Tone or Sound Edge

I find tedge is much harder to describe than to hear!

David Sanborn is a good example of having an edgey sound where as Grover Washington, on alto in this instance has a much rounder sound.

I think an edgey sound has more higher frequency partials and generally more vibrant and bright feel.
High baffled small chambered mouthpieces help to produce edge and if you are not careful, a horrible shrill but as your own control increases, the less you need to rely on the height of a baffle of size of a chamber.
 
Edge to me is akin to turning up the treble or presence controls on your amplifier to let the tone cut through more, but as Saxlicker says it is quite hard to describe because if you have a less edgy, more rounded tone it doesn't necessarily mean you won't cut through.

Maybe 'edge' in terms of describing sounds is a very subjective term, one man's edge is another man's bleeding eardrums; I for one find Sanborn's tone a little too edgy for my liking.
 
On the tenor sax, I find Michael Brecker had loads of edge to his playing, whereas someone like Stan Getz had a much more rounded sound.

For alto "edgy" sounding sax is perfectly epitomised by David Sanborn, whereas Paul Desmond (sax on Dave Brubeck's Take 5) is almost the sonic opposite: Smooth and rounded.

Hope that helps
 
I always think of Paul Desmond's lovely rounded tone and style of playing as very 'polite'.

On the other hand, Cannonball has a good edge on his tone - is it necessary to have that edge if you're going to play fast like Cannon, so that notes sound cleanly rather than being a mushy flurry, or is it more to do with his tonguing and accenting?
 
Edge is often used to mean the same as bright, which many people think of as the opposite of dark. However I often use dark as meaning the opposite of light (although some people might think the opposite of light is heavy. I think of the opposite of a bright tone as warm, though many people would think of warm as the opposite of cold. What some people call a cold tone I call a clear tone, but others would call that a focussed tone. However to some people a focussed tone is bright, but to others it's thin, the opposite of which some would call fat, however it could be described as unfocussed, the opposite of which is edge.

I hope that's clear now.
 
I have been told that I have an edgey tone....

I find it difficult to make an opinion on what peoples tone is like.... I never quite understand what the different descripive words mean lol
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
Edge is often used to mean the same as bright, which many people think of as the opposite of dark. However I often use dark as meaning the opposite of light (although some people might think the opposite of light is heavy. I think of the opposite of a bright tone as warm, though many people would think of warm as the opposite of cold. What some people call a cold tone I call a clear tone, but others would call that a focussed tone. However to some people a focussed tone is bright, but to others it's thin, the opposite of which some would call fat, however it could be described as unfocussed, the opposite of which is edge.

I hope that's clear now.

Hmm, I've been thinking... as a word describing tone, where does cut fit into this pantheon of linguistic terminology?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,310
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom