Saxophones In a dilemma on a new saxophone...

Just wondering. Which mouthpiece did you try the TJ with? And did you try it on the JK?

Funny thing... Every time I try a new mouthpiece it sounds different. But after a while I sound the same as I did before. Same with horns. So if you swap, don't be too surprised if the problems come back with the new horn.

One thing about the TJ Vs Keilwerth - if the TJ is new/well setup it's going to be better founding and easier to play than an sax that needs a proper setup. I seem to remember that you had a lot of work done on the JK when you bought it. Maybe it needs some more work.

How are the exams going, btw?
 
You always end up sounding like you. Sometimes more you and sometimes easier you, but always you. Chasing a sound may be more to do with what you play than what you play it on. It's all about the music. A tune you hate on a horn you like is still a tune you hate 😉
 
I'd very strongly advise you to hang on to the Keilwerth.

Sure, it tends to have a darker approach than many other horns - but I suspect the 'wow' factor you're getting from the TJ is due to how well the TJ is working...and how less well the JK is.
But the important thing to consider is that what you got out of the TJ is pretty much all you're likely to get. With some practice, and some time getting used to the horn, you'll perhaps get a little bit more...but the JK is a vastly more capable and versatile horn.
That's not to say that players never trade in an expensive horn for a cheaper one - but it's rare.

My advice would be to spend the money on having the JK overhauled.
I've played quite a few 90R altos, and while they're not quite my cup of tea there's absoutely no doubt that they're top quality horns that compete on every level with the likes of Yamaha, Yanagisawa and Selmer (etc.).. Horns like this have a 'certain something' that you rarely get from budget models, the chief of which is that they're capable to taking you far beyond the standard you're playing at presently.
And if the worst came to the worst and you decide that you really can't get along with the JK, it'll be far more saleable...and you might even be able to to swap it for another horn of similar quality.
 
It's a great place to discuss it.

This may be the problem, two years with the same set up and you might have got there. I've spent time on and off chasing my sound by changing things but really what I should have done was kept it all the same once I got a good horn and concentrated on improving my tone through more playing. Which I am now doing 🙂

I've lost count of the number of times I've read it's the player that has the biggest influence on sound and sax is usually at the bottom of the list after mouthpieces and reeds........

Jx

Yup. If you gave 10 randomly-selected beginners on the saxophone a "killer" assortment of top-flight modern and vintage pro-grade dream-machines e.g. Selmer Mk VI, Conn 26M, King Super 20 Silversonic, Yanagisawa AWO37 (solid silver!), Martin Committee, Buescher 400, Holton Stratodyne, Inderbinen or Yamaha 875EX Custom - complete with snake-oil cryotreatment etc, then chances are (and let's be diplomatic here) that they'd probably sound reasonably OK - but not exactly superb.

However, give a professional player (whether it's Jay Beckenstein from Spyro Gyra, Dave Sanborn, Tom Scott or "Bird" etc) a humble Yamaha YAS-23, or Trevor James "The Horn" or Conn 14 "Shooting Stars" - and chances are they'd blow those beginners out of the water. They wouldn't just be better on technique, they'd also create a better sound. This is not meaning any disrespect to beginners on the saxophone because everyone's got to start somewhere. It's simply that for pro-players, playing the saxophone is a full-time job. It's what they do to earn a living, so they have to be damned good at it in order to get hired - whether that's working as a session musician in the studio or performing to an audience up on-stage - whether that's a regular Friday night gig in a medium-sized city, or being part of the horn section touring with a mega-group across 15 different countries in Europe.

Having the best gear won't automatically make you a good player with the sound you want. The saxophone and mouthpiece are only about 50% of the equation. You have to put the hours in and work on your "chops". The secret is practice, practice and practice. There aren't enough hours in the day to do sufficient practice. I practice as much as I can, but inevitably life gets in the way (get pulled away by family commitments) which frustrates my plans. As a result, I don't practice as much as I should, despite my best efforts.
 
Last edited:
You always end up sounding like you. Sometimes more you and sometimes easier you, but always you. Chasing a sound may be more to do with what you play than what you play it on. It's all about the music. A tune you hate on a horn you like is still a tune you hate 😉

+1 on this. You'll always sound like yourself. The essential "core" characteristics of your sound don't really change because they are related to the internal physical attributes of your dentition and mouth-shape e.g the length, width and height of your maxilla:-

Image of Maxilla (everyone is different)

The only exception would be if you changed to a really weird mouthpiece design. For example, I once borrowed a Beechler S6S alto mouthpiece - it's the one with a small-chamber. It was the loudest mouthpiece I've ever played and would practically burn the paint off a fence at 20 paces. It was so loud that (and I'm not kidding here!) it actually gave me headaches, even though I wasn't playing louder than mezzoforte. Needless to say after a few days I gave it back ASAP. Now I play mainly Yanis, Selmers and Lawton mouthpieces on alto - depending on the mood. Sometimes when I want to "slum it" I'll play a Rico Metalite (which has a baffle) - but even that is a pussycat when compared to the Beechler S6S. I still shudder when I remember that Beechler...
 
Last edited:
Personally I don't accept the argument that the saxophone doesn't matter much because the player will always sound like themselves.

I do believe that the player has more influence on the sound more than the saxophone does. In that sense, I will always sound like me. But that doesn't mean that there is no difference between one sax and another from an individual player's point of view.

- Firstly, I don't believe at all that all saxophones sound alike.

- Secondly, whether other people can hear any noticeable difference in the sound is not the only thing that matters. If the player perceives a difference in sound between two instruments, then there is a difference.

- But thirdly, and more importantly, sound is not the only thing that matters. I have played saxophones that I have liked and ones that I didn't like. As an amateur, what matters to me in the end is whether I feel happy when I play the instrument.
 
There is one more thing besides Sound. How does the instrument fit your hand? I like the sound of JK SX90R horns but I am not willing to cope with their more spread position of pearls. While the alto is ok my short pinky misses the Eb/C keys every time. So some of the preference of the TJ might come from a differnet feel as well. Personally I wouldn't swap the JK for a TJ Classic.

Alphorn
 
If you want to flick the JK in favour of a TJ get one of the Custom Signature Series saxes. You might be able to import one from the UK - sax.co.uk come to mind or closer to Singapore may be try one of the big horn shops in Aussie - Parramatta Road in Sydney or there is a big horn shop in Melbourne if you can't get one in Singapore.

Greg S. .
 
As Bob from Curly Woodwind would say:
long tones.webp
 
Lots of good advice so far. I don't know anything about either sax, except that JK is considered a good brand, at least in Europe. Don't know anything about TJ., Two things I'd like to add to this thread (if you haven't already done so) are:
- take your time comparing the sound/feel of the JK and TJ with the same mpc/reed in different room sizes; shops often have small padded tryout rooms but its good to compare both saxes in the larger shop too; if you have the opportunity to borrow/rent it for a month with the option of buying, take it.
- take someone along with you to the shop who has a good ear for tone and ask for his/her opinion on the tonal difference when you play the 2 saxes

I do realise that sometimes, you're just ready for something new/different/better. Have a look on E-bay. There are 3 used SX 90R altos advertised for an asking price of between $ 3000 and $4500. The shipping costs to Europe (where the JK brand is perhaps better known) is about $80

Mike.
 
Just wondering. Which mouthpiece did you try the TJ with? And did you try it on the JK?

Funny thing... Every time I try a new mouthpiece it sounds different. But after a while I sound the same as I did before. Same with horns. So if you swap, don't be too surprised if the problems come back with the new horn.

One thing about the TJ Vs Keilwerth - if the TJ is new/well setup it's going to be better founding and easier to play than an sax that needs a proper setup. I seem to remember that you had a lot of work done on the JK when you bought it. Maybe it needs some more work.

How are the exams going, btw?

Same mouthpiece was used for both the TJ and my JK. I have no idea what's a Supreme Metal Mouthpiece but it was the mouthpiece that I bought from a man named Ivan, who makes mouthpieces. He didn't make the Supreme Mouthpiece, he just had it in his collection and told me to try it. I tried it and I liked the tone I'm getting (not the tone I want, but the tone I'm getting), and it was about a year ago or so when I got it and I've used it ever since. I've used this same mouthpiece on the TJ as well. It seems to go pretty well, brighter, more focused and warmer.

The JK is a generally dark sounding horn, large bell and everything. The work that was done, was already done. Unless I'm missing out something. It's just...dark. I've tried playing my classmate's 62, same mouthpiece just different sax, there is a difference.

I'm still contemplating, and what most of you said does make a lot of sense. There's actually a buyer who is keen at the price of $1,400 for the JK but I'm just getting him to drop by to test it. Honestly, I feel that "I'm not that good at all, why do I even want a Pro Model horn?" but it also made a lot of sense that, "if I get there one day, I don't have to upgrade my horn". It's just the sound/tone...I don't think it is a placebo effect either because I can hear the difference.

What I know I'm probably not going to do now is to trade it in and topping up with $800. Instead, I'm gonna see if someone would cherish the JK and buy it off at $1,400, then I'll keep the money meanwhile and playtest the different saxophone and see if I can find something that resonates with me.

I really appreciate all the feedbacks because it really did got my thinking process going.
 
You you want a pro horn because if you dont sound good yet, you will sound less bad on quality gear. Plus you already have a pro horn. Would you trade in a pair of comfortable, high quality, leather shoes for a pair of cheap plastc shoes simply because you are not a professional walker? They are your damn shoes 🙂
 
You you want a pro horn because if you dont sound good yet, you will sound less bad on quality gear. Plus you already have a pro horn. Would you trade in a pair of comfortable, high quality, leather shoes for a pair of cheap plastc shoes simply because you are not a professional walker? They are your damn shoes 🙂

I like your analogy. Not exactly in that sense. It's just that, "I've been using these pair of leather shoes that don't feel comfortable". High quality, definitely. Comfortable...not really. So I've been walking in pain for 2 years in these shoes and it is probably time to change it, or at least get a new pair that feels comfortable.

Right now, what I'm planning to do after much consideration would be to...buy the TJ but not by selling off my JK.

As for my JK, I'll put it up for sale. To be honest, I'm not sure how much it is worth. I actually tried to ask for $2,000 on the FB Saxophone Marketplace and people actually texted to ask me about it.
 
If it feels right for you, then do it !

Although a brighter mouthpiece/reed would be a cheaper option 😛

Hahaha, I have, I really did try different mouthpieces before concluding anything.

I tried reeds, different sizes, different brand, different types. I changed ligature, leather, metal, etc. Then mouthpieces after mouthpieces.

I'll probably not sell the JK...I don't know yet.
 
it's clear that you're not happy with the Keilwerth and there's no point playing an instrument that you're not happy with so a change to something that you feel more satisfied with isn't a bad idea.
If you've tried every sax you can find and still the TJ is the one you want, then go for it if it feels like it's the one. An older musicna once told me "never buy an instrument unless it feels like it's yours" and there's a good deal of wisdom in that.
I'm happy playing a student Martin Indiana, I've tried a lot of other altos, but this is the one that I can get the most out of, I wouldn't swap it for a brand new Selmer, but that's my personal preference.
Everyone has different tastes, finding what's best for you is part of the journey - good luck!
 
Now! About the TJ! It would have been a TJ Classic Black/Silver which I picked. I've tried the silver, the gold and the black/silver. I really liked the sound of the black/silver. Here's the link...Trevor James saxophone - TJ 'Horn' Classic

I don't know what I should do. Dear saxophone players...please advice me! =(
It's black and silver - buy it, although it won't be as good as my black and silver Hanson.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,525
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom