spike
Old Indian
- Messages
- 3,414
- Location
- Half way up a hill
You're right and it's not a belief - it's a fact - They don't.- Firstly, I don't believe at all that all saxophones sound alike.
They're built out've at least 500 different parts, from pads to screws to rods to bits of felt and cork and then you stick a mouthpiece on the narrow end with a piece of dried grass attached and then a Homo-Sapien blows in the narrow end.
I bought my present tenor about 20 years ago - I tried 5 supposedly "identical" models and none of 'em hit the spot. It was only two weeks later that my dealer found one in his warehouse and that was and still is "my horn".
A couple a years ago I went to a Thelma 😉 presentation and was confonted with a showroom full of horns, that's 3 walls stacked 3 high with horns. So the rep was of course eager to sell me so I tried practically every alto in the room and there was only one that I would have considered. The rep's smile soon turned sour when I told him sorry but I'm not looking for a horn at the moment. They'd sent me a personal invite to come to the event so I went along out've curiosity.
But for me it just goes to show that the tolerances involved in building a curly tubed blows-a-phone are such that even a slight difference in set-up will have an enormous effect on the sound characteristics that we as players perceive.
