Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

Alto won't fit on my Conn at all. So I used a couple of tenors at first. Sounded ok, but intonation was a challenge. Would love a Morgan C or Getasax, but can't justify the cost. Next was to try Mouthpiece Planet. Price was right and intonation was good. Sounded ok, kind of close to Meyer. Eventually landed on a metal Weibster from eBay. Bigger tip, bigger sound.
Are you using an alto reed on the Weibster ? I have one too. Alto reed works best for me. The Conn Eagle is my favorite, but I think it’s been worked on. The Dr Caravan I have is challenging. Depending on the sax maker it’s great or trash. This was gifted to me.
The Planet C is ok. Very useable for the value. A good bit if you have none.
The other 22+ C Melody OE mouthpieces I have are largely uneventful.
 
Speaking of C Melody, my 1925 Martin has the tenor style crook/neck, and am curious if the straight neck like a long Alto neck would be more comfortable to play? I see Eastern Music has them on the bay for around $130 USD.
 
Are you using an alto reed on the Weibster ? I have one too. Alto reed works best for me. The Conn Eagle is my favorite, but I think it’s been worked on. The Dr Caravan I have is challenging. Depending on the sax maker it’s great or trash. This was gifted to me.
The Planet C is ok. Very useable for the value. A good bit if you have none.
The other 22+ C Melody OE mouthpieces I have are largely uneventful.
Wow, 22!

Haven't tried alto reeds, but now that you mention it, I think I will. Tenor plays ok but looks oversized for this mouthpiece. I should try alto reeds on my Mouthpiece Planet too.
 
Speaking of C Melody, my 1925 Martin has the tenor style crook/neck, and am curious if the straight neck like a long Alto neck would be more comfortable to play? I see Eastern Music has them on the bay for around $130 USD.
I find the straight neck a bit awkward TBH. Never tried the tenor style one.
 
GS Reso C Mel

Makes a Cmel not sound like you think a Cmel sounds like.
I would love to try a GS but they don't pop up used and since I only paid $600.00 for Cmelly new to my door it is hard to pay $300.00, half the price of the horn for a mouthpiece for it.

I was playing the Beechler Bellite as I bought it for my tenor and discovered it worked and that was only $150.00 all in for a Custom model. I will bide my time.

The metal MeYer J alto piece was singing last night at the wedding. I was playing with a violinist at the wedding gig. We played current pop and Indian pieces the bride wanted. I played a lot of Indian gigs, and the violinist knew and steered the bride to traditional tunes he knew. I did not bother learning the ones I didn't know. I just listened to them beforehand and played off the violinist when he took the lead. The gig went very well, I have played with this fellow before. We made huge on tips! They love to throw cash at the players.

I stopped by my Dads on the way and practiced. I swapped the leather Rovner lig that came with the MeYer with a silver Selmer M402 lig and cap which sounded better to my ear.

The piece gives a more tenor sound, and the tone is warm to the ear. It has a tight horseshoe chamber, straight side walls so the opposite of a Reso chamber piece.

Pigsqueak :optimistic: I have discovered what Cmelly's make is I will post later as not wanting to disrupt the flow of the thread.
 
I have my eye on a Runyon C Melody piece pristine with the box a 6 but the seller wants toooo much for it. He has had it posted for 4 months with no takers and won't budge on the price. Wants GS $200.00 USD money.
But the chamber looks the same as the Meyer metal Jazz piece.
1767646611896.webp

1767646667662.webp
 
Wow, 22!

Haven't tried alto reeds, but now that you mention it, I think I will. Tenor plays ok but looks oversized for this mouthpiece. I should try alto reeds on my Mouthpiece Planet too.
Think I own something like 28 C Melodies. I’m just a handful short of most all produced in L.P. Many acquired as full kits with all original contents.
1767647681580.webp

1767647732537.webp

1767647848326.webp



MPC Planet suggests trying an alto reed first.
MPC Planet C Melody Saxophone Mouthpiece - New
1767647325417.webp
 
Here is direct correspondence from Dr Caravan. This dated to 5/25/2020
Posted with permission.
The link I referred was to the other place. I have a C mouthpiece and C Sax thread there.


Hello Dr. Caravan

Regarding your C Melody mouthpiece. You noted the saxophone used for testing. Can you furnish what reed was used please. I’m curious if it was for a bass clarinet and what strength. Best to my knowledge there are no C Melody reeds available.

Sincerely,
Glenn


Greetings,

Thank you for your interest in Caravan Mouthpieces.

The C-tenor mouthpiece on the caravanmouthpieces.com web site requires a regular tenor reed, which is one of the aspects that make it more user-friendly. In rare instances, a player might need to trim a little of the butt of the reed of, but that isn't likely. While I don't play tenor very often (other than testing new mouthpieces or when the symphony needs a tenor part covered), I typically use a traditional Van Doren ("blue-box") no. 3 or 3.5.

--r.l.c.

Thank you for your follow-up message. I will see about getting that reed information added to the C-tenor listing on the web site. Should be there for sure.

Thank you also for sharing that link. I have visited saxophone forum sites very seldom, and usually because someone points me there for some specific reason. I imagine there are some useful dialogues and sharing of information there, but if I had the time to visit those sites, I'm not sure I would be able to avoid the temptation to try clarifying misunderstandings (often erroneous presumptions) that persist because they spread so widely as "fact." One entry on the page you linked me to is almost something like that. A contributor asserts that the C tenor is not considered a classical instrument. He may very well be correct in that (demographically it could probably be said about all the saxophones, for that matter), but we forget that all the saxophones, including the C tenor, were well established well prior to the development of the jazz sounds that were precursors of contemporary jazz tone qualities, and certainly prior to the development of the more jazz-oriented mouthpieces (i.e., reduced interior sizes) that made the brighter jazz sounds more attainable. When I added the C-tenor mouthpiece to the Caravan Mouthpieces line, it had nothing to do with "classical" vs. "jazz" or the like; it was a simple matter of responding to inquiries and requests from players who wanted one, and it came to the point that there had been enough of them to warrant consideration.

As for the information about the reed, I would have no objection to your sharing that on the forum if you like. (If you decide to quote me directly from my original response to you, though, please correct the grammatical error; I must have been in a hurry when I typed that.)

Best regards,
--r.l.c.
 
28 C Melodies?!! That's amazing!! I have 2. ;-)
Buescher, Conn, Couturier, Evette & Schaffer, Holton, Jeromé Thibouville Lamy, King, Lyon & Healy, Martin, Selmer, Selmer New York, York. Different finishes and different Vin / years.
Speaking of C Melody, my 1925 Martin has the tenor style crook/neck, and am curious if the straight neck like a long Alto neck would be more comfortable to play? I see Eastern Music has them on the bay for around $130 USD.
The Martin C tenon OD runs around 25mm. The size you need can be specified upon your ordering. I believe the necks from Eastern Power Neck, Eastern Music and Taishan Winds are all based off a Conn C. I have no experience or feedback to offer on any of these.

Comfort could be better for some players with either a straight neck, or a neck with the mouth pipe level with bottom of tenon.
A common complaint that Martins are too downwards.
1767682991568.webp

1767683236367.webp


The straight neck lowers the sax holding / playing position(3”?). Your reach away from your body will be further some. The angle of forearm and hands will be noticeable different.
1767683539281.webp

1767684056713.webp

IMG_0081.webp
 
Speaking of C Melody, my 1925 Martin has the tenor style crook/neck, and am curious if the straight neck like a long Alto neck would be more comfortable to play? I see Eastern Music has them on the bay for around $130 USD.
Why not buy a new horn, at $499.00 the Eastern horn comes with both a swan neck and a straight neck.
I bought my C Melody through a third party and it cost $600.00 USD delivered to my door here in Toronto. I recieved the nickel plated body model with gold keys. It plays best with the straight neck, swan was more comfortable for me.

I have no idea what company made it, but it has the same stamped bell logo as this Eastern. I spent $200.00CDN having it set up properly when I recieved it. It has more then paid for itself since recieving it. Playing in Concert allows me to walk into a gig cold, playing Klezmer, Eastern folk music or classical with a pianist or violinist without practicing or transposing music I have never seen or heard before on the fly.
1767659314982.webp

Same horn on Amazon.ca ! What makes this one worth 5 times as much?🤨 Delivery is only $5.54 though! LOL
1767659798152.webp
 
@PigSquealer Thank you so very much for the comprehensive C Melody neck comparison. Very helpful.

@Tonehole Good to know about the EM new C Melody. Didn't know they made one. I have an EM gold plated copper tenor neck that produces a nice deep rich dark tone on my Yamaha Tenor. They make quality products in my limited experience with them.
 
Congratulations to whoever bought this fine Couturier C.
#13395 is currently the highest known serial number for any E.A. Couturier produced instrument.
1769147801865.webp

The number that supersedes it (13749 alto) is questionable. A 3000 number sax is too low. Couturier sax manufacturing started in Aug. 1922 @ #6960- C Melody. This is lowest on record.
13748 has been documented as L&H Makers
1769148632805.webp
 
Someone will certainly enjoy playing this horn. I’ve been playing the previous youngest C Melody (13279) for a few years now, and it is an easy, smooth player with it’s own voice and personality. As a beginner I also have a Yamaha (for better intonation, I was told), but my C-built C-Mel is just as good, for me anyway (ymmv).
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,449
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom