Is there a thread about which fowl the best lucky feathers come from? Depending on; tone, style...
Maybe I over reacted. (Well, likely I over reacted…) I shouldn’t type late at night…It's a shame you are overly sensitive in thinking that somehow the post was aimed specifically at you. I'm sure you are familiar with people who have rituals regarding their reed prep, storage, special containers/humidifiers, etc. There certainly are gear sellers who cater to all of these things, and obviously have buyers.
As said "Whatever works for you is fair". Taking such vociferous offense at what should have been considered a "lighthearted" bit of banter means you are possibly a bit oversensitive...a nerve has been hit?
I guess you'd also like to tell people like me and Pete Thomas (and a large and growing contingent of pros) that none of us have good tone or know how to play. How ridiculous! Play whatever reeds you want and if you have something that works for you that's good. Others have what works for them and it's not going to be the same as what works for you, and that was the gist of the post.
The biggest reason I can see for rotation, if managed well, is that you can have a series of reeds that are all good but at different times in their lifespan; meaning you don't get used to playing the reed of choice but worn and much softer than the next new one out the box..
Maybe some people do rotate reeds for similar reasons but I’m sure most do it because it does have real advantages in that you always have a ready to go back up, or maybe there really is an actual advantage in resting a reed for a bit. Either way I see no harm and the more I think about it the more I see probable benefit.
True. I did lots of things that most players thought was nonsense. I used to drill, soak, sand, scrape, cut, file .... reeds. I also think the cork should fit the bore perfect. I rotated when comes to mouthpieces as well. Two of each. The reed shouldn't be longer than the table, otherwise I lost power. I believed in mass. So a heavy mouthpiece was the thing for me. And Klangenbogen sounds interesting. When I was playing football I used to rotate my shoes as well. As a chef I had three of my best knives ready (same type/style).If you need the magic feather, lucky hat and sunglasses, or a Klangbogen, that's OK. Whatever makes you feel good embrace...just remember that it's your ritual that benefits you, and not a universal truth.
THIS is a point of real wisdom....each reed is slightly different, so each day it takes a minute or two to optimize my sound. This forces me to concentrate on making my sound, rather than having my sound dependent on a particular reed....
IMO, that's too late. To have four "equal" reeds in my reedgaurd, was an ongoing process.No matter how much time you spend the day before the big gig,
True. I prepared reeds to make the bad ones to play better. Reeds are rather expensive and my sax playing never gave me any money. To prepare reeds was also some kind of meditation thing. Listen to relaxing music and prepare reeds. I was not a professional player. Why should I adopt methods that is not fine by me?You have a choice: either learn how to play on the reed you have, or spend your entire life in a futile search for the perfect one.
Yeah, but they haven't been using it for saxophone reeds for millennia.You'd think Chinese bamboo would be good. They've been using it for millennia.
Apparently not, even though it's incredibly cheap.
I got a box of ten alto, free with a 99p reed cutter. Still got nine and an unuseable reed cutter.
Yeah, it’s weird. The Chinese reeds I’ve tried had the density and strength of balsa wood. The opposite of a good Vandoren. The few playable ones only lasted a few days. Seems like the same species of cane would be similar if grown elsewhere in a similar climate, but is vastly different.You'd think Chinese bamboo would be good. They've been using it for millennia.
Apparently not, even though it's incredibly cheap.
I got a box of ten alto, free with a 99p reed cutter. Still got nine and an unuseable reed cutter.
