Introduction Hi, I'm Alan...

alanp

Member
Messages
10
I was a bit of a rock'n'roll guitarist in my yoof... (but that was ages ago)...

I decided I needed to prove to my precocious daughter (9 years old, playing piano for 2 years, and just taking grade 7! Almost that advanced on cello (18 months), and Oboe, (12 months)), that her ability was *genetic* 🙂 ... And to prove to her mother that it was my fault, not hers >:)

I got a Yamaha clarinet (YCL450) from ebay at end of November - I'm doing ok (had a few lessons from daughter's oboe teacher) - but my calloused finger tips (still messed up after all these years) have a problem covering the (open) holes reliably (ok, that's my story...) I'm learning to read at last!

Always fancied sax, and felt that my finger problems (sic) would not affect me so much - so scored a YAS-23 in vgc from the same "devils junkyard"... Ok, keys are easier than holes, octaves are easier than the clarinet's 18-semitone hike from it's register key, but as y'all know, sax has some unique challenges...

... but I'm loving it!

Current issues: getting tone production even half reasonable (ok, I think I know what I need to be doing there - for the moment at least)

The part that is currently needling me, is as follows: The sax came with the usual Yam m/p (don't recall the number as I sit here) - and with that, the bottom two notes both need a fairly committed airstream to cause them to sing - and then boy are they loud...

After some fairly extensive lurking here, I saw opinions that a standard Yani m/p would go really quiet. Back to the junkyard, and got one in a 5 - and yes it does play both loud and quiet (so a chance of practicing without mutiny from the family and neighbours!!!)

However, the aforesaid two low notes are now really keen to overtone an octave as I blow them. I can get the right notes, but it's tricky, and not too reliable...

I'm using RJS 2s as they seem just about right for me at the moment - or at least, AFAIAA, everything else about them seems to be about as good as it gets for me... I do have some Java 2, but I don't like them as much - they seem a bit 'louder', and I'm not sure they are at all better in respect of the inadventent octave jumps...

I also got a Vandoren V5 A25 m/p (for a song) - as far as I can tell right now, that is roughly the same as the Yamaha piece. Also a Meyer 6M that is promising, but too much for my chops right now...

Yes - just started, and suffering from GAS already (ok - that affliction is not unique to Sax)

...any pointers folks??? (I'm sure persistence and practice is a big part of it - and I'll see my daughter's teacher this weekend - but I'd be grateful for any opinions to a real tyro right here...)

TIA, Alan
 
Hi Alan and welcome to the Breakfastroom.

I think you should get your horn cjecked for leaks, both the stock Yamaha and Yanagisaw should be fine for low notes. Also get a teacher to check that you are playing the low notes properly.
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
Hi Alan and welcome to the Breakfastroom.

I think you should get your horn czeched 🙂P) for leaks, both the stock Yamaha and Yanagisaw should be fine for low notes. Also get a teacher to check that you are playing the low notes properly.

Thanks Pete.

I did the cigarette-paper trick already, and already found a little bit of a leak on the pad right on the bend of the bow (is that the 'C' - I don't have the horn with me right now). A little "refinement" seems to have corrected that, and certainly improved it (it doesn't further improve now if I add any kind of extra pressure directly to the pad).

What I'll do next then, is to sort out a way of dangling a small light-bulb into the bell, to see if anything else is leaky, or whether there is anything more subtle going on that I can't find with paper...

... if anything more subtle does appear, I'll take it to "a man who knows"... I'll certainly be pleased if my "unintentional octave" problem is with the horn, and not with me (or my setup, which otherwise seems to be working for me...)

Apart from that, I'll talk to my "man" on Saturday...

Alan
 
Usually a cigarette paper if used correctly (very light pressure while you test all round the pad) reveals more than a leak light IMO.
 
Welcome Alan.
Wonder if the old adage 'Spare the rod, spoil the child' was ignored? 🙂
Best advice is to get her to sign you for eternity as her manager.
 
Well, the V5 seems just a little better than the standard Yamaha piece. However, I'm certain that my perception is a bit of a blunt instrument right now...

The one I really like (so far) is the Yani, I've gone back to comparing them several times, and keep ending up with the Yani. I'm still getting this tendency to go to the octaves on the bottom notes though... but I'm guessing its me...

... still, my daughter's oboe teacher comes on sunday, and sax was his second study... I'll see what he says...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,272
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom