Playing the saxophone I've hit a wall with my practice

I sometimes had students who wanted to play jazz but likewise were daunted by all the chords whizzing by. One thing I found useful was I'd just play one chord on the piano and suggest they just play "stuff" over it for several minutes and see what melodic things they coord. See what sounding "on" what sounded "out" and if it sounded out was it in a good or a bad way.

Just playing over one chord is great for finding out stuff like what works and why but it's only a small part of the picture as the tricky bit is going form one to another.

So we'd then do another chord.

After that I'd play them one after the other so they could get the idea of how to play over that one chord change and I'd then dissect and show them how melody notes can lead from one to the other.

I think throwing a relative beginner at the deep end can be very frustrating and counter productive.

It's also crucial to explain how chords fit in the overall harmony. Some teachers will tell you there is a specific scale for each chord. Hopefully yours doesn't do that because it's a method that is doomed to make things more complicated in the end even if it seems simple to begin with. So for example the simple cadence Dm7 G7 C should not be thought of as having to play 3 different scales because you only need one - the C scale.

Also if they are teaching you to improvise jazz they must tell you how the harmony works, what is a cadence etc. For this you need very simple songs to begin with and gradually build up to the more complex. If
The one chord at a time approach is something I used to do when teaching too, and as you say, then try and get into the change over.

Deep end isn’t any good at all - mostly, any task should be a step away, something that can be grasped or understood fairly easily.
 
I'm not sure I completely agree with the notion that Stitt is impossible here. How many folk played stuff out of the Omnibook pretty early on? I depends on what you're doing and trying to achieve. There's benefit to trying to read something that's above your skill level, and always benefit trying to work something out.

For instance, right at the very start of the Sonny Stitt recording of It Could Happen To You, he starts with the famous nur nur nu nur nur playground taunt; which is a great little phrase to learn and incorporate, followed by a lovely 2-5 turnaround back to the melody. You could spend ages just working out that phrase, playing along with Sonny, and have an absolute LOAD to take away from this. You could also just transcribe the way he plays the head, and get a bucket load out of it.

Main thing is to break it down into steps and move from there. Just try singing along with it, little bit by little bit, then take that to the horn. Make sure you can sing it first! And don't doubt that you can do that - everyone can sing a melody if they listen to it over and over.
 
This transcription is way too hard for a beginner player, the song itself would be fine but to do the transcription with meaning and understanding and at the speed it's meant to be you would need to be at a much higher level, why not learn the basic tune first then move up in stages.
 
It’s hard enough nailing the 8ths. Then there are harmonics and 16ths.
Y s, maybe the starting quote is a good example of humour and how you can quote stuff in a solo - so look at that on it’s own.

It’s long too…
 
I'm not sure I completely agree with the notion that Stitt is impossible here. How many folk played stuff out of the Omnibook pretty early on? I depends on what you're doing and trying to achieve. There's benefit to trying to read something that's above your skill level, and always benefit trying to work something out.

For instance, right at the very start of the Sonny Stitt recording of It Could Happen To You, he starts with the famous nur nur nu nur nur playground taunt; which is a great little phrase to learn and incorporate, followed by a lovely 2-5 turnaround back to the melody. You could spend ages just working out that phrase, playing along with Sonny, and have an absolute LOAD to take away from this. You could also just transcribe the way he plays the head, and get a bucket load out of it.

Main thing is to break it down into steps and move from there. Just try singing along with it, little bit by little bit, then take that to the horn. Make sure you can sing it first! And don't doubt that you can do that - everyone can sing a melody if they listen to it over and over.
With respect, I think you’re seeing yourself in the OP.
 
With respect, I think you’re seeing yourself in the OP.
Possibly, but also I kinda wish someone pushed me into doing this a LOT earlier than it actually happened. And I really don't think this is as hard as people want to make out, so long as you just let your ears do the work - take the theory away, take the sheet music away and so on.

I remember working tunes out VERY early in my development on the saxophone (Simpson's theme tune, anyone.... yes I was that age). And then over time that got taken away by sheet music, theory, scales and so on.
 
Possibly, but also I kinda wish someone pushed me into doing this a LOT earlier than it actually happened. And I really don't think this is as hard as people want to make out, so long as you just let your ears do the work - take the theory away, take the sheet music away and so on.

I remember working tunes out VERY early in my development on the saxophone (Simpson's theme tune, anyone.... yes I was that age). And then over time that got taken away by sheet music, theory, scales and so on.
If you’re that type of person - and it’s up to the teacher to gauge that.

Ears - learned.

And yes, you’ve forgotten how much you know. 😃
 
Also, let's remember that at this point nobody has heard @Mix O Lydian play other than the teacher. Yes, the solo may be well beyond.... or maybe it's not as far away as everyone thinks - Sonny Stitt is great, but he has very core language - that open lick is a very familiar turnaround phrase he uses all the time that is mostly just an arpeggio.

Breaking it down into chunks like that is absolutely the way:-

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dy5DgR8Uap0
 
@Mix O Lydian rest assured you're not alone, and I've been exactly where you are. I've been having lessons with my teacher for a few years, and I cannot deny my playing has improved, but each time there's more 'stuff' I could, should and want to practice but there's just not enough hours in the day.

I've previously posted about my improvisation journey as after making good progress with my playing I just seemed incapable of improvisation.

I agree Practicing and Playing are very different. Over the summer break from the orchestra, I put effort into my rhythm & timing, the results weren't immediately noticeable but even now month later, I get a real sense of satisfaction when I play a Soli in time, or get further in a duet with my teacher... the hours of repetitive practice paid off, I should do more of it.

I'm planning to work on my chords, one at a time, and start working through Autumn Leaves. Oh and I really need to work on my syncopation too.

I would suggest speaking to your teacher, find out what your biggest weakness is, at least that way you should see some progression. Is your teacher giving you advice on how to learn? Mine often comes out with gems on information on how to approach the 'learning', not just telling me what to learn.

All that said, my last lesson, I think both my teacher and I just needed to let off a bit of steam, and we had a laugh playing some duets - Yes there were still things I learnt, but it was a side step away from the usual, and good to gauge how much I'd improved.
 
But now I dread the frustration of my practice sessions. Last week I didn't play for four days in a row, which is the longest I have gone without practicing.

IMO this is a sign the material is too challenging. Maybe you can meet the teacher halfway here, and ask them to give you a smaller chunk of the solo, like the first 8 bars.

I think I understand the situation here because I'm in a similar boat -- almost one and a half years into playing. It's not that a solo like Stitt's is impossible to learn. But faced with the knowledge of all the other things to practise -- tone, scales, other repertoire, etc. -- having to devote a whole practice session (or like a week of sessions) to learning one chunk of material can feel wrong.
 
I'm going to send him an email.
Can I ask how you go about learning something like that?

I've found, sometimes, that leaning learning technique is as or more important than playing technique.

You've been learning, what?, 2 years? With, little if any, playing background?
Yes just two years and only been focusing on jazz since August. I'm learning it a few bars at a time and repeating the phrases that I struggle with.
 
IMO this is a sign the material is too challenging. Maybe you can meet the teacher halfway here, and ask them to give you a smaller chunk of the solo, like the first 8 bars.

I think I understand the situation here because I'm in a similar boat -- almost one and a half years into playing. It's not that a solo like Stitt's is impossible to learn. But faced with the knowledge of all the other things to practise -- tone, scales, other repertoire, etc. -- having to devote a whole practice session (or like a week of sessions) to learning one chunk of material can feel wrong.
Indeed. I've decided to set it aside for now. It's causing me too much angst! We had been doing Autumn Leaves solos and learning improvisation for that so I think I'll just focus on the language and theory for that particular song.
He has given me so much other great material to work with, not to mention the books that I already have.
 
Yes - but then my 3 year old is singing all the Christmas songs after hearing them a couple of times this morning. When Santa Gets Stuck Up the Chimney has been on shouty repeat all day....
Yes, as will most 3 year olds. But when your 3 year old starts scatting Bebop send her to someone special. That degree of complexity takes ear training.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,428
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom