Saxophones Conn 10m.... Could this be the one?

FWIW, don’t assume that all vintage horns share much of anything in common other than age.
I find this to be true, yet I still see (or hear) people refer to a vintage sound whereas as far as I can tell there can be a fair amount of difference.
that's what I'm getting from this whole post guys, you have both voiced my thoughts.... To try and play a few vintage horns to see how I feel about them myself.
That is the best way.
 
I grew up playing vintage saxophones and then moved on to more modern ones as I progressed through school. Most of my horns were Selmers. Flash forward to a time when a business associate gave me an old horn that was lying around in storage and as soon as I gave it a blow, I recognized my true preference for vintage horns. That was almost thirty years ago and I've since moved out the Selmers and moved in the older vintage American horns.

That said, if you've only been playing modern horns, a vintage horn might not feel right for you. And you'll only know this when one is in your hands. So definitely don't buy sight-unseen or go by someone else's reverence for a certain model or make. You have to try them to find out.
OP, @Grumps has a valid point, and to lay on to that, if there is a horn that you like but something feels off, play a few others and then go back, it may be a slow acquisition of taste/appreciation.

FWIW, don’t assume that all vintage horns share much of anything in common other than age. This includes the subcategory of vintage American tenors. As much as I enjoy hearing some people play a good 10M, I don’t care to play them. I much prefer to play Buescher or King tenors that have been well-maintained and properly overhauled in recent years.

You really do need to play a lot of horns to learn what works best with your body and airstream.
That's another important point.

Personally, I don't have any brand loyalty but when all you play are cheap throwaway pawnshop horns that you personally restored, you develop a much more intimate relationship with each finished specimen than if you bought them in top condition or had them professionally overhauled after the purchase.

And there are "special" instruments, like the King saxello. I love my Conn, and my "uber-vintage" Martin soprano, and my Holton can run with the best but the quirky saxello is where my heart is with a close second Buescher.

My favorite bari is a King Zephyr but for rowdy gigs I play the Conn 12M.

And so on... It's a journey and a very enjoyable, I might add.
 
And as you made the point..... I'm just an intermediate player on a base model.... so at the end of the day what does it really matter?...... except to me of course, 😏🤷
Yipes that makes it sound like a dis' ....😳..which was not my intention at all.

It certainly matters anytime you can team up a player with an instrument that inspires them. I know plenty of beginner-intermediate players who bought vintage horns and have been truly jazzed with them (pun not intended).

There are multiple levels of intent on buying a new (to you) horn.

The basic level is...wanting something in good play shape, user friendly ergonomically and intonationally.

Then after playing a while (as you have) it is pretty typical for a player to start yearning for other attributes, some tangible, others intangible. Tonality is a big one. Ability to flex note intonation (intentionally) is another. Then blowing response is a third. Aforementioned 'resistance' being a part of that (although I disagree with previous commenter who suggested a free blowing resistance is harder to tame...I think the opposite is true, but that is another subject).

These may be things an intermediate player can now identify, which didn't matter at all earlier.

Then, intangibles.
Example...you play three great horns, you like all, but one just 'speaks to you' more, or you feel it just 'fits better'. Hard to 'explain' it, it is almost a more holistic alignment, if you'll forgive my woo-woo semantics here.

I have experienced it myself as a player and also as a seller when potential buyers playtest. Sometimes I can literally see and feel the vibe connection happen right there when a client is playtesting.

One example I will always remember was a young intermediate player showed up with his GF to playtest three or four vintage Tenors I had, all give or take in the same price vicinity. He went thru them and one really seemed to click in sound and HOW he was actually playing it. He asked 'is this one better adjusted than the others ?" It wasn't, all had been equally regulated, so I said 'no, not at all. But that's the one which is speaking to you'

He seemed confused and asked what I meant. Before I could reply his GF said

"that one LIKES you the most".

Brilliantly astute observation, 'twas.

There was nothing more I could add to that.
 
Yipes that makes it sound like a dis' ....😳..which was not my intention at all.

It certainly matters anytime you can team up a player with an instrument that inspires them. I know plenty of beginner-intermediate players who bought vintage horns and have been truly jazzed with them (pun not intended).

There are multiple levels of intent on buying a new (to you) horn.

The basic level is...wanting something in good play shape, user friendly ergonomically and intonationally.

Then after playing a while (as you have) it is pretty typical for a player to start yearning for other attributes, some tangible, others intangible. Tonality is a big one. Ability to flex note intonation (intentionally) is another. Then blowing response is a third. Aforementioned 'resistance' being a part of that (although I disagree with previous commenter who suggested a free blowing resistance is harder to tame...I think the opposite is true, but that is another subject).

These may be things an intermediate player can now identify, which didn't matter at all earlier.

Then, intangibles.
Example...you play three great horns, you like all, but one just 'speaks to you' more, or you feel it just 'fits better'. Hard to 'explain' it, it is almost a more holistic alignment, if you'll forgive my woo-woo semantics here.

I have experienced it myself as a player and also as a seller when potential buyers playtest. Sometimes I can literally see and feel the vibe connection happen right there when a client is playtesting.

One example I will always remember was a young intermediate player showed up with his GF to playtest three or four vintage Tenors I had, all give or take in the same price vicinity. He went thru them and one really seemed to click in sound and HOW he was actually playing it. He asked 'is this one better adjusted than the others ?" It wasn't, all had been equally regulated, so I said 'no, not at all. But that's the one which is speaking to you'

He seemed confused and asked what I meant. Before I could reply his GF said

"that one LIKES you the most".

Brilliantly astute observation, 'twas.

There was nothing more I could add to that.
And it's the same thing with mouthpieces, maybe even more pronounced.
I don't know how many pros have stood at my kitchen counter to try "identical MPCs" and all of a sudden it clicked.
 
Yipes that makes it sound like a dis' ....😳..which was not my intention at all.

It certainly matters anytime you can team up a player with an instrument that inspires them. I know plenty of beginner-intermediate players who bought vintage horns and have been truly jazzed with them (pun not intended).

There are multiple levels of intent on buying a new (to you) horn.

The basic level is...wanting something in good play shape, user friendly ergonomically and intonationally.

Then after playing a while (as you have) it is pretty typical for a player to start yearning for other attributes, some tangible, others intangible. Tonality is a big one. Ability to flex note intonation (intentionally) is another. Then blowing response is a third. Aforementioned 'resistance' being a part of that (although I disagree with previous commenter who suggested a free blowing resistance is harder to tame...I think the opposite is true, but that is another subject).

These may be things an intermediate player can now identify, which didn't matter at all earlier.

Then, intangibles.
Example...you play three great horns, you like all, but one just 'speaks to you' more, or you feel it just 'fits better'. Hard to 'explain' it, it is almost a more holistic alignment, if you'll forgive my woo-woo semantics here.

I have experienced it myself as a player and also as a seller when potential buyers playtest. Sometimes I can literally see and feel the vibe connection happen right there when a client is playtesting.

One example I will always remember was a young intermediate player showed up with his GF to playtest three or four vintage Tenors I had, all give or take in the same price vicinity. He went thru them and one really seemed to click in sound and HOW he was actually playing it. He asked 'is this one better adjusted than the others ?" It wasn't, all had been equally regulated, so I said 'no, not at all. But that's the one which is speaking to you'

He seemed confused and asked what I meant. Before I could reply his GF said

"that one LIKES you the most".

Brilliantly astute observation, 'twas.

There was nothing more I could add to that.
Thank you, well explained ☺️🙏
 
Fair. It amuses me no end to see someone take their favorite mouthpiece to go shopping for a new horn. It can be immediately constraining in some instances.
So.. you’d line up a load of different mouthpieces / reeds along with a dozen different horns and try every combination??
 
Having watched a few comparison videos on Selmer mark VI Vs Conn 10m, (not that I was looking at the Mark VI 😳) I immediately noticed how different the tone was between them.
You’ve obviously missed my old (but true) anecdote of when I was recording an album and two weeks into the recording my MKVI broke. I panicked a bit but then found a 10m and continued the recordings. Nobody, including the producer, noticed I’d started a solo on the MKVI and finished it overdubbing some dropins on the 10m. Even to this day I cannot tell the difference in sound. What I do know is the Conn was easier to get in tune at the top hence I stuck with it rather than going on a hunt for a MKVI.
 
Fair. It amuses me no end to see someone take their favorite mouthpiece to go shopping for a new horn. It can be immediately constraining in some instances.
The trick (skill, knack, nous, whatever) is in being able to recognise that. When I searched for a new tenor I did so using my old Dukoff D8 - a mouthpiece I'd used for 25+ years. Having that consistency enabled me to make a direct comparison between the horns I was trying - and it was only when I found the horn that I felt had the potential I was looking for that I changed the mouthpiece to better bring out that potential.

I'm a very firm advocator in changing as little as possible when testing/trying new horns. You need a baseline - a reference. Without that you're just shooting in the breeze.
 
You’ve obviously missed my old (but true) anecdote of when I was recording an album and two weeks into the recording my MKVI broke. I panicked a bit but then found a 10m and continued the recordings. Nobody, including the producer, noticed I’d started a solo on the MKVI and finished it overdubbing some dropins on the 10m. Even to this day I cannot tell the difference in sound. What I do know is the Conn was easier to get in tune at the top hence I stuck with it rather than going on a hunt for a MKVI.
Nope can't say that I've seen or heard that particular recording Pete 😏 but I believe you as I did see a comparison on a MK VI Vs Yam 62 - no difference at all and I was watching the changes. 🙄

I dunno 🙄 it's all getting quite confusing and overwhelming.

I guess it comes down to personal preferences in all of it. Mpc, lig, reed and horn not discounting the player variables in all of this of course.
 
Nope can't say that I've seen or heard that particular recording Pete 😏 but I believe you as I did see a comparison on a MK VI Vs Yam 62 - no difference at all and I was watching the changes. 🙄

I dunno 🙄 it's all getting quite confusing and overwhelming.

I guess it comes down to personal preferences in all of it. Mpc, lig, reed and horn not discounting the player variables in all of this of course.
The one thing that doesn’t change is: go and try some horns, as many as is practicable.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,399
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom