Saxophones Elkhart vintage Alto

You know, hand engraving often has mistakes. I had a King baritone that clearly said "Made by H N Whit Co., Cleveland, Ohio".

I'd guess the engraving was MEANT to say "Artist".

Everything about that "Artiso" looks very Buescher-y except the exotic octave mechanism. That looks like an experiment that wasn't continued.
 
In the sales video the seller describes the Buescher case as "original." I wonder how he knows for sure?...

View: https://youtu.be/Oy3kL2BiP1I?si=-YpQvG9DSvScgYPi


I'm hoping you paid less than the £1,300 he was asking on Preloved, although for what seems a very rare, pristine, Buescher (albeit possibly a stencil) an obsessive Buescher collector may be inclined to part with that kind of money.

I seem to recall Buescher made an "Aristo" model, but that was much much later. I had a brief thought the engraver may have been dyslexic and got the letters muddled, but that can't be the case... unless he also had vision problems, was trying to engrave "Aristocrat" but didn't have enough room.

Perhaps it was a maker trying to somewhat copy an early Aristocrat (when did they start?) but adding some innovations and wanting to find a similar model name to get people interested. A prototype perhaps.

Interesting find anyhow.
 
The sax tech that I took it to, to do some work on it, actually pointed out that it ends in an 'o' and not a letter 't' , he asked me to compare with the third letter that is a definite letter 't' and I'd see that it wasn't the same. I'd be in agreement with him on this...
Yes, I see it now - your eyesight is better than mine! Curiouser and curiouser: I've never come across that name before.
 
In the sales video the seller describes the Buescher case as "original." I wonder how he knows for sure?...

View: https://youtu.be/Oy3kL2BiP1I?si=-YpQvG9DSvScgYPi


I'm hoping you paid less than the £1,300 he was asking on Preloved, although for what seems a very rare, pristine, Buescher (albeit possibly a stencil) an obsessive Buescher collector may be inclined to part with that kind of money.

I seem to recall Buescher made an "Aristo" model, but that was much much later. I had a brief thought the engraver may have been dyslexic and got the letters muddled, but that can't be the case... unless he also had vision problems, was trying to engrave "Aristocrat" but didn't have enough room.

Perhaps it was a maker trying to somewhat copy an early Aristocrat (when did they start?) but adding some innovations and wanting to find a similar model name to get people interested. A prototype perhaps.

Interesting find anyhow.
Buescher's Aristocrat model started around 1932/34 at s/no. 262,700, being preceded by the True-Tone series' 1 - 5. The first model was "The New Aristocrat" which had opposed bell keys, followed about 1935 by the "Aristocrat" Mk1 (bell keys on the left), which is the one much prized as a classical horn - still used by the Rascher Quartet, for instance. I have owned several True-Tones and Mk1 Aristocrats over the years, although I've never had a New Aristocrat, but none of them had a crude octave key mechanism like the one on the above pictures, so I still don't think it's a Buescher. I've never owned an "Elkhart" - Buescher's "second-line" horns from the '30's as opposed to being stencils - so I don't know if they had an octave mechanism like this. I wonder, therefore, if it could be a stencilled Elkhart? Otherwise bafflement reigns supreme over here!
 
I seem to recall Buescher made an "Aristo" model, but that was much much later. I had a brief thought the engraver may have been dyslexic and got the letters muddled, but that can't be the case... unless he also had vision problems, was trying to engrave "Aristocrat" but didn't have enough room.
The first tenor I owned was a Buescher Aristocrat made in the 1970s. Nothing like this, at all, or the earlier Aristocrats, to be honest. I still have it, 42 years later, because I'm a bit of a sentimentalist, But by objective standards, it's really not a very good sax, with cheap, basic manufacture. It's nowhere near as good as a decent modern student sax made in China. It's a good example of a failure of economic practice in manufacture. Take a fundamentally good product, allow the profit motive to over-ride all other considerations, ruin the product, go bust.
 
In the sales video the seller describes the Buescher case as "original." I wonder how he knows for sure?...

View: https://youtu.be/Oy3kL2BiP1I?si=-YpQvG9DSvScgYPi


I'm hoping you paid less than the £1,300 he was asking on Preloved, although for what seems a very rare, pristine, Buescher (albeit possibly a stencil) an obsessive Buescher collector may be inclined to part with that kind of money.

I seem to recall Buescher made an "Aristo" model, but that was much much later. I had a brief thought the engraver may have been dyslexic and got the letters muddled, but that can't be the case... unless he also had vision problems, was trying to engrave "Aristocrat" but didn't have enough room.

Perhaps it was a maker trying to somewhat copy an early Aristocrat (when did they start?) but adding some innovations and wanting to find a similar model name to get people interested. A prototype perhaps.

Interesting find anyhow.
Yeah, that's my video, and the sax tech (Roger Price, from Pentre near Chirk, N Wales) who repaired and serviced it, said by the design of the case, it fits with the age of the sax. So I believed in his opinion..
 
The first tenor I owned was a Buescher Aristocrat made in the 1970s. Nothing like this, at all, or the earlier Aristocrats, to be honest. I still have it, 42 years later, because I'm a bit of a sentimentalist, But by objective standards, it's really not a very good sax, with cheap, basic manufacture. It's nowhere near as good as a decent modern student sax made in China. It's a good example of a failure of economic practice in manufacture. Take a fundamentally good product, allow the profit motive to over-ride all other considerations, ruin the product, go bust.
Yeah, Roger Price (a sax tech and semi retired) seeing 100's of vintage horns pass through his hands over the past 50 years or so of his self- employment in the trade, said it was a 'lovely horn' ....
 
@Hagster69 It's a Martin Stencil - the giveaway is the bevelled tone holes. Probably dating to the mid-1920's; if the s/no. conforms to a Martin number, it's 1925, and that would match with the design of a 1925 Martin Handcraft alto. I play a Lewin alto, which is another Martin Handcraft stencil, and have owned several Martins. The Martin stencils seem to be of as good quality as the main brand, and play well if in good condition with (usually) good intonation, fast action and a big, dark tone. The ergonomics can be a little difficult, especially for the RH pinky keys which are not well-placed for me, anyway, but an hour or two of practice will sort that out. Risers on the palm keys can also be useful. As to price: in reasonable playing condition - perhaps needing a couple of pads and a service - £200 to £250max. If it needs a full repad that will cost you anywhere from £350 upwards, so £100 to £150max. Sadly Martin Handcrafts don't make much, even in top condition, so you want to try to keep the total cost to a max. £500 IMHO. At that you should have a fine alto, although it will still be a stencil!
Yes, every other Elkhart I've seen has been basically a Bundy before there was a Bundy, but this is clearly a Martin. The low C and Eb are also giveaways. Probably a decent player, and a curiosity because it's an Elkhart that wasn't built by Buescher, but very little monetary value. The engraving is similar to the Buescher horns, but they usually have the elk inside the heart. I guess it's an irresistible pun. There are enough horns out there with a front F, for probably similar money, that I'd pass on this one, but that's personal preference.
 
Yeah, Roger Price (a sax tech and semi retired) seeing 100's of vintage horns pass through his hands over the past 50 years or so of his self- employment in the trade, said it was a 'lovely horn' ....
By the '70s, the Aristocrat was exactly the same sax as the Bundy. These were cranked out in numbers for middle and high school players at a low price. They weren't much to look at, and the keywork was sloppy, but acoustically they're some of my favorite horns. I'm sure a lot was done to the bore over the years, but they seem to still have some of the magic that Gus Buescher borrowed from Adolphe Sax when he started out. They also take tremendous punishment and play past leaks that would turn other saxes into boat anchors. Accept a late Aristocrat for what it is, and you'll get more out of it than you expect.
 
I too saw bevelled toneholes at first, but then wasn't so sure in other photos. It does however have a rectangular G# touch rather than the arc typical of Bueschers.
The low C and Eb being split in the middle as opposed to Bueschers having the C fit between the two ends of the Eb is more typical of Martin. Conn did that too, but this isn't a Conn.
 
The low C and Eb being split in the middle as opposed to Bueschers having the C fit between the two ends of the Eb is more typical of Martin. Conn did that too, but this isn't a Conn.
I received this message from the sax tech today and it is in agreement with your comments.
Screenshot_20230907_175340_WhatsApp.webp
 
I've seen this design before on an old Besson alto. My very old John Grey tenor - Italian-made, I think - has a similar mechanism, with the automatic octave keypad in the middle and a kind of hook over the top, like your picture. I've never seen that design on a Buescher, so I'm inclined to think it's not one of them, but I don't know what it is. A pure guess might be a stencil of a late '20s York.........
I found this on a sale site today, with a very similar octave mechanism, and although it is a Hawkes & Son saxophone, it does have an Italian connection..
Screenshot_20230907_094650_eBay.webp

Screenshot_20230907_094751_eBay.webp
Screenshot_20230907_094835_eBay.webp
Screenshot_20230907_094906_eBay.webp
 
Was it this one?
No - that one's a (made for) John Grey in a Hawkes & Son case. Made in Italy, not by H&S in England.

It's not an arrangement commonly fitted on H&S saxes. It struck me as unusual, though I have seen it on others - possibly Besson, as mentioned above.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,432
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom