Courtney Pine

I saw him at the jazz cafe in Camden about seven years ago,what he does is not really my cup of tea but,I admire him for trying to do things his way (often with a reggae flavour)
The circular breathing thing is OK, in moderation.
 
Wow! Just got in and found a long thread to read. Circular breathing is a tool in a players toolbox. It gets me out of trouble when the trumpet player decides to go for the surprise long note ending. I'm sure he does it on purpose. I also use it when playing to build tension in a piece. You can feel the audience waiting for you to breathe. It's not an end in itself. I think I'd be impressed with a long low A on Bari mind. I do like that note. Endlessly repeating the same atonal phrase on a lone soprano? I can't see the point but was willing to let it go as a bit of flash and showmanship.

I've seen Courtney before and have some of his records. I understand that feeling of the sudden revelation when something everyone raves about and you're struggling with becomes clear. I persevered with Parker and one day I got it. I was asking a fellow muso what he thought with the record on and was explaining my lack of comprehension when the door opened and the sound changed from black and white to technicolour. That was early on in my twenties. I think I have a more educated ear now. My musical likes include some pretty wierd stuff as well as mainstream. I think I said on here once that the only thing I don't get on with is rap but I've heard one or two tracks on the radio recently that were quite good. So anything goes. The shuffle in the car can throw up death metal followed by northern soul and a bit of debussy some 1920's jazz a bit of Sinatra some marley a ltlle Ian Dury follwed by Vivaldi a bit of glen miller and nat king cole. 60's 70's 80's 90's pop....I'm up for anything.

The performance last night was unbearable. I kept thinking the band would settle down or some one would tweak something. I can't remember walking out on anything before. I'm glad others feel the same way about him. It does make you wonder if it's you that's losing the plot.
 
I walked out on Polar Bear - the bassist was the only one who could play a decent solo and the electronics guy sounded like the PA was on the blink.. I went to see the support band - Henry Grimes, Paul Dunmall and Andrew Cyrille, who were incredibly good and stuck out about 5 numbers from Polar Bear until I decided that the pouring rain outside was preferable to the soulless drivel inside..
I now have a policy of avoiding anything that John Fordham raves about in the jazz press - Nat Birchall was underwhelming too, 10th rate Alice Coltrane-isms in a creative void.. I would've walked out, but I was waiting for Pharoah Sanders to come on and show 'em how it should be done.
 
Presumably not listened to much Coltrane then.

I bought the LP "A Love Supreme" when it first came out, influenced by reports in Down Beat. The local record store clerk was also raving about Coltrane - he was an enthusiast but a fool and no musician, who burbled "...Trane gets onto these moods..."

In spite of him I paid my money and listened to it many times over a month or so, each time wondering what all the fuss was about...

While I would not go as far as quoting from the Scottish play "....full of sound and fury / Signifying nothing..." nor to describe him as "playing snake-charmer music" - both of which criticisms have been voiced at one time or another - I have to admit that Coltrane has never managed to enthuse me as has, say, Parker, Johnny Griffin, Dolphy, John Handy, Rollins, Ornette Coleman, Dexter Gordon, Zoot Sims... just to name a few and in no particular order and omitting many.

Coltrane had an amazing sound and a virtuoso technique, but it was his choice of notes which I found boring. His playing on Monk's 1957 recording of 'Nutty' doesn't excite me, either. Rollins says some nice things about him though, so maybe I should have persevered and listened to more of his music - suggestions welcome.

Another youthful and impetuous purchase was an Albert Ayler LP - the title had something to do with spirits. I think I played it through twice, the second time just to make sure I'd heard it right the first time - it contains extended amounts of irritating noise.

I have often wondered if Ayler, instead of doing the traditional thing and woodshedding, used to practice in a piggery...
 
I bought the LP "A Love Supreme" when it first came out, influenced by reports in Down Beat. The local record store clerk was also raving about Coltrane - he was an enthusiast but a fool and no musician, who burbled "...Trane gets onto these moods..."

In spite of him I paid my money and listened to it many times over a month or so, each time wondering what all the fuss was about...

It is just a matter of time before you get its magic. It is definitely there.
 
I bought the LP "A Love Supreme" when it first came out, influenced by reports in Down Beat. The local record store clerk was also raving about Coltrane - he was an enthusiast but a fool and no musician, who burbled "...Trane gets onto these moods..."

In spite of him I paid my money and listened to it many times over a month or so, each time wondering what all the fuss was about...

While I would not go as far as quoting from the Scottish play "....full of sound and fury / Signifying nothing..." nor to describe him as "playing snake-charmer music" - both of which criticisms have been voiced at one time or another - I have to admit that Coltrane has never managed to enthuse me as has, say, Parker, Johnny Griffin, Dolphy, John Handy, Rollins, Ornette Coleman, Dexter Gordon, Zoot Sims... just to name a few and in no particular order and omitting many.

Coltrane had an amazing sound and a virtuoso technique, but it was his choice of notes which I found boring. His playing on Monk's 1957 recording of 'Nutty' doesn't excite me, either. Rollins says some nice things about him though, so maybe I should have persevered and listened to more of his music - suggestions welcome.

Another youthful and impetuous purchase was an Albert Ayler LP - the title had something to do with spirits. I think I played it through twice, the second time just to make sure I'd heard it right the first time - it contains extended amounts of irritating noise.

I have often wondered if Ayler, instead of doing the traditional thing and woodshedding, used to practice in a piggery...

well there's no law that says you have to like Coltrane, I found him a bit hard to keep up with at first until I heard 'After The Rain' and his playing with Miles - the people who don't like Coltrane don't seem to moan about 'Kind Of Blue'.
There's a certain relentlessness to Coltrane's approach that some folks have difficulty with and not every album he did is brilliant - a lot of those Prestige recordings from the 50's were cash in hand drug money sessions with unrehearsed, cobbled together bands who didn't normally play together, so the results were variable.
I doubt Coltrane was happy with his playing with Monk, he was only in the band for a few months and it takes longer than that to fully come to terms with Monk's music - I doubt I ever will..
Listening to music can be a tricky business and our preconceptions can affect how we judge what we're listening to...
I find that albums that are overhyped are always disappointing at first, a lot of classic albums don't turn out to be the artist's best work and music critics often seem to have a different agenda that's more to do with magnifying there own coolness by being hip to something you're not. Sometimes it's only years later that I can appreciate some albums, when all the fuss has died down, other much lauded works will always elude me.

Since you mentioned Albert Ayler, it should be pointed out that in his younger days he was quite proficient at playing blues (he toured with Little Walter) and be bop and was well respected on the Cleveland jazz scene. He joined the army and
spent a few years playing in a military band. It was somewhere during this period that he started to develop his own way of playing, which most people, then and now, find difficult to listen to. So, woodshed - yes - piggery - no...

For those of you who've just ordered 'Love Supreme' - wouldn't it have been easier to check it out first on youtube or spotify before you shell out the cash? I rarely buy albums unless I've got a good idea that I'm going to like them
 
The Iggy Pop guide to the sax on Radio 6 Music had an interesting Ayler track at the beginning- very gospel/R&B based- quite unlike anytihng I'd normally associated with his work. The docmentary "My Name is Albert Ayler" (viewable in its entirety on youtube) is well worth a watch, even if you're not a huge fan of his music....
"After the Rain"....for me, one of the most beautiful pieces of music ever... together with his version of Lush Life...
 
For those of you who've just ordered 'Love Supreme' - wouldn't it have been easier to check it out first on youtube or spotify before you shell out the cash? I rarely buy albums unless I've got a good idea that I'm going to like them

Possibly but I do most of my listening in the car and if it will take a few listens to appreciate it, it's easier this way 🙂

Jx
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom