Playing the saxophone Different Bb alternative fingerings

The ABRSM book (and my teacher) gives the Bb using the RH side key as the primary fingering, with the Bbis key method next and the RH1 and RH2 alternatives as 3rd and 4th. I find the RHSK fingering the most natural, rarely, if ever, use the Bbis key and only sometimes use the others. Again the ABRSM book suggests using all of them at some points where it could be advantageous. It's a bit like the alternative C using L1, RHSK2: I find this much more fluid when doing a downward chromatic and/or slurred run.

Antiquated spellings ("ise or "ize") apart, we do seem to have got ourselves some awful linquistic aberrations in the cause of modernisation. As well as the examples already given by others, why does everything these days have to be on a basis (eg "on a daily basis"; what is wrong with just "daily")? Why are things tagged "obviously" when they are far from so? Why is the collection of buildings down the road now called a "train station" when it has always been pretty obvious that the only thing that could possibly run along those steel tracks and stop at the station ("railway station" if you are a pedant) could be a train? Why do the staff in restaurants and shops say to Mrs YC and me "Are you guys OK?". And this morning Angela Rippon on TV said something was happening "twenty four, seven, three hundred and sixty five". When I'd done the maths I realised she meant "all the time", by which time I had lost interest in the subject. Rant over. Must be something better to do.... go out and vandalis(z)e OG's Zimmer?

Colin>:)
 
Young Col, Fowlers advises 'ize' in such circumstances.

I agree with your concerns about the abuse of our beautiful language, and how it is even mangled by HM Radio4.


Some of mine are, (here we go) are.

'The best temperature today will be.....' Best for what, skiing, sunbathing?

'The Army delivered essential supplies to innaccessible areas'. Not possible.

The way people are allowed to say 'I refute that' without being made to refute it.
Refute means disprove, which requires a reasoned argument. They say 'refute' because they think it it a classy way of saying deny.

It happens all the time. Even weather forecasters talk of hotter and colder temperatures!

The worst, and I think most irritating/blatant/incompent/illiterate, and just plain wrong, is where there is a news item written by a journalist, edited and then read on Radio 4, where the subject and object are confused.

'Mr Bloggs was yesterday convicted of multiple rape at Swansea Crown Court.'

He may have been convicted, that may have happened in the Crown Court. I don't imagine multiple rapes occured at Swansea Crown Court.

It is just wrong, innaccurate and fodder for us who care!
We all make mistakes in everyday speech, but when it is written, edited and then broadcast without anyone spotting the elementary errors it becomes detrimental to the accuracy with which we express ourselves.

'The stand out player........' What is wrong with the word 'outstanding'?
'Two times World Champion' The word is 'twice'.
It shouldn't be difficult for professional journalists to master, then get past their sub-editors and broadcast.

And believe or not, I'm not a pedant. I just want our wonderful language to be used correctly and to convey the meaning without ambiguity.

Isn't that what language is for?


Sorry, what was the question?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Young Col, Fowlers advises 'ize' in such circumstances.

I agree with your concerns about the abuse of our beautiful language, and how it is even mangled by HM Radio4.

'Mr Bloggs was yesterday convicted of multiple rape at Swansea Crown Court.'

He may have been convicted, that may have happened in the Crown Court. I don't imagine multiple rapes occured at Swansea Crown Court.
Tom,
I do not believe you should accept this challenge.
 
Yes, I'll go with that. We all make lots of mistakes when speaking, but when things are scripted for broadcast there is no excuse. I learned last week that the "g" in Porgy and Bess is soft. It must be so as a BBC TV anouncer said it twice on one day last week.

What question? :shocked:
 
For Bb I generally use B+Bis or A+side Bb but find for some passages long Bb is easier.
On a YTS-25 with the 5C mpc I can get decent Bb with L1+R1 less so L1R2/3. On my newly acquired Soloist E L1+R2 and L1+R3 are ok but L1+R1 sounds flabby.
Is this due to the mpc, the horn or me?

Off to rehearsal so you argue amongst yourselves until I return later tonight. 😉
Thanks in advance.
 
Last edited:
For Bb I generally use B+Bis or A+side Bb but find for some passages long Bb is easier.
I can't think of a single passage where the long Bb fingering (1 + 1) would be easier. It may be best for a B-Bb trill, but other than that I would never use it. Trills aside, I don't like the timbre of that fingering either. You don't need it.
 
I can't think of a single passage where the long Bb fingering (1 + 1) would be easier. It may be best for a B-Bb trill, but other than that I would never use it. Trills aside, I don't like the timbre of that fingering either. You don't need it.
Interesting

Long Bb (1 + 2) is my go-to for lots of runs/intervals

But to add context, for me side Bb is the least used of the three, which I expect puts me on the sax-technique naughty step
 
the horn
Maybe.
There's a long leaver behind the bell which is depressed by the D E and F keys, which, in turn depressed the levers to close the G# hole, should it be open and, eventually, the Bb.
On the YTS there's little screw for each of D E F so they can be independently regulated to close the holes above without being held open themselves. Along the bar is an engraving that says "abandon all hope ye who starts adjusting this" It's a bit of a balancing act, helped by a leak light etc.
And, yes, I think that can vary with MP because leaks can have more or less impact depending on how much power you are sending their way.
 
Sound like a leak because of an adjustment screw on the rod coming off the RH F key. Without gawping at the sax I think it’s the 2nd one? 1st one holds G# down when RH keys down. Should go onto a rod underneath which is connected to the Bb Bis key. Adjust til the Bb key is just closed when the F key is closed.
But look it up as my sax isn’t in front of me.
 
I can't think of a single passage where the long Bb fingering (1 + 1) would be easier. It may be best for a B-Bb trill, but other than that I would never use it. Trills aside, I don't like the timbre of that fingering either. You don't need it.
Funny how we differ ..I pretty much use long Bb all the time, when I was a teenager two different old ex dance band players both recommended I use long Bb as the standard, Which I've always done and works for me anyway.
 
That could be a leak. Pad, something bent, cork missing or worn, or none of the above.

No reason for it to be mouthpiece or you.
Thanks all.

"Is this due to the mpc, the horn or me?" I wasn't inferring any issue with the mpc save it being positioned correctly.

I don't know about a leak but it plays ok apart from the L1+R1 sounding weak and a bit off compared with L1+R2 (not L1+R3 as above).

I'll take a closer look tomorrow - I have Steve Howard's book - but I'm not going to fiddle with it! I'll ask my teacher/technician to check it over when I see him next month.

Re utility, it was 'D2_F2_Bb2 F1 Bb2' for which I found long Bb simpler than Bis or RSKBb.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,320
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom