I bought the LP "A Love Supreme" when it first came out, influenced by reports in Down Beat. The local record store clerk was also raving about Coltrane - he was an enthusiast but a fool and no musician, who burbled "...Trane gets onto these moods..."
In spite of him I paid my money and listened to it many times over a month or so, each time wondering what all the fuss was about...
While I would not go as far as quoting from the Scottish play "....full of sound and fury / Signifying nothing..." nor to describe him as "playing snake-charmer music" - both of which criticisms have been voiced at one time or another - I have to admit that Coltrane has never managed to enthuse me as has, say, Parker, Johnny Griffin, Dolphy, John Handy, Rollins, Ornette Coleman, Dexter Gordon, Zoot Sims... just to name a few and in no particular order and omitting many.
Coltrane had an amazing sound and a virtuoso technique, but it was his choice of notes which I found boring. His playing on Monk's 1957 recording of 'Nutty' doesn't excite me, either. Rollins says some nice things about him though, so maybe I should have persevered and listened to more of his music - suggestions welcome.
Another youthful and impetuous purchase was an Albert Ayler LP - the title had something to do with spirits. I think I played it through twice, the second time just to make sure I'd heard it right the first time - it contains extended amounts of irritating noise.
I have often wondered if Ayler, instead of doing the traditional thing and woodshedding, used to practice in a piggery...