Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

Thanks to @PigSquealer, being a helpful and all around awesome member here, I was able to complete my C-Melody earlier this week!

He gave alot of fantastic advice and thing I simply would not have thought of.

I really like this C Melody! It is not even remotely stuffy, and plays effortlessly.

It is a 1923 Lyon&Healy "Professional Chicago" model (Buescher stencil), with no MoP key touches. I ordered a MPC Planet C-Melody mouthpiece to go with it and am using tenor Java Green 2.5 reeds on it at the moment. I chose MM Soft Feel pads with a single rivet and per their suggestion sent SF Thick since the original pads were marshmallows. They work very well on it and feel great.

Before pics with original pads before cleaning are below.

Theres a couple of pictures mid-work with the new pads dry fit in the next post.

After pics will be in another post below.

Overall this was my first real experience fixing a sax. I previously took apart and cleaned my 1925 Martin HC alto and replaced a couple of pads, but did not take my time as I did on this. It was a great learning experience. It plays lovely from low Bb to top F. I plan to play alot with my wife who plays violin. They go well together.
 

Attachments

  • 20260223_102730.webp
    20260223_102730.webp
    69.8 KB · : 110
  • 20260223_102741.webp
    20260223_102741.webp
    54 KB · : 108
Thanks to @PigSquealer, being a helpful and all around awesome member here, I was able to complete my C-Melody earlier this week!

He gave alot of fantastic advice and things I simply would not have thought of.
Thanks for the compliment. You’ve done a fantastic job on this project. It’s very rewarding to see a member’s successfully completed project. Thanks for sharing the pictures.
Getting started off right from the beginning is very important. Helping people midway after mistakes have happened is challenging. Ya done well !
 
Trigger finger issues this last month….
This 1925 Holton is an Pre-Rudy build. A true Rudy Wiedoeft is LH bell keys.
1783124581088.webp

It arrived with some interesting extras. The cap and mouthpiece were first introduced in early August 1924. The screwdriver is time period correct, but not a factory Holton one. The reeds are most likely from the 1950’s. The Brodaus school program dated 1952. I looked up the school. It’s still there in a small town in Montana. Current population is 462. The auction purchased from was in same region.
1783125631743.webp

1783125867126.webp

1783125910030.webp


The case had a big surprise too. This is a (Pre WWll ?) Selmer Table HS* with matching lig. SN# 34101 if anyone has a SN chart to properly date please let me know.
1783126002854.webp


The neck strap, Ugg. Small town probably didn’t have a music store. Mail order from Sears ? Hand made ?
1783127037071.webp
 
The Holton case also has an interesting store badge.
1783127282082.webp


I often lookup these old stores. Results are sparse to none. Got lucky this time ! The store had a long and rich history.
1783127597950.webp

1783127671991.webp

This is likely the exact sales counter the horn was sold on. The store opened in 1918.
1783127786782.webp

I see the Holton C on left of tenor 🙌
1783127958723.webp

1783128069994.webp
 
Honestly I think my dog Dug clicked on BIN on Fleabay.
Another Couturier C this month. Case in great condition too and 100% Couturier factory original. Best I know the only maker that used Corduroy fabric inside.
1783140475333.webp


Not much in the way of case candy. Just one old sewing machine screwdriver and…. A KEY 🤩 ! It actually is correct and locks the case.
1783140730005.webp


36 C Melodies and only my other with a working key is my King.
1783141066967.webp


This horn has see some use, but well cared for. All the pads are light tan not white, so all the pads were changed at least once. Some have just a stitch. Others have rivets. Rivets nickel plated and some are brown. Brown was use during 1940’s when war related shortages occurred. So I’m guessing last service was pre 1955 ?
1783141265802.webp


The G# touch resembles an early first year Martin. Interesting that the C# & B touches have no wear. These were the most expensive C’s on the market. I read this fact many times, but I’ve yet to find a price point.
1783141802619.webp

The G# touch was probably cut shorter. It should look like this below.
1783144380180.webp

Little piggy fell over after seeing this fine regulation work. He came around when I pointed out the original end plug.
1783142225915.webp
 
As the most expensive and pro grade. These were likely purchased by working professionals. Seldom do I see these with dents, damage or signs of abuse. 99% all show long term use with good care. The one a few posts back being an outlier.
The bowfin has plating loss probably from resting on the players knee.
1783142581830.webp


The upper stack keywork plating is worn from holding with right hand.
1783142945778.webp


1783142836214.webp


I haven’t got around to weighing any yet, but I’ll bet Couturier is the heaviest. Buescher the lightest.
Couturier built a beefy horn. Look at the difference compared to a JW York key.
1783143570165.webp


Everything is slightly thicker. The spring cradles are 1.6mm thick. Probably double the thickness of others.

1783143928911.webp
 
Blimey, how many is that now, i used to blame the dog for things like this but we don't have him now so i get all the blame.
Honestly I’ve lost count. I think I have something like 34-40 C Mel tenors and from 13 different makers. From memory I have 3 Buescher, 3 Conn, 7 Couturier, 2 Evette & Schaffer, 6-8 Holton, 1 JTL, 2/3 Kings, 6 Lyon & Healy , 3 Martins, 1 Selmer New York, 1 Selmer Paris, 4 JW York & Sons.
Everyone is a different year or build. Only the JTL ( Jerome Lamy Thibouville) is a HP.
I’m reasonably certain I have one each of America makers.
Europe didn’t experience the C saxophone craze of the 1920’s like the US did. Still there are European makers I would like to have for my collection.
Cousnon, Hawks & Son, F.X Hüller , Kolhert, Oscar Adler, Rampone & Cazzani all made C tenors. H.P. or L.P. best I know. Some were keyed to low A but in HP.
The issue is finding one that’s complete and restorable along with being affordable. @ $100 price but $250 in shipping kills the deal. Honestly this has been a poor man’s hobby 10 years in the making. I don’t spend outside my budget.
Below
The tax included. See shipping…$20
1783238418137.webp


Below the buyers premium was 18%. No state tax. Shipping @ $62. Hit my door under $150.
1783238494265.webp

This below included shipping. The Buy was $80+ tax @ $8.80. $109.75 total delivered to my door.
1783238746571.webp

I think was just under $400 for the three. Haven’t bought anything since last September. January/ February before that. I do all my own work as entertainment.
My classic car habit & related work is 100% self supporting.
 
Honestly I’ve lost count. I think I have something like 34-40 C Mel tenors and from 13 different makers. From memory I have 3 Buescher, 3 Conn, 7 Couturier, 2 Evette & Schaffer, 6-8 Holton, 1 JTL, 2/3 Kings, 6 Lyon & Healy , 3 Martins, 1 Selmer New York, 1 Selmer Paris, 4 JW York & Sons.
You didn't snag that Selmer Paris for $97? You're making my own set of 20th century USA made Conn altos look pretty paltry.

But the '23 Conn "00" finish you built for me is still humming. Thanks!

1783255242300.webp
 
"My classic car habit & related work is 100% self supporting."
Pig Squeak, your caveat says it all, I do the same with mouthpieces, ligatures, instruments and electronics. I buy them try them and then flip them. Keep only the best of what works.

Now since you are collecting C Melodies that may not work for your hoard!
Definitely a want not a need!

Attempting to keep my horn inventory down.
The ideal number will be - 1 Sopranino, 3 Sopranos, 2 C Melody, 2 Alto, 3 Tenors, 2 Baritones. 2 Bb Clarinets, 1 C Clarinet, 1 Bass Clarinet and 1 flute.
I have to sell a whole bunch to meet that target. Plus buy one more C Melody.
I have 6 tenors at present and will sell 4 and buy another I want. I have 3 soprano to sell, just sold one last week so mad money on hand.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,447
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom