your choice on a loop, and play the blues for a half hour - sticking that lick in every chorus. If you can play in more than one key, add those into the practice.
This is definitely great practise and how to start making those patterns and licks stick. And that handy mode in iReal that I really don't use often enough that shifts the key is fab for this too.

Something for me to spend more time on! 🫣
 
Last edited:
It takes time and patience to get all the tools you want. Try to study small things as most people said here. Isolate each issue. Don't try to make them all at once. It's tried and proven. For example if your articulation has issues, try a scale or arpeggios until done right. If you want to explore dominant major ideas use a dominant major drone etc.
It may sound that people magically put things together but noone did. They all put an enormous effort and made sure the ly made their practice fun.

I call this method "William Blake method" as per his line "to see the world in a grain of sand" because if you x-ray harmony and melody.... Great things come together on their own.

Also never underestimate the importance of fundamentals. Tone rhythm accuracy etc. and take it slooooooow
 
I guess it's this one:
View: https://youtu.be/QioT8qGMPfY?si=DpBzGfU_FEmOpG8r


It's very Stitt and very bebop - is that what you want to learn and are you able to get around some/much/all of the solo ?

Rhys

PS That YouTube link does say the written transcription can be bought for alto as well as tenor and concert pitch instruments. How is your reading ?
Yes this is the one. My teacher already gave me the transcript for alto. No problem reading it, just playing it!
 
I sometimes had students who wanted to play jazz but likewise were daunted by all the chords whizzing by. One thing I found useful was I'd just play one chord on the piano and suggest they just play "stuff" over it for several minutes and see what melodic things they coord. See what sounding "on" what sounded "out" and if it sounded out was it in a good or a bad way.

Just playing over one chord is great for finding out stuff like what works and why but it's only a small part of the picture as the tricky bit is going form one to another.

So we'd then do another chord.

After that I'd play them one after the other so they could get the idea of how to play over that one chord change and I'd then dissect and show them how melody notes can lead from one to the other.

I think throwing a relative beginner at the deep end can be very frustrating and counter productive.

It's also crucial to explain how chords fit in the overall harmony. Some teachers will tell you there is a specific scale for each chord. Hopefully yours doesn't do that because it's a method that is doomed to make things more complicated in the end even if it seems simple to begin with. So for example the simple cadence Dm7 G7 C should not be thought of as having to play 3 different scales because you only need one - the C scale.

Also if they are teaching you to improvise jazz they must tell you how the harmony works, what is a cadence etc. For this you need very simple songs to begin with and gradually build up to the more complex. If
Thank you. That's helpful. I have your TTS improvisation book and find it explains things in a way I can understand, alongside a couple of useful You Tube channels.
I feel I need to learn more theory before I could even begin to understand a complex bebop solo like that.
 
Wow, I would never ask a beginner to start with something like that unless they really wanted to and could understand and analyse the harmony.
My sentiments exactly. It's definitely not what I want.
Perhaps he's testing my commitment? Or he just doesn't want to teach me and knows this will scare me off? 😭
I feel I might go back to learning on my own ... Or find a different teacher 😔
 
I'm not sure I completely agree with the notion that Stitt is impossible here. How many folk played stuff out of the Omnibook pretty early on? I depends on what you're doing and trying to achieve. There's benefit to trying to read something that's above your skill level, and always benefit trying to work something out.

For instance, right at the very start of the Sonny Stitt recording of It Could Happen To You, he starts with the famous nur nur nu nur nur playground taunt; which is a great little phrase to learn and incorporate, followed by a lovely 2-5 turnaround back to the melody. You could spend ages just working out that phrase, playing along with Sonny, and have an absolute LOAD to take away from this. You could also just transcribe the way he plays the head, and get a bucket load out of it.

Main thing is to break it down into steps and move from there. Just try singing along with it, little bit by little bit, then take that to the horn. Make sure you can sing it first! And don't doubt that you can do that - everyone can sing a melody if they listen to it over and over.
So the bit you're talking about is the intro bit which I just tackle, albeit very slowly and not fluidly. After bar 38 is where the actual solo starts in earnest.
I appreciate your feedback. I feel you are possibly more advanced in your playing than I? The whole point of my lessons is so that I can learn to do the things you are suggesting.
 
No problem reading it, just playing it!
I bet you can. Not fast, not as fast as on the video. What 50bpm? 80? 40?
That's ok.
Never play anything faster than you can manage. Doing so would be anti-learning!

Why not do what most people do? Learn it really slow till you have it ok (say 3 times through without error. Possibly without looking). Speed up 5bpm... Rinse and repeat till your lesson; then play it for teacher where you are. It's not an audition, it's an assessment. If he criticizes it for being to slow... Well, you've got an answer.

Bonus suggestion. Putting the metronome on 1 & 3, 2 & 4, on 8ths etc. Can be really useful to tie down the timing... Whatever the speed you are playing.

Bonus 2:
Don't just play it through. Spend 80% if your time on the hardest passages
 
Last edited:
"No problem reading it, just playing it!"

Try playing a phrase or just a measure with quarter or even half notes.
Even tempo always.
Will help get the fingering down and the sounds into your mind.

Try to enjoy the challenges that are part of becoming musical.
Frustration and Failure ain't helpful.
In normal daily activities, the only thing that is HARD, as my Airborne buddies say,
is the ground. 🙄
 
Just saw your post, and it's 4 times thru in the States. 😀
If you slow it down, with the written values, once you can play it without error, 4 times thru, continue that tempo for 5-7 days.
Then take it a bit faster the following week.
Coordination and muscle development takes time.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,429
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom