Saxophones Has the internet changed players’ attitudes around saxophones and saxophone playing.

@skeller047 this is my point, I've a good understanding of the theory/logic behind all of that... but the practicalities are different.

Playing with the orchestra is fine, with a conductor & percussion, but if it comes to a solo suddenly it can become quite lonely and exposed.

Same with a metronome, fine putting notes on the beat, but I struggle with Syncopation, and keeping off the beat. It's developing the internal feel of where the beat is, and being able to place the note in the correct place.

I've yet to see any 'you tube' video that goes into any real depth on how to achieve that, my teacher has and this is the biggest challenge I'm currently facing with my playing.

Similarly the player who can recite various scales, and theory surrounding them, but can't implement that knowledge for example improvising.
Knowing the tune well and humming/playing along with favourite solos helps me a lot.
 
Knowing the tune well and humming/playing along with favourite solos helps me a lot.
Without venturing too far off topic - My last lesson my teacher flicked through one of the early exercise books we worked through, picked a random exercise, and told me to clap the beat and sing the rhythm.

Starting with the first bar, and even then only the first two beats, getting the 'beats' on the clap before introducing the syncopation onto the 2nd beat. Repeat, repeat, repeat, before then introducing the next note, then the next note.

It was painfully slow going, but the beat & rhythm became solid. It's quite good fun (and equally frustrating) doing it with unknown pieces, and sussing out the rhythm, without even touching the saxophone.

My teacher has advised me (more than once) to practice my rhythm separately to playing the saxophone, he assures me there's only so many rhythms you can make with the notes available. His analogy like learning to read, as a child reading C-A-T, Cat, the suddenly we can read Cat, Bat, Fat, Mat, without having to spell each one out.

It sounds like some illusive state of nirvana at the moment, but his own experience was being equally as bad at reading music as I am, but after spending a stint teaching school children music, and teaching rhythms like this day in, day out, his reading vastly improved. A fluke perhaps, except the Bari player I play alongside spent years teaching children music, and is excellent at reading rhythms, so maybe there something in it?

Back to the OP - Watching a video on YouTube, or reading this forum for hours on end, may give you the knowledge, but not the skills to play. The same can be said about any task, from plastering to Bricklaying, there's a vast difference between knowing how to do it, and being able to do it.
 
Back to the OP - Watching a video on YouTube, or reading this forum for hours on end, may give you the knowledge, but not the skills to play. The same can be said about any task, from plastering to Bricklaying, there's a vast difference between knowing how to do it, and being able to do it.
Repetition is mastery 🙂

Regarding subdividing, @Pete Thomas, I was taught to do this as a young student by my clarinet teacher. Set the metronome at, say, 60, and start thinking semiquavers. Now play a scale in quavers, ensuring that the notes fall exactly on every other semiquaver.

Thinking: 1234123412341234
Playing: 1-3-1-3-1-3-1-3-

This technique came in handy in my mid-teens when I was presented with lots of syncopated rock and funk music in big band, which is usually notated in semiquavers and quavers, rather than quavers and crotchets as in swing music. It enabled me to count and lock in to the various complicated figures.

@Digger2054 - I had to learn to “lock in” to an external source of time. When working with a metronome, you have to be aware of it AND your playing at the same time. Making sure that your timing matches the metronome. (Or the drummer…)

This is really the hardest part of playing an instrument - paying attention to multiple things simultaneously. Tone, intonation, timing, articulation, volume, blend, etc., all while maintaining good embouchure and air support. It’s why we get tired playing, it is hard work. But worth it in the service of a joyful noise!
 
Just one thing, the gen Z are absolutely not curiosity, it has not interest by anything it's not tiktoks, on Web and on internet.

I played buescher straight alto and conn f mezzo soprano on jam, only old man Ask me what is it for exemple.

(many years ago, maybe 10 years, they're many People to Ask what is it)

Same thing, i played on octavin by oscar adler, only two Ask med what is it ?

The curiosity, the interest for music, for playing instrument will die with next generation. And the video and website around musical instrument will die one after one.

Why ?? Just simply, it has not time
Playing instrument take long long time, and it's hard to try a good skills for ??? Absolutely not job for 90% of players,

For exemple, Yannick coderre is canadian good players of sax, talk the problem with the futur of Jobs musicien. The problem of this situation.

It's hard to have good skills, or now the gen Z Come aways when it's hard, and you can have facility to have successful and money with influence and social network influence like that tiktok, instagram,... Etc.

Why you try to have good skill during many years with one instrument, when A.I could be create an illusion to play good...

It's Just like that, gen Z is gen Z, to be nostalgic is not good solution, gen Z is New world, sadly Probably but it's like that and we don't do any thing against that.

Better sax, chad, and other influencor will become the new stars, and after that, it's natural evolution.

Before we played and learn to play by radio like that de de talk, now it's better sax and chad will replace that, and after it will be A.I will replace the old influencor.... And the life continue...
 
Well, I don’t disagree with some of what you say about Gen Z, but there are many frighteningly good young players around. Maybe there are less, but arguably we’re oversubscribed anyway - too many in music conservatoires who won’t go anywhere.
 
Well, I don’t disagree with some of what you say about Gen Z, but there are many frighteningly good young players around. Maybe there are less, but arguably we’re oversubscribed anyway - too many in music conservatoires who won’t go anywhere.
They're are plenty young People who played an musicale instrument, in usa it's Probably different but in France, it's globally less and less People, it's dramatic
 
Just one thing, the gen Z are absolutely not curiosity, it has not interest by anything it's not tiktoks, on Web and on internet.

The curiosity, the interest for music, for playing instrument will die with next generation. And the video and website around musical instrument will die one after one.

Why ?? Just simply, it has not time
Playing instrument take long long time, and it's hard to try a good skills for ??? Absolutely not job for 90% of players,
I wonder if they're connected?

Most videos online tend to make stuff look easy, not just musical videos, when the reality is often much different. A video of a competent player performing is the result of many hours practice.

Add to that how the internet seems almost instant, order something today it rocks up tomorrow.
 
Add to that how the internet seems almost instant, order something today it rocks up tomorrow.
I took 2 semesters of Spanish at the local community college to learn the language 6 years ago. Spanish is not as easy as some say. There are many verb conjugations, rules for regular and irregular, but then I found that there are sufficient irregulars that one needs to memorise verbs individually, negating rules. Also there are colloquial sayings, what they translate to is not what they mean.

Those saying the language is easy are those selling language materials and lessons, basically marketing. The only way is to keep learning is consistently plugging away, otherwise one regresses.

It is the same with playing the sax. It takes hard work and persistence to excell. There is no corner cutting.
 
Well, I'm sure someone has mentioned this, but it is certainly easy now to pull up chords, lead sheets, backing tracks, and multiple recordings of almost any piece of music - this simply wasn't possible 40 years ago. We all probably tend to forget what it was like, when you heard a tune you liked. If you were lucky, you could hum it for someone who knew its name. If it was in the Real Book, great. If not, you MIGHT be able to find it on a record - but probably not. Otherwise you'd try to remember how it went and pick it out on the piano.
 
Well, I'm sure someone has mentioned this, but it is certainly easy now to pull up chords, lead sheets, backing tracks, and multiple recordings of almost any piece of music - this simply wasn't possible 40 years ago. We all probably tend to forget what it was like, when you heard a tune you liked. If you were lucky, you could hum it for someone who knew its name. If it was in the Real Book, great. If not, you MIGHT be able to find it on a record - but probably not. Otherwise you'd try to remember how it went and pick it out on the piano.
Yeah, well it’s still true up to a point. A couple years ago I heard something on the radio (I know, old school) and missed the announcement. I recognized the tune, I’d heard it before, could hum it a bit, tried to find out what it was using various web-based services, eventually gave up. Earlier this year I happened on it while researching Tadd Dameron - On A Misty Night. Such a beautiful tune, not a lot of people play it.

I do believe it’s best to learn tunes by ear - what we used to call “taking it off the record” but is now known by the $2.80 term “transcribing”. Apple Music (which I prefer to Spotify) does make it easier to get multiple examples of a song. I do this to learn a tune - put 6-10 versions of a tune on a playlist, and play along with it. If they are in different keys, so much the better. You have to internalize the music and make it part of you, and this approach works well.

Learning music “sticks” better when you do it by ear. And playing it somewhere, as opposed to just practicing it, tends to burn it in. That’s how the old cats (well, older than me anyway, at 77 I guess I qualify) knew so many tunes. Playing them 4 or 5 nights a week, week after week, which never happens these days, tends to reinforce them.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,193
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom