Saxophone beginners Involuntary high octave notes

Hello all, just an update.

I've been a bit busy with work lately and I'm currently in Barcelona and enjoying the warmth for a few days! but since my last post I have had chance to practice a little more and it seems that the involuntary high notes are gradually disappearing. I still get them, and mainly at the start of practice but after a few minutes of practising scales etc I can hit the lower notes without a hint of upper octave no problem.

I am still going to try a better mouthpiece as the one I have is the one that came with it and I'm not convinced it's helping me much at all. I haven't forgotten about your offer Martin but time has been limited for me lately! I am going to sax.co.uk next Wednesday though as I'm in a meeting down that way on Mon/Tues, however, if that goes pearshaped like it did last week I'll be knocking on your door!

I've noticed that another thread has appeared from Buzby who also seems to have come to the same problem I am having, so I'm glad I'm not the only one!

Will keep you posted after trying some other mouthpieces next week, although I am listening to you guys who recommend not to do this at my early stage of learning, I'll probably just end up getting one that is good for beginners like the Yamaha.
 
Hi Jason

Its not just you and Buzby Jason, every beginner has these problems, Me too, it just becomes less and less with time and practice. I get caught out still and i'll bet almost everyone here does occasionally. The offer is there if you change your mind, I don't use the 4C any more, but may again one day. meanwhile I wouldn't miss it for a week or two.

I'm working around Kent Tuesday and Wednesday too πŸ™‚
 
Ok, I managed to get to Sax.co.uk, just as the snow was starting to settle!

I tried 4 or 5 mpcs, of which I cannot remember all of the exact models now but there was a Selmer, Vandoren, Yamaha, Otto and Meyer that I tried. A couple of these were very difficult to blow so they went out of the window straight away! The others seemed very similar to what I already had, but I guess this is just because I'm not that good or experienced yet, however, the Meyer seemed great, it sounded slightly different which I liked and it was very easy to blow, so I went with this one.

It happened to be the most expensive at Β£130 which always happens to me when I like something! but I'm not too worried about the costs as I don't spend my money on much else. The exact model I bought was a Meyer No.6 medium chamber, medium facing length.

I'm not sure if it's going to cure my problem and infact I'm pretty sure now that it has nothing to do with the mpc and is just me! I had a practice while at my hotel this week and this problem was getting on my nerves big time, no matter what I did I couldn't stop hitting the high notes involuntary, however, while at sax.co.uk today I played perfectly without this problem, even when using my own mpc! I guess it could be when I'm tired that I have this problem as I have been worse lately and I've missed a couple of nights sleep with travelling.

I also bought a reed pack which contains Rico and Vandoren reeds of different types, I will give all these a go at my next practice to see I prefer another type.

I must say there are some nice looking saxes at that shop, I tried a Yanagisawa Alto which was worth about Β£1600, more than double the price of mine and it did feel much more well made, however, when I had a play on it it sounded the same as mine! I didn't bother playing any others as I guessed that with me not being that good yet they would all sound the same.

I also felt a little better after hearing one of the guys that works there having a practice and he was getting a few squeaks on some notes and having problems resolving it, I guess he was trying a new sax out but at least I wasn't the only one squeaking in the shop!

Jason
 
That's brilliant, I hope it works for you. Sometimes just changing the read can appear to make all the problems go away, but I think it's because in my mind you want it to, and sure, i agree with being tired. I'm sure that is a factor.

We should compare work diaries, I thought i was the only sad service engineer practising in hotel rooms.. πŸ™‚))
 
Just a thought...squeaks can often result from your not having your reed on 'just right'.

It's the first thing I check if I suddenly get squeaks.
(They are quite frequent atm with my new tenor, new mpc & new reeds!!)
 
Hi Jason
Im also new to alto sax, learning for about 7 months.
I had the same problem, but found after a few weeks that it was far less frequent, as my emboucher improved and I seemed to be able to stop it happening.
I too then purchased a new mouthpeice (E.Rousseau JDX 5) and moved to a 2 1/2 reed and not only does it give a much better sound, I dont squeak (or very rarely) and I can easily hit high D, E and F, something I just couldn't do before.

So I guess what Im trying to say ( from my limited experience) is that time and practice will probably cure the problem and especially now you have a mouthpeice you feel comfortable with.
Will be interesting to hear how the new mouthpeice improves your playing.
 
That's brilliant, I hope it works for you. Sometimes just changing the read can appear to make all the problems go away, but I think it's because in my mind you want it to, and sure, i agree with being tired. I'm sure that is a factor.

We should compare work diaries, I thought i was the only sad service engineer practising in hotel rooms.. πŸ™‚))

Yes I'm sure psychology comes into it somewhere but if it helps then I'm happy! No your not the only saddo! work is a nightmare for me at the moment and will be up until about mid Feb, hopefully then I can get some proper practice in.

Just a thought...squeaks can often result from your not having your reed on 'just right'.

It's the first thing I check if I suddenly get squeaks.
(They are quite frequent atm with my new tenor, new mpc & new reeds!!)

Believe me, I check the reed a hundred times but its always in the right place! that's what makes it more frustrating as I'm hoping to find something wrong with the sax which is causing my problem, yet the finger is pointing at me more and more! oh also, I don't really get a problem with squeaks at all, its just that the lower notes jump into the higher octave notes.

So I guess what Im trying to say ( from my limited experience) is that time and practice will probably cure the problem and especially now you have a mouthpeice you feel comfortable with.
Will be interesting to hear how the new mouthpeice improves your playing.

Yes I'm pretty sure your right! and as mentioned above, I'm hoping to able to practice a lot more come mid Feb, I will keep you all posted on my progress anyway, although I guess most of the experienced players are bored of threads by now!

Cheers
Jason
 
Ok, having had a quick practice before I get back to work, I think I have found my problem.

I have a new mpc as you know which I'm now going to use from now on, I also bought a pack of different reeds of different types ranging from 1.5 to 2.5. Having tried all the reeds it seems that the 2.5 reed has virtually eliminated my problem! I do find it a little harder to blow but it's not impossible, I reckon a few more hours on it and I will be playing normal through it again like I was on the 1.5.

As a double check, straight after using a 2.5 reed, I put my old mpc back on with my 1.5 strength reed and the problem came back instantly. I then realised that my embouchure was quite strong so I loosened my mouth a lot to compensate and get the low notes but found that my mouth had to be so loose that air was escaping from the corners of my mouth.

I have tried strength 2 reeds before now but I never noticed any difference at all, maybe it was a dodgy one? as I would have thought this would have improved my problem slightly. I also have some Vandorens which are strength 2 which are similar to the 2.5 Rico Royal so these should be ok to use also as they are supposed to be 0.5 higher than the Ricos (from what I have read on here).

I'm glad I have found the problem, I was getting worried that I wouldn't be able to correct this problem. I did not think of increasing the strength before for some reason but I'm sure glad I tried it now!

Jason
 
I've tried various reeds myself settling on a Rico 3 with the 4C but when I bought the 5C I thought to go back to a 2, God I struggled at first, it was as if every reed was faulty. Yesterday I bought some Rico 2 plastic coated reeds and WOW, does that play nice. I think I get my reeds too wet, that's why after two days using the plastic coated I think I'm converted. It doesn't change when wet or dry. :welldone
 
I think you've got it Jason.
There are so many factors at play simultaneously.
Embouchure, reed, mouthpiece, ligature, confidence, mood etc.

A bloke at work that I'm helping has just bought a Rovner style ligature and he sounds so much better.
The higher notes have lost that thin, strained sound and the lower notes are rich and full, as well as being easy for him to hit.
I asked him for his lowest note (without taking a run down to it) and he played a respectable Bb. And this is on a Yamaha 4C mouthpiece.

He had borrowed my Meyer, but gave it back preferring his Yamaha.
Horses for courses!
 
Hello Jason
I also have a trevor james alto and the mouthpiece that they come with is awful - the first piece of advice my teacher gave me to was change it! I now play with a Selmer S80 C* mouthpiece, a rovner dark lig and la voz medium reeds, which has sorted out all the squeaks so far. It does take time to build your embouchure, it is the same as doing any exercise for the first time - you are using muscles that you haven't used much before - they take time to get used to it and strengthen. They will get there!

I started playing nearly a year ago, had only played the recorder before & couldn't sight read at all - now things are getting easier at last! (still rubbish at sight reading though!)

Good luck
Emma
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom