Reeds Do you rotate your reeds? If so, what's your routine?

Do you rotate your reeds?

  • Yes

    Votes: 10 50.0%
  • No

    Votes: 10 50.0%

  • Total voters
    20
Hi, my name is Steve and I rotate my reeds.

I just go in order through the reed case. Each day a new reed. Every 4 or 8 days (depends on the case), I get back to the 1st. I believe, but have no objective proof, that this prolongs the life of the reed.

There is one other benefit to rotating - each reed is slightly different, so each day it takes a minute or two to optimize my sound. This forces me to concentrate on making my sound, rather than having my sound dependent on a particular reed.

I have done the “play a reed till it dies” thing in the past, but the pain of accommodating myself to a new reed after a week or three of one reed is much more than the slight discomfort of today’s reed being slightly different than yesterday’s.
With the rotation, do you just end up with 4 or 8 reeds that have aged progressively together though, or do you stagger their 'newness'?
 
Like Mizmar above I have a box of 5 2.5 Boston reeds. I use the one on the right and when I finish practice put it back in the box on the left. Every 5 days the reeds rotate back to the beginning and every practice is just that bit different to the last. I am at last finding differences in range and dynamics in the reeds and nod to myself when I recognise the characteristic's of today's reed. Makes me feel like my ear must be improving if not my 'chops'.
Again I guess it's the same question to you both: what triggers getting a new box and making sure there isn't a big jump between five new reeds and five old worn reeds?
 
Again I guess it's the same question to you both: what triggers getting a new box and making sure there isn't a big jump between five new reeds and five old worn reeds?
They drift apart. One mighty eventually split, another be unpleasant somehow. I'm spending more time in the G+ altissimo range and some reeds seem to find that stressful. I replace one-by-one. When the box of new reeds starts getting low I get something new. But, they do last ages. I'm not very fussy.

Currently I have half Roberto's Reeds and half Rigotti (who make Roberto's) same strength on the label but not in fact! So, it's interesting and, as Jules says, satisfying to start on a reed and think "ah, this one.."
 
Last edited:
Again with Mizmar. The few short months I've been practicing I've purchased a few different reeds in make as well as strength. Currently the Boston 2.5's my favourite but the principal was the same prior to settling with them so had a few different makes and therefore slightly different ages which I played in daily rotation. Currently I'm trying hard to eliminate my weeknesses so keeping the same reed make and strenght along with mouthpiece hopefully gives me a bit of a platform to work from
 
With the rotation, do you just end up with 4 or 8 reeds that have aged progressively together though, or do you stagger their 'newness'?
Reeds tend to last somewhat different amounts of time. Generally between 20 and 30 hours, sometimes more. (Also, some days I “have it” and some days I just suck.) Reeds that don’t play “right” end up meeting the edge of the table head on. So they end up staggering out on their own. When the case gets down to 3 (4 reed case) or 5 (8 reed case), I replace them.

Note that beheaded reeds have many uses, as glue speaders/mixers and sacrificial pokers and pushers, so I keep several broken reeds around. Plus, I generally keep a reed stub under the ligature when storing my mouthpiece.
 
In university my major was cultural anthropology. When questions like this come up I can't help but think in terms of practices that mirror rituals that are supposed to bring benefits or good luck to an individual. This becomes more apparent when "practitioners" have routines.

Whatever works for you is fair, yet there is no one true way, the same as there are multiple religions. If the goal is to play with as few hassles as possible and have consistency the answer is synthetics. Same reed for 6 months to two years? No soaking, sanding, scraping, clipping etc. Yea, that's OK with me!

If you need the magic feather, lucky hat and sunglasses, or a Klangbogen, that's OK. Whatever makes you feel good embrace...just remember that it's your ritual that benefits you, and not a universal truth.
 
I once got in terrible trouble on SOTW for saying I don't recommend rotating. I actually received a death threat
That is one of the reasons why I don't post there now. Attempted posting there a number of years back, after a long recess started again, but that reminded me why I took the long recess. Folk are more civil here.

I used to rotate. These days I get one out of the packet, play it till it dies, then open a new one.
Playing SABT and clarinet, I lose track.
I hear you, feel the same. I have reed holders for all my instruments (Bb, Eb clarinets; soprano, alto, tenor, bari saxes). Used to be more proactive in rotation. Now, I'll populate the holders, when a reed wears out, put a new one to replace it. Sometimes I'll use a favorite reed until it breaks down and doesn't play well any more. Because I don't keep track, switching horns, I've lost track, path of least resistance.

Always keep a box of new in my cases.
 
Same reed for 6 months to two years? No soaking, sanding, scraping, clipping etc. Yea, that's OK with me!
So for me, I found this by just finding a great brand and reed that matched what I wanted to do. I regularly have cane reeds that last for months, and a box of five (cheaper than a synth) lasts for a couple of years.

On the ritual thing, whilst I have a few reeds on the go at any one time (well 6, as that's the capacity of my reed box), I don't really have a system as such. And always have a spare box or two in the case.
 
Last edited:
In university my major was cultural anthropology. When questions like this come up I can't help but think in terms of practices that mirror rituals that are supposed to bring benefits or good luck to an individual. This becomes more apparent when "practitioners" have routines.

Whatever works for you is fair, yet there is no one true way, the same as there are multiple religions. If the goal is to play with as few hassles as possible and have consistency the answer is synthetics. Same reed for 6 months to two years? No soaking, sanding, scraping, clipping etc. Yea, that's OK with me!

If you need the magic feather, lucky hat and sunglasses, or a Klangbogen, that's OK. Whatever makes you feel good embrace...just remember that it's your ritual that benefits you, and not a universal truth.
Respectfully, I disagree with the assumptions in this post. I don’t do things with reeds because of some supposed benefit or good juju, but because they work. I have tried multiple approaches to reed management because I am always trying to get the most out of reeds, and to always play with the best possible sound.

The routine that I have, adjusting the reed as soon as I take it out of the box and playing it in rotation with others, was arrived at by many years of experimentation while maintaining a career as a professional musician, both full and part time. This is what works best for me.

I know many other professionals that do things differently, and I was taught a different (more complicated) routine, but I also know players that do what I do. To each his own, as they say, but there is no magic involved here for me, nor for most of the players I know, regardless of their routines. It’s not what makes me feel the best, it’s what lets me get my sound in the most efficient way. It’s not a ritual, it’s a practice that I evolved into over many years.

Reeds are not religious artifacts, they are tools with which to make art.

This post also suggests that synthetic reeds are the answer if you want to avoid hassle. That sounds good, and it may be true for some people, but it is not for me. I do not consider my reed prep routine to be a hassle, but it is more work than just putting a reed on and forgetting about it for many months. I have tried synthetics many times over the years, and their tonal qualities are substandard. The concept is attractive, but the implementation is poor.

But the implicit suggestion in your post that synthetics are the answer if you want to get out of the cane management cult is nonsense. Most serious players I know who still play cane reeds have tried synthetics, and like me, have found them to be a poor substitute.
 
Respectfully, I disagree with the assumptions in this post. I don’t do things with reeds because of some supposed benefit or good juju, but because they work. I have tried multiple approaches to reed management because I am always trying to get the most out of reeds, and to always play with the best possible sound.

The routine that I have, adjusting the reed as soon as I take it out of the box and playing it in rotation with others, was arrived at by many years of experimentation while maintaining a career as a professional musician, both full and part time. This is what works best for me.

I know many other professionals that do things differently, and I was taught a different (more complicated) routine, but I also know players that do what I do. To each his own, as they say, but there is no magic involved here for me, nor for most of the players I know, regardless of their routines. It’s not what makes me feel the best, it’s what lets me get my sound in the most efficient way. It’s not a ritual, it’s a practice that I evolved into over many years.

Reeds are not religious artifacts, they are tools with which to make art.

This post also suggests that synthetic reeds are the answer if you want to avoid hassle. That sounds good, and it may be true for some people, but it is not for me. I do not consider my reed prep routine to be a hassle, but it is more work than just putting a reed on and forgetting about it for many months. I have tried synthetics many times over the years, and their tonal qualities are substandard. The concept is attractive, but the implementation is poor.

But the implicit suggestion in your post that synthetics are the answer if you want to get out of the cane management cult is nonsense. Most serious players I know who still play cane reeds have tried synthetics, and like me, have found them to be a poor substitute.
It's a shame you are overly sensitive in thinking that somehow the post was aimed specifically at you. I'm sure you are familiar with people who have rituals regarding their reed prep, storage, special containers/humidifiers, etc. There certainly are gear sellers who cater to all of these things, and obviously have buyers.

As said "Whatever works for you is fair". Taking such vociferous offense at what should have been considered a "lighthearted" bit of banter means you are possibly a bit oversensitive...a nerve has been hit?

I guess you'd also like to tell people like me and Pete Thomas (and a large and growing contingent of pros) that none of us have good tone or know how to play. How ridiculous! Play whatever reeds you want and if you have something that works for you that's good. Others have what works for them and it's not going to be the same as what works for you, and that was the gist of the post.
 
rituals that are supposed to bring benefits or good luck to an individual.
Didn't Rapport show that (sacred) rituals can, sometimes, actually be providing important services to the society and, indeed, environment?
Sure, there are many reasons for rituals to develop: superstition, group cohesion, material functions... And, sure, if someone does something about it before playing, it's a ritual; but surely it's the job of the Anthropologist to use data to divine which.

Brushing teeth is a ritual, it's taught by parents and high priests (dentists) to kids who don't understand tooth decay. But it's not just the ritual qua ritual that benefits.
 
Do I? Well, sort of. My plastic containers (with added vodka) usually contain about 10 reeds. At any one time I'll probably use just 2 of them, not strictly rotated but chosen at random. The other 8 sit there waiting their turn - which may never come. There's usually a mixture of makes and strengths.

Playing bari last night I had a look at the usual 2 (Jazz Select 2M) and thought they were looking a bit tired. They're probably a couple of years old so it's to be expected. I may change them soon. The one I picked played fine though.

It's not an approach that would suit everyone. 🙂
 
the primary thinking behind this is that you want to have a bunch of reeds that are in good shape to go for practise/performance and if one dies the second is ready to g
I have about 12-15 reeds that I have ready all the time. Two different brands depending on the gig. I take an extra reed on stage just in case one gets too soft on a 3-4 hour gig and I change it out on break.

At home I test several at a time for response. The good ones are marked and put in a box. Ones that are dull or lack easy response will be revisited later.
 
It's a shame you are overly sensitive in thinking that somehow the post was aimed specifically at you. I'm sure you are familiar with people who have rituals regarding their reed prep, storage, special containers/humidifiers, etc. There certainly are gear sellers who cater to all of these things, and obviously have buyers.
I don’t think it came across as aimed at any one person. This is obviously something some people do and may be because they were advised to or maybe there really is an advantage. I'm on the fence still.

But even though I don’t set out to rotate reeds I see a lot of validity in it as opposed to some of the other things you mentioned such as lucky feathers or Klangboga.

Maybe some people do rotate reeds for similar reasons but I’m sure most do it because it does have real advantages in that you always have a ready to go back up, or maybe there really is an actual advantage in resting a reed for a bit. Either way I see no harm and the more I think about it the more I see probable benefit.
 
My rotation practice is to leave all the reeds in current use and ones that have served well in the past in two more or less distinct heaps on a table. I use 3 or 4 from the current pile in a random fashion but the newcomer gets preference for a few days. I’ll find 3 that I like if I’m going out to play.

Occasionally I’ll go to the other heap and pick through them, maybe promote some or maybe even throw some away, this pile increases more rapidly than the primary one. I separate the piles with my lucky feather.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,569
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom