Reeds Do you rotate your reeds? If so, what's your routine?

Do you rotate your reeds?

  • Yes

    Votes: 10 50.0%
  • No

    Votes: 10 50.0%

  • Total voters
    20
It's a shame you are overly sensitive in thinking that somehow the post was aimed specifically at you. I'm sure you are familiar with people who have rituals regarding their reed prep, storage, special containers/humidifiers, etc. There certainly are gear sellers who cater to all of these things, and obviously have buyers.

As said "Whatever works for you is fair". Taking such vociferous offense at what should have been considered a "lighthearted" bit of banter means you are possibly a bit oversensitive...a nerve has been hit?

I guess you'd also like to tell people like me and Pete Thomas (and a large and growing contingent of pros) that none of us have good tone or know how to play. How ridiculous! Play whatever reeds you want and if you have something that works for you that's good. Others have what works for them and it's not going to be the same as what works for you, and that was the gist of the post.
Maybe I over reacted. (Well, likely I over reacted…) I shouldn’t type late at night…

In my defense, characterizing the processes that cane players use as religious rituals is over the top. And stating that using synthetics is the answer is nonsense. It may be the answer for some people, and if I were still working doubling jobs I might use them in certain situations, but they just don’t play well - for me.
 
.

Maybe some people do rotate reeds for similar reasons but I’m sure most do it because it does have real advantages in that you always have a ready to go back up, or maybe there really is an actual advantage in resting a reed for a bit. Either way I see no harm and the more I think about it the more I see probable benefit.
The biggest reason I can see for rotation, if managed well, is that you can have a series of reeds that are all good but at different times in their lifespan; meaning you don't get used to playing the reed of choice but worn and much softer than the next new one out the box.

If you have a couple that are maybe a practise session old, and a couple that are a week or two alongside a couple that have been gigged to death that you love but are gonna die any moment, the jump to the next new one to break in shouldn't be as stark.

I definitely have reeds that I've had for a long whilse that feel half a strength lower than the newer ones in my case; if I only played that reed, then I think it'd be more of a painful period breaking in the next one.
 
If you need the magic feather, lucky hat and sunglasses, or a Klangbogen, that's OK. Whatever makes you feel good embrace...just remember that it's your ritual that benefits you, and not a universal truth.
True. I did lots of things that most players thought was nonsense. I used to drill, soak, sand, scrape, cut, file .... reeds. I also think the cork should fit the bore perfect. I rotated when comes to mouthpieces as well. Two of each. The reed shouldn't be longer than the table, otherwise I lost power. I believed in mass. So a heavy mouthpiece was the thing for me. And Klangenbogen sounds interesting. When I was playing football I used to rotate my shoes as well. As a chef I had three of my best knives ready (same type/style).

It was my own ideas and rituals. Never told anyone to do what I did. But other guys were questioning about my rituals. And it wasn't in a curious and good way.
 
...each reed is slightly different, so each day it takes a minute or two to optimize my sound. This forces me to concentrate on making my sound, rather than having my sound dependent on a particular reed....
THIS is a point of real wisdom.

Somewhere I read about one teacher who insisted his students play on their second and third best reeds rather than spending all their lives fiddly-dicking around trying to achieve that one true perfect reed. I read that and immediately changed my mindset on reeds.

The damn things aren't ever going to be any good.

No matter how much time you spend the day before the big gig, trying to identify that perfect reed, when you actually get there and apply your current embouchure to the actual reed, it's not going to play the way it did yesterday.

In my experience every time I've gone to great trouble to get the perfect reed, either picking it out before hand, or sitting on the bandstand for half an hour swapping and testing, the results were worse than if I'd just pulled one out of the holder and slapped it on.

You have a choice: either learn how to play on the reed you have, or spend your entire life in a futile search for the perfect one.
 
So, here's a story for B/I and (possibly wrong, but my) conclusion.
A few months ago I was dog-bodying for a visiting group, the leader was Tenor and an old timer. As they where settling in, he was taking to someone on stage, took a new reed from box, unwrapped it, gave it a quick suck, stuck it in the horn and they started playing, sound checking etc.
Conclusion; chappy is so sorted with technique, his music, his kit, his brand of reed that he knows he can work with whatever is in the box.
I'm not. So I'm allowed to "play in" a reed, soak it, maybe adjust it, etc. Within my tolerances, which won't be the same as someone else's. And especially not folks who've been playing long time...
 
I buy boxes of 5. I play them all and use the best one first and the worst one for long note practice only. Rotation takes too much effort for an amateur like me.
 
No matter how much time you spend the day before the big gig,
IMO, that's too late. To have four "equal" reeds in my reedgaurd, was an ongoing process.
You have a choice: either learn how to play on the reed you have, or spend your entire life in a futile search for the perfect one.
True. I prepared reeds to make the bad ones to play better. Reeds are rather expensive and my sax playing never gave me any money. To prepare reeds was also some kind of meditation thing. Listen to relaxing music and prepare reeds. I was not a professional player. Why should I adopt methods that is not fine by me?

Do what you want with with your reeds. Play and have fun.
 
Last edited:
I play mostly Legere AC 2 on alto and rotate between 5 reeds, the oldest one of these 5 I bought back in late 2019 and it still plays fine, we are all different so whatever works and keeps us playing is what's best, there is such a lot of choice out there, maybe too much choice.
 
I do wonder if dicking about with reeds is for quiet players.
Sitting in front of the bass drum of a drum kit, as part of a three piece front row used to playing outside in parade bands and a very enthusiastic banjo player seems to have taken the subtlety out of my reed requirements.
 
Regarding reed purchases, I usually buy Rico orange boxes of 25, because cost per unit is lower, since they don't move as quickly as the smaller boxes, find them discounted during sales. Those that don't work out of the box, I'll set aside and tweak later, although occasionally I have a few duds. Did come across some new old stock 10 years ago, which worked out great cost and seasoned wise.

Occasionally have picked up others, like several boxes of (10 in each) jazz select for soprano 7 years ago. Also picked up a couple boxes (10 in each) Rico Royal for Eb clarinet and soprano sax a couple years ago.

Caveats - bargain reeds:
I did find a caveat in seeking bargains. Some of the exceptionally cheap off brands from the Far East were basically a toss up. I did find one that seemed decent, most all their alto reeds played. Can't remember the brand now as it was maybe 5 years ago, plus it was short lived. Reordering time, nada available.

Another buy about two years ago for only $12 for 10 reeds with free shipping, best put, basically makes a beginner player sound like a beginner, truly horrible. Tip off is ... read ... - ultra low price.

That cured me to stick with name brands, even though costs are escalating. Similarly on the synthetics, I found the hard way, you get what you pay for. One, a black plastic sythetic Bb clarinet reed for under $5 US, just didn't resonate right. I think it was the type of plastic they used.

On the other hand, a bari synthetic I bought a decade ago was okay. (I paid $15 US for it, am a little lazy to dig out my other sax for the moment, otherwise I'd state the brand, got a good rating on sax forums.) I was doing a lot of outdoor playing. It was nice to pick up the horn after a break, and it still played without having to remove and rewet. (I dip a reed into a cup of water, being older sometimes lack the saliva to wet reeds right away. We have very dry air here, so even with a mouthpiece cap on, reed dries out very quickly.)
 
Bari synthetics give me nightmares, frankly. But, to a lesser extent, so do Ricos. Never got on with them at all. Perhaps if I bought 5s and completely recut them all myself, but I'd rather spend that time playing.

Almost every other brand I've ever tried has been a lot more consistent, and sure they're a little more expensive because of that but I think that's a good trade off.

Lots of people make them work, which is fair enough.
 
I play M (Lavoz) reeds on bari. I use to work on my bari reeds so I can play with less pressure compared to tenor. No reed cutter, I don't want a thicker tip. I just file, scrape, sand, drill ..... my bari reeds. Always work on a wet reed.

Here is a clip showing how to file the back of the reed with a wet stone. In the background you hear the great baritone player David "Woody" Woodford (RIP) playing bari on the song "Jawa".
View: https://youtu.be/XBAafccRxag
 
My issue with ultra-cheap reeds has been bad cuts and finding them already damaged in the box. If the thing's 1/4" off center when it's cut, you can't adjust that to be right. Or if you take it out of the box and it's already got a half inch split in it.
 
You'd think Chinese bamboo would be good. They've been using it for millennia.
Apparently not, even though it's incredibly cheap.
I got a box of ten alto, free with a 99p reed cutter. Still got nine and an unuseable reed cutter.
Yeah, but they haven't been using it for saxophone reeds for millennia.

Bamboo is really a fantastic material for a lot of purposes. Not necessarily for sax reeds.

After all, POST slide rules were all made from bamboo with a celluloid overlay. Still have mine.
 
You'd think Chinese bamboo would be good. They've been using it for millennia.
Apparently not, even though it's incredibly cheap.
I got a box of ten alto, free with a 99p reed cutter. Still got nine and an unuseable reed cutter.
Yeah, it’s weird. The Chinese reeds I’ve tried had the density and strength of balsa wood. The opposite of a good Vandoren. The few playable ones only lasted a few days. Seems like the same species of cane would be similar if grown elsewhere in a similar climate, but is vastly different.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,571
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom