Playing the saxophone I've hit a wall with my practice

I'm planning to work on my chords, one at a time, and start working through Autumn Leaves. Oh and I really need to work on my syncopation too.
We had been doing Autumn Leaves solos and impro and I was slowly starting to get used to it. Similar to you, syncopation, getting used to the language and pace of the music, understanding the chords, I think I need more time. I feel I need more time.
 
I'm learning it a few bars at a time and repeating the phrases that I struggle with.
So for me this is the way to learn it. What I would do is something like this:

Imagine there are 8 prhases; learn phrase 1, slowly at 60bpm until the fingers are really drilled in, then take it up in tempo (you'll probably find if you've really drilled it slow, it comes easy at a faster tempo). Sing it in your head as you're playing it, almost screaming it out in your internal voice, if that makes sense.

Once you have that first phrase down, do the same with the second phrase, but start it on the last note or two of the previous phrase. Bring it up to tempo.

Then take the tempo back to 60bpm and join the two phrases together; bring it back up as you're comfortable. If there are bits that don't feel fluid, focus on those for a bit and then the phrase around them.

Once you have those two down, start on the third phrase, then add the second phrase in, the when that's comfy and the first in.

So essentially you'll build it all up in chunks of phrases like this:

1
2
12
3
23
123
4
34
234
1234

Erc
 
We had been doing Autumn Leaves solos and impro and I was slowly starting to get used to it. Similar to you, syncopation, getting used to the language and pace of the music, understanding the chords, I think I need more time. I feel I need more time.
More time is always fine, and listening is also really important too - listening can be a practise session!

You sound like you have all the right things going on, so just go at the tempo you feel is right; bring it up with your teacher and say if you feel there's too much too soon and so on.

I'm currently having lessons... but at a frequency of 1 every 6 months at the moment. There's more than enough in each one of the sessions I have to keep me busy for months!
 
Yes, as will most 3 year olds. But when your 3 year old starts scatting Bebop send her to someone special. That degree of complexity takes ear training.
But the point remains that we do better with our ears earlier, then put stuff in the way.

The same applies to bebop. Look at a bebop scale: it's a major 6 and a diminished 7th put together. You can take those two pieces of information, practise how they sound and listen to it, play their sounds.... and sound like you're playing bebop.

When Sonny Rollins, Jackie McLean and co were all playing as kids in Harlem in the Counts of Bop, do you think they'd sat down and gone through all the theory of lydian dominants, altered chords, covered off voice leading, enclosures etc etc. Or did they just listen to the records, realise almost everything is a major 6th arpeggio or a diminished 7th and just played?
 
But the point remains that we do better with our ears earlier, then put stuff in the way.

The same applies to bebop. Look at a bebop scale: it's a major 6 and a diminished 7th put together. You can take those two pieces of information, practise how they sound and listen to it, play their sounds.... and sound like you're playing bebop.

When Sonny Rollins, Jackie McLean and co were all playing as kids in Harlem in the Counts of Bop, do you think they'd sat down and gone through all the theory of lydian dominants, altered chords, covered off voice leading, enclosures etc etc. Or did they just listen to the records, realise almost everything is a major 6th arpeggio or a diminished 7th and just played?
Your argument is flawed. They were immersed in a music community. They also became incredible players - they weren’t the only ones there, so what happened to them?

I’m sure you won’t be surprised to know that I’m aware of the Bebop scale. Your level of commitment is probably more than the OP has to give. The OP is also two years in, and has said that the they feel inundated. Practice mechanisms will not solve this on their own.
 
The community they had was their peers saying "yes you can do it" rather than "no you can't".

Sadly there seems to be a lot more of the latter, nowadays.

I wasn't suggesting you didn't know what a bebop scale is. But from a simplification process breaking it down into two parts: tension and resolution (diminished and major 6 respectively) gives you a huge amount of tools to work with. A lot of that other stuff then comes naturally.

As I said earlier, we haven't heard the OP, but their teacher has. Perhaps that teacher hears the potential to get there, and just giving a little push. Or perhaps they're a terrible teacher. Who knows?

I'd prefer to have faith that people aren't terrible, until evidence proves otherwise.
 
The community they had was their peers saying "yes you can do it" rather than "no you can't".
And they were among musicians getting tips on a daily basis. Plus these people are some of the best of their generation. My point is that we can’t just hold up the process and conditions that the best players had when starting out and think that must work for everyone.

It’s a bit like saying that Wynton Marsalis only got good through lots of practice, or just because he had that family of great musicians around him - but of course, it’s both. And the fact that he had some aptitude for music and drive to succeed.

Heap too much on some people and you kill that. They drown. It seems that we are being told this by the OP. Whatever the teacher did, I’m sure they’d have explained how to break it down and go slowly at first…. Which obviously hasn’t made a lot of difference. Sometimes things are just too daunting. Extra explanation in this case is not going to make a difference.
 
We had been doing Autumn Leaves solos and impro and I was slowly starting to get used to it. Similar to you, syncopation, getting used to the language and pace of the music, understanding the chords, I think I need more time. I feel I need more time.
It's challenging, improvising is a world away from playing written music. As others have said, take a break from the improv and work on something else, there's always something that needs working on. The come back to improv when you feel ready you might be surprised.

I've been busy working on pieces for the orchestra X-Mas concert, and the quartet pieces (that's another story), I found this video on chord tone exercises had a little go this evening with the opening chord of Autumn Leaves, just messing with those 4 notes, starting on different inversions, different rhythms... I'll eventually build up to the next chord and hopefully string the two together.
 
And they were among musicians getting tips on a daily basis. Plus these people are some of the best of their generation. My point is that we can’t just hold up the process and conditions that the best players had when starting out and think that must work for everyone.

It’s a bit like saying that Wynton Marsalis only got good through lots of practice, or just because he had that family of great musicians around him - but of course, it’s both. And the fact that he had some aptitude for music and drive to succeed.

Heap too much on some people and you kill that. They drown. It seems that we are being told this by the OP. Whatever the teacher did, I’m sure they’d have explained how to break it down and go slowly at first…. Which obviously hasn’t made a lot of difference. Sometimes things are just too daunting. Extra explanation in this case is not going to make a difference.
I agree with you 100%, this level of learning at such an early part of a players journey is too much and could lead some players in a similar position to give up.
If it's a hobby then what's wrong with learning at a slower pace where the player doesn't feel swapped, what could happen is for the teacher to take the pressure off and give the student unlimited time on this and make it a longer term goal and build up to this level gradually.
Just my thoughts but others may vary.
 
Should have been Some Skunk Funk huh? Sing it first if you can’t play it 🙄
Nah Coltrane's solo on Someday My Prince Will Come, but the same thought process applies!

What was I actually playing? Some crap for a graded exam that I didn't really care about, wasn't written for saxophone, and involved reading music that didn't really benefit how I wanted tonplay in anyway.

A few years later I had the self confidence to tell my teacher at that point to do the minimum to get through the exams so I could get into university, but focus on teaching me about jazz.

Wish someone had had the foresight to do that for me sooner.

It's what I find amusing about the "too much jazz form the 50s" complaints about teaching. I came across 0% of that. I came across an awful lot of adapted classical music, that sounded terrible, the idea that music is written on a page and not heard, and that you play as and when someone waves a stick at you to play.
 
Last edited:
The same applies to bebop. Look at a bebop scale: it's a major 6 and a diminished 7th put together.
I don’t understand that. They are enharmonic. To me, as explained by James Moody, a bebop scale is just a diatonic scale with a passing note added. So on a C7 or Gm7 I might play C B Bb etc adding the B as a passing note. It generally helps you target a chord note. But I’m not thinking about major 6 or diminished 7, seems a bit complicated and I just don’t understand what those have to do with a bebop scale.
 
Wish someone had had the foresight to do that for me sooner.
Rather like the OP then. She’s voicing her concerns now, and is going to run them by her teacher. Perhaps you can be happy for that as it must remind you of yourself all those years ago.

Your goals are not everyone’s goals. Other people do learn in different ways. I went a long way in classical clarinet. I loved playing chamber music and miss it very much since deciding against a career in classical music in favour of pop/jazz.
My jazz/improvisation learning, from a young age, was self-taught and also a “blind leading the blind” with a few mates. I don’t regret the classical stuff - it’s still relevant to me as it made me the musician I am (and it’s good stuff) - someone who can dip a decent enough toe in most musical styles - which I’m more than ok with as I’d get bored with one style of music.

If asked, we can inform on what did or didn’t work for us, what we think might be better ways to absorb knowledge more quickly or effectively. Our way might not always be the best way, or perhaps just not the best way for everyone.
 
More time is always fine, and listening is also really important too - listening can be a practise session!

You sound like you have all the right things going on, so just go at the tempo you feel is right; bring it up with your teacher and say if you feel there's too much too soon and so on.

I'm currently having lessons... but at a frequency of 1 every 6 months at the moment. There's more than enough in each one of the sessions I have to keep me busy for months!
I was having weekly lessons, but I feel I could get on ok by myself and have a lesson once a month.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,429
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom