Courtney Pine

you'll have people ordering sofas now... and lighting dimmers...
Did I mention that people's lives would be much better with a Sequoia saxophone and a Pillinger mouthpiece?
Forty something years? When can I expect it? :old:

Actually, I only tried for the first month... but I am encouraged to have another try by members' comments to try again to seek the magic...
Anytime: I took 14 years of Coltrane worshiping before I could fully be touched by those notes.
There are things that have a superiour, beyond language, power: Kind of Blue, Love Supreme, Citizen Kane, The Blidsman's meal by Picasso, the Sistine Chapel....
Just plain spiritual power. (and I am quite a materialist person)


It is odd, for example, that Nick likes Coltrane but doesn't get Dolphy - and I like Dolphy but don't get Coltrane... and I don't think that de gustibus is sufficient explanation...

When people, such as those on this thread, whose opinions I respect "get" something which I don't it makes me curious as to why. What triggered their understanding or appreciation? Would it trigger mine, and widen my horizons?
You nailed why I love this forum.


Other people in the house don't appreciate the sound of the saxophone 🙁
Send them to the pub, open your best bottle, and listen to "A Love Supreme"

Listening is a very rare commodity, nowadays. We usually hear things. Following John Coltrane phrasing in that album is really fulfilling.
 
I find listening to music when driving can be very revealing. It's as if it goes in subliminaly and when I listen properly on the house stereo it feels familiar but still new. I stick songs I'm considering learning on the mp3 player and let them roll. The ones I don't get fed up with are the ones that make the short list.

I think we can't help having preconceptions with new music and our mood can help or hinder with something new. I'm not a fan of Coltrane, though I have some of his stuff, but I'm an Eb man. My favourites players are all alto and Baritone.
 
but I'm an Eb man. My favourites players are all alto and Baritone.

You know, however much you try to be objective about all this stuff, there exists crap in your head that has no sensible basis in fact. I don't know if you feel about it the same way that I do (I doubt it) but, to me, Bb saxes are in some way "hard" and Eb saxes "soft". I can't explain this. It makes no sense - but it's in my head. It's like expecting metal ligs to give you a hard sound and fabric ones a soft one. Total codswallop, of course, but you can't get it out of your head. Anyway, my favourite players tend to be players of Bb saxes. But an alto/sop player and a bari/sop player inspired me to take up playing the damn things.
I have often had a little chuckle about musical types referring to sharp keys as being bright and cheerful and flat keys as being dark but I don't get why my head would pick out a difference between Bb and Eb.
 
Did I mention that people's lives would be much better with a Sequoia saxophone and a Pillinger mouthpiece?.

I don't doubt it 🙂

You nailed why I love this forum.

as we all do

Send them to the pub, open your best bottle, and listen to "A Love Supreme"

Listening is a very rare commodity, nowadays. We usually hear things. Following John Coltrane phrasing in that album is really fulfilling.

Might just do that but I still love listening in the car, pity it won't be here for my long drive to Bath 🙂

Jx
 
I'm not sure that I could put into words any of my lightbulb moments and I'm not sure it would help any one. When I find two jigsaw pieces that fit and the two pieces together illuminate that small part of the picture, it makes finding some of the other pieces for that area easier. The areas come together and it gives a flavour of what the whole picture might be. It's a big picture. I haven't found any straight edges yet.

I had one recording my version of "Take Five" I've been banging away at it for decades. While trying to make BiaB play in 5 4 it occured to me that I'd never noticed it was in Eb minor. I got fluent with it and got lucky with BiaB and was pleasantly surprised with the result. See. Told you it wouldn't help lol. I still can't get over what you can do in the back bedroom with a cheap mic and a laptop.
 
I really like the lightbulb resource idea idea, kernewegor- your list of Parker numbers and illustration story of how it lit up for you is terrific for someone like me who trawls Spotify rather than buys records anymore. I'll go through the list tomorrow and see what your understanding has been. I've always had Parker around in my adult life but haven't paid all that much attention. And seeing other people's lightbulb moments would be fascinating - another musical exercise.
I can think of quite a few of these moments of my own, to be summed up in a list of links. For instance the discussion around 'A love supreme' had me listening to Sam Newsome's - who I get- tribute [ I think ] to Coltrane - who I don't get. And at one point today, I heard Newsome go on and on with a series of musical ideas which were nothing more than one of those exercises where you play a few notes, repeat a few times, go up a note, repeat same number of other notes, a few times, up a note, repeat etc. Modes, is it? Anyway it's what Bach did in the well tempered clavier and I think it's very typical of Handel.
There's at least one country riff on guitar that turns up in Bach prelude #1 in C.
The neat thing about music is that it's out there, bold and available for every one with ears. The lightbulb list resource could be
such an immediate illustration of ideas and musical concepts for anyone to explore things that bit further. A way of expressing in sound the idea that one has had oneself as well as the ideas of the musicians who made the music. A curiosity building tool - and surely curiosity is a corollary[sp ?] of creativity.
I'm probably making a simple idea too complicated but I hope it happens one way or another.
 
Bejayzus, Jane, you're up late! Another night bird!

I think that you have summed up what I think the idea could achieve.

I had a brief look at Spotify once, but tend to use youtube. There are lots of CDs there - if I like them then I buy them from my local shop if possible or online.
 
Good to get a reply so soon! it'll be interesting to see what other formats get proposed. I love this forum for just that chance thing of a recommendation here or there that can turn into a whole new view of music.
Rambling a bit now. catch y'all tomorrow.
 
It arrived. Sorry. Had a listen. I won't be listening again. It's like someone trying to attack me with a pneumatic drill. Coltrane doesn't do anything positive for me.
This reminds me a famous Italian reviewer about "Blue Train":
"with this album John Coltrane confirms that his saxophone sounds more like some bagpipes than a tenor".

Kev, try to forget it is a saxophone and follow the music. Only once again, please.
I will send you an extra helping of sauerkraut, if you do.
Not too much, or you might end up like this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wyDGDpze8k
 
This reminds me a famous Italian reviewer about "Blue Train":
"with this album John Coltrane confirms that his saxophone sounds more like some bagpipes than a tenor".

That could be a lightbulb moment and explain why my wife likes (or at least doesn't complain about) me playing the sax, she's Scottish.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This reminds me a famous Italian reviewer about "Blue Train":
"with this album John Coltrane confirms that his saxophone sounds more like some bagpipes than a tenor".

That could be a lightbulb moment and explain why my wife likes (or at least doesn't complain about) me playing the sax, she's Scottish.

Wait a minute! I just got booked for some gigs in Scotland! What are you trying to say?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom