Saxophones Feedback for a kid learning a lyrical piece

Will give it a listen tonight or tomorrow.
Jumped on it.
First step, learn to play it perfectly without any hesitation.
Memorizing the piece is a plus, as you can concentrate on telling the story.

Sounds familiar, does it have a name?
Actually, if you've been playing for decades, everything sounds familiar.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Might slow it down from Andante to Adagio at 72 BPM, for now.
It’s written as 80 bpm. It’s for a middle school region band audition actually. I’m not sure if they will deduct for not playing it at the written tempo. Though I must agree and think it sounds more beautiful played a bit slower.
Does it sound likes he’s biting at all or anything wrong with his sound or tone? Just like any glaring issues?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Not sure when the audition is, but slowing it down for now, is so it's played without any hesitation.
Try it at 72, and if it can be played okay, four times thru, then pick it up 2bpm each day, until 80bpm.
Record at 72 then post.
Curious as to the source of the music.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The good - time, rhythm, intonation, tone
Needs work - emotion and musicality, vibrato, like you said

Have the child try to sing the melody lyrically and note the flow of the lines and dynamics (da da deee-da da da ...). Give the lines somewhere to go, crescendo ascending lines, decrescedo descending. Put more air through the horn, possibly even try a softer reed. Sounds timid, so encourage them to really belt it out. Listen to a recording of a pro and see what they do.

Since the vibrato isn't really solid yet, may want to leave it out this time around.

Every kid auditioning will be able to play the notes on the page like yours. Giving a beautiful and emotional performance will give your kid the edge and make them a better musician.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Tell your kid to try to think of the music like talking. If you are telling a story to someone you emphasize certain words, change your tone, the general volume of your speaking. In other words, you add meaning to the words with your inflection.

It’s the same with music, but it’s more abstract because we don’t “think” in notes. But notes still have meaning, and it’s up to the performer to emphasize that meaning with volume and inflection. “Inflection” meaning vibrato, articulation and tone color.

I would avoid being specific about where and how to add these things, rather let the kid figure it out for themself.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Would disagree with some of post #8.
Giving the kid, maybe 14 years old at most, insight of how to interpret and play the piece, to be beneficial.
Before any symphony or opera, I attended, at that age, our music maestros, gave us the details, of what we would hear and see.
Plus Italian was not a language that I spoke/understood.
Made the experience real.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Disclaimer: I'm just an (old) amateur sax player with little tutoring. And I've never auditioned for any band.

+1 for @lydian's feedback. My impression is that your middle schooler's doing really well! I really like his tone (better than mine TBH!) and the general 'fluidity' of his playing. I noticed just one little hiccup in needing to take a breath mid-phrase. But I'm sure he'll have noticed that too.

IHMO, perhaps the most important thing in auditioning (and playing generally) is 'playing confidently'. Which - to - also means feeling (reasonably) confident and comfortable (enough) when playing. At least, feeling confident and comfortable enough about being able to 'perform' reasonably well when auditioning.

So there's a fine line between:
a. your son gradually developing his performance and enjoying this, and
b. trying to 'cram' new - but not yet fully natural - techniques in for the audition

Option b. runs IMHO the risk of increased 'mental overload' (remembering what, when how), increased uncertainty and perhaps more nervousness than your son would otherwise have. For many (most?) people, 'auditions' and public solo performances can be quite nerve-wracking events. So, IMHO, the less 'added pressure', the better. Anything that increases your son's sense of 'comfort' and 'confidence' is, I think, welcome.

Any performance that's 'cramped' by more than average nerves or uncertainty is IMHO less likely to succeed than other candidates who feel more at ease and confident. And are more able to express themselves (at what whatever musical level). So - to me - the obvious thing to do as a parent - is to keep emphasizing all the positives about your son's sax practice. The positive comments that have been here, his progress, his commitment, his ambition, etc. I'm convinced that positive, supportive and appreciative comments really do inspire and enable musicians to 'grow and develop'. Much more than comments that note 'the improvements that are possible'.

Even if your son's not selected for the middle school band, I personally believe that it's much more important that he still feels supported, appreciated and inspired to continue to develop. For doing his best. Rather than feeling a failure for 'not making the grade'. This is just one audition for one band at his age! Pass or fail, it says nothing about his future potential as a musician!

Just some personal advice based on my Big Band MD's (and jazz workshop leader's) advice. He has a Master's degree in music so he pretty much knows what he's talking about:
1. Sing the melody over and over again! Forget (for a moment) the sheet music, Just sing the melody (with some emotion) as you'd naturally do. His intention was that - though singing - we'd naturally discover the 'phrasing', the 'flow' and the dynamics.
2. Exaggerate the 'dynamics': audiences don't readily perceive the distinction between mp and mf, so make mp softer (pp) and make mf (sometimes) louder (f).
I should add that:
a. the 'dynamics' pp -> FF are always relative (to the hall, vocal/non-vocal, etc.)
b. in any band, all members need to have the same (relative) interpretations of the written 'dynamics'
c. in any band, all band members (with the exception of soloists) need to have the same 'expression' of any piece (as directed by the MD)

As said, I have no experience with 'auditions'. My wild (amateur) guess is that at your son's audition, assessors might be looking at things like:
- sight-reading (in combination with 'memory' and 'muscle memory'
- timing
- tone
- fluency
- following the written 'dynamics'
- showing (where needed) some non-written 'personal expression'
- confidence

I came across this short video on 'phrasing'. Perhaps it might inspire your son.
View: https://youtu.be/01zbVEvgkAw?si=9IFz9yhMURLpVINk
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Not sure when the audition is, but slowing it down for now, is so it's played without any hesitation.
Try it at 72, and if it can be played okay, four times thru, then pick it up 2bpm each day, until 80bpm.
Record at 72 then post.
Curious as to the source of the music.
I know it’s from a Voxman book. (#17 - pg. 34 from Advance Method of Saxophone, Vol. 1) They just hand out print outs of just a section of the song not the full piece. I think this may only be half of the piece.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6269.webp
    IMG_6269.webp
    51 KB · : 86
Vote:
Upvote 0
1) Breathe. I can hear the ends of phrases dropping off at times.

2) Exaggerate dynamics, ritards, all that stuff. What seems like totally-over-the-top chewing the scenery to the player, will sound tentative and constrained to the audience. For young players in band settings playing instruments like saxophone, it's particularly tough because they've been hollered at "TOO LOUD!" for years now. They have now to learn how to let loose.

3) Can you get a real professional saxophonist with some classical background to play this for the student? Even with YouTuba everywhere, there's nothing like standing in the room with an actual top level player, hearing how he/she actually sets the air into motion.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Is there a reason to play without?
Yes. To make music. You don't want to be training an automaton. Musicality involves actually feeling what a piece is about and making it your own. That constant beat in your head while you're doing it makes that impossible.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Not sure when the audition is, but slowing it down for now, is so it's played without any hesitation.
Try it at 72,
Slowing down can be good but bear in mind it makes breath control harder, already there is a breath that would be best not in the middle of a phrase (just before the end)

I think the sound is very good though.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
The nome is good for a while, but by now it's time to turn it off and feel the time internally.

To add to that it doesn't have to be all or nothing, at first you could subdivide the metronome tempo to only have it click on the first beat of a measure, etcetera. Obviously at some point you practice playing with it off.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,274
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom