Saxophones In a dilemma on a new saxophone...

- Firstly, I don't believe at all that all saxophones sound alike.
You're right and it's not a belief - it's a fact - They don't.
They're built out've at least 500 different parts, from pads to screws to rods to bits of felt and cork and then you stick a mouthpiece on the narrow end with a piece of dried grass attached and then a Homo-Sapien blows in the narrow end.
I bought my present tenor about 20 years ago - I tried 5 supposedly "identical" models and none of 'em hit the spot. It was only two weeks later that my dealer found one in his warehouse and that was and still is "my horn".
A couple a years ago I went to a Thelma 😉 presentation and was confonted with a showroom full of horns, that's 3 walls stacked 3 high with horns. So the rep was of course eager to sell me so I tried practically every alto in the room and there was only one that I would have considered. The rep's smile soon turned sour when I told him sorry but I'm not looking for a horn at the moment. They'd sent me a personal invite to come to the event so I went along out've curiosity.
But for me it just goes to show that the tolerances involved in building a curly tubed blows-a-phone are such that even a slight difference in set-up will have an enormous effect on the sound characteristics that we as players perceive.
 
Have you tried the TJ signature RAW, the non-laquered one? I'd had various tenors before but the RAW taught me to play because it came perfectly set-up. I've had it for nearly 8 years and I still love it for the way it plays. The downsides to the RAW are, not everyone likes its appearance, particularly now it's aged and, because it's light in weight (a plus-point for some) it's easily damaged. For this reason I've stopped taking it to pubs; I now have a sturdier Yamaha for that sort of thing, but the TJ is the one I enjoy more.
 
Have you tried the TJ signature RAW, the non-laquered one? I'd had various tenors before but the RAW taught me to play because it came perfectly set-up. I've had it for nearly 8 years and I still love it for the way it plays. The downsides to the RAW are, not everyone likes its appearance, particularly now it's aged and, because it's light in weight (a plus-point for some) it's easily damaged. For this reason I've stopped taking it to pubs; I now have a sturdier Yamaha for that sort of thing, but the TJ is the one I enjoy more.

I have, I tried their signature RAW. I haven't tried the 88 and SR. The shop I went to said they will not be bringing in any 88, and the only SR they are bringing in is the Phosphor Bronze version. The stock will come in a couple of weeks later. I'll give it a test run before making a decision.
 
Better than swapping for TJ classic huh? :thumbs: Now go get the horn you want and have lots of fun!

Well yeah but...for a moment I had second thoughts about selling my 'grandma'...I hope she's in a better place right now. I'm sorry I suck...when I'm supposed to blow. =(

Now I have more money for an SR, or if there's a need to, I can top up a bit more for the Signature. I tried the Raw Signature the first time I was there, I didn't really liked it as much as the classic. But I haven't tried the SR yet, they'll be bringing in the SR...so I'll only be able to test it once it arrives.
 
ow I have more money for an SR, or if there's a need to, I can top up a bit more for the Signature. I tried the Raw Signature the first time I was there, I didn't really liked it as much as the classic. But I haven't tried the SR yet, they'll be bringing in the SR...so I'll only be able to test it once it arrives.

Something tells me you have your eyes and ears set for that black and silver....
 
Something tells me you have your eyes and ears set for that black and silver....
I'm giving the SR a chance before I make my final decision. But for now, possibly...yes, the black and silver. There's no turning back now because I'm all outta sax. (I only have 1 sax and since my JK was sold suddenly...it was perhaps a sign)

Get a harmonica, give up sax😉
Nuh uh! But yeah, that's funny! Everyone needs sax!
 
10 years ago I had to playtest a shipment of about 40 BW alto's and tenors. While they all played reasonably well (some needed some tweaks after shipping) and sounded pretty similar, I was amazed at the differences between the same models. Lots of other threads on this lead me to believe this is so with all manufacturers.

My 2 sml Gold Medal 1 tenors are only 400 serial numbers apart yet one is a good horn and the other is simply magic. Go figure
 
What a predicament to be in "Saxless In Singapore" - Little Walter Jacobs called the harmonica the "Mississippi Saxophone" maybe you can buy a bamboo flute and call it the "Singapore Sax"...🙂

When and if you are to buy another saxophone try as many different brands as possible, before deciding...

Greg S.

Saxless in Singapore, hah! Sounds like a miserable love story about an aspiring musician whose love of his life left him for a man with a more stable income...

Incidentally, I do have a bamboo flute (the dizi) which I play for fun.

I'll give as many ones (within my budget too) a try and see how it goes.
 
Saxless in Singapore, hah! Sounds like a miserable love story about an aspiring musician whose love of his life left him for a man with a more stable income...

Incidentally, I do have a bamboo flute (the dizi) which I play for fun.

I'll give as many ones (within my budget too) a try and see how it goes.
A stable income? He must be a race horse breeder.
 
I'm just waiting for them to get back to me when the stock for both the SR and the Classic arrives. For sure, I didn't really enjoy the RAW at the moment. I would however, like to highlight that at the point of testing, it was with my current mouthpiece. I wouldn't ignore the possibility that the RAW would excel if I had another mouthpiece. Until then, I'll just wait...

Part of me believes that it was a sign that my JK was sold...but part of me thinks that I'd like to hold onto that JK. We'll see how it goes, won't we? Either way, I do know that I will have some time before that to test the different saxophones to see which one I really like.

I've rounded down to a couple of choices and I was hoping that y'all would be able to offer me some opinions...

Yamaha 62
Trevor James Classic
Trevor James SR (Phosphor Bronze specifically)
Yamaha 280
Yanagisawa AW01

Or if you have any advice? I'm saxless now so any advice goes. Thanks in advance!
 
...I would however, like to highlight that at the point of testing, it was with my current mouthpiece. I wouldn't ignore the possibility that the RAW would excel if I had another mouthpiece. Until then, I'll just wait...

Ahm, no! If your mouthpiece gives you the basic sound you want, that should at least reveal the sound concept of the respective horn. How will you ever know what mouthpiece will fit your "horn to be owned"? I guess it is a nightmare. The scientific recommendation would be change only one factor at a time unless you do a Design of Exeriment with the help of your statistician. Testing an unknown horn with a mouthpiece that is new to you with reeds that might react different to that mouthpiece vs. your usual mouthpiece is not a wise decision. May it was only the specfic sample of the TJ SC or maybe it is simply not your horn.

Alphorn
 
If you like something on the brighter side yani makes a nice alto. I dont recall which model Ive seen but it has a lively sweet and zippy tone. At the same time it holds a nice core.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,538
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom