Playing the saxophone Is it me or my saxophone?

Should be able to manage without the sax then !
Yes. Another saxophone player asked me: "Why are playing the saxophone? You are playing for sax as it was a guitar." !!!! He was in a way right. I pick up lots of ideas from guitarists. But playing the saxophone I can use my lungs better. And it's fun to play power sax.
 
Yes. Another saxophone player asked me: "Why are playing the saxophone? You are playing for sax as it was a guitar." !!!! He was in a way right. I pick up lots of ideas from guitarists. But playing the saxophone I can use my lungs better. And it's fun to play power sax.
In the jazz world there is a lot of back and forth between guitarists and saxophonists. Stealing each others’ licks. So you are firmly in the tradition!
 
It’s great that OP is looking for and trying out advice given here by our very knowledgeable members, I’ve been following this thread since inception, and my impression is that she is not learning by practice but by others’ experiences. A B5 is a decent mpc but won’t give the sound that a beginner expects in his audio memory, since we’ve all been there, and want to hear our favourite players’ sound come out of our sax before we can even sound like a decent player. And now going up in reed strength means she’ll have less control over her sound notwithstanding that she might very well damage her embouchure if it’s too hard for her. Not sure if I’m making sense to y’all. I’m speaking from personal experience having spent years learning by myself with books and online videos and falling in every pit and bad habit that the beginner falls into. In the end what worked for me was a good midpriced mpc going slowly from a 1.5 to a 2.5 to attain my best sound and lots and lots of practice, in my case over 5 years of daily practice, probably would have been less with a good teacher to point out the mistakes. Every player has their own journey, but imo a lot of practice gets us all to the same meeting point. So keep all that’s been written here in mind and …..practice.
 
What do people think of the advice to get reeds slightly harder than you like (for example if you like a 2 get a 2.5) because some in a box will be soft and some that are harder you can adjust down (but not up)?
Not much. If a reed is too hard, work on it with sandpapaer or reed rush or a knife or a reed geek or .. It’s too soft, clip it.

I work on EVERY reed I play, I adjust them for balance, and also as above if they are too hard or soft. I want all my reeds to play more or less the same, they are different enough tonally as it is.
 
I'm totally the opposite, never worked on any reed, play them as they come.
Many do of course. Somewhat depends upon the gig you’re doing. If you’re semi-orchestral or show then you could be asked for pp at either end of the instrument and then full on jazzing or rock n roll type playing. Hard with a reed that isn’t helpful.
 
A hard reed you can sand down, a soft reed you can clip if you have to but I prefer to play it until it quickly dies and chuck it. A dull reed is a vexation to the spirit, there's nothing wrong with it but it sounds awful and drains you. To chuck or not to chuck? That is the question.
 
What do people think of the advice to get reeds slightly harder than you like (for example if you like a 2 get a 2.5) because some in a box will be soft and some that are harder you can adjust down (but not up)?
By playing on soft reeds all reeds in a box are within the comfort zone, The only adjustment I do is for balance. No problems with fortissimo or pianissimo. You can choose to play on harder reeds but than you are always on the edge of your comfort zone.
 
I am not a fan of hard reeds, even for beginners.
Yeah switching to a 2.5 Rico from a 3 really helped me. Used to use Vandoren and never had any problems before (at least not sound wise, but a 3 was pushing it for jaw fatigue) but for some reason I was not getting a very consistent sound on my new mouthpiece with those. I switched to Rico and the problem was pretty much fixed, no idea why as I believe Vandoren is good quality as well. Maybe just not so good for my new set-up.

Then I went down to a 2.5, and of course rico being softer too it meant I could have a MUCH longer session. Made all the difference. I was struggling before (as I've documented) and would often have to stop mid-song for various reasons (to adjust something or take a break) but now I'm good for an hour plus. I was stubbornly sticking to a 3 for a long time and it was probably a bad idea. Just need to record myself again, what sounds ok to the ears doesn't always translate to a recording as I'm sure we all know. I'm just glad not to have to constantly fiddle about adjusting stuff all the time and get down to a good playing session. I'm not budging from my set-up now 😀
 
By playing on soft reeds all reeds in a box are within the comfort zone, The only adjustment I do is for balance. No problems with fortissimo or pianissimo. You can choose to play on harder reeds but than you are always on the edge of your comfort zone.
To play a too soft reed is out of my comfort zone as well.
 
Not much. If a reed is too hard, work on it with sandpapaer or reed rush or a knife or a reed geek or .. It’s too soft, clip it.

I work on EVERY reed I play, I adjust them for balance, and also as above if they are too hard or soft. I want all my reeds to play more or less the same, they are different enough tonally as it is.
The first thing I do with a reed, which is not playing well, is to work the downside of the reed on a wet stone. All kind of wood have tension.

I play plasticover on tenor and they are great reeds for rock on a mouthpiece that is also good for rock. To play bari means softer reeds and less pressure for me. I seldom play in higher register on bari.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom