Ads
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 4,243
- Location
- North West UK

They aren't fussy about what octave I play in.C mel will only take you down to Bb in bass clef, though. You need a bari (speaking of lugging heavy instruments around...)! That transposition is a piece of cake, you just pretend it's treble clef and adjust the key sig/accidentals.


I meant if you're playing baritone, sorry if I didn't make that clear.. To get a C you play an A.
In the long term, yes. Your transposing skills will stay with you (+ you can play those pesky F horn parts). Your C Mel chops won't unless you keep working on them.LOL, and you think this is easier than learning to get a decent sound out of a C mel and carrying two cases into orchestra!
Prejudice.What is it that makes a C Mel so tame when the alto and tenor on either side can scream?
They were designed to be tame. That was the point of them.What is it that makes a C Mel so tame when the alto and tenor on either side can scream?
In the long term, yes. Your transposing skills will stay with you (+ you can play those pesky F horn parts). Your C Mel chops won't unless you keep working on them.
Yes.So: When a horn plays a written C, it sounds as an F (so a perfect 5th down)... So in order to sound like a horn playing a C, I would need to play a G - ie a fourth down from what's written??
Yes.
Or you could take up the French horn 🙂 I could recommend someone to sell you a nice one for a very reasonable price.
I think I'd better stick to saxophones for now - I don't keep up with practising those (and a full time job, and a single-handed smallholding, and learning to ride a motorbike, and forget the house and garden) let alone learning the French horn too! 
I'm not so sure. I tried many different alto and tenor mouthpieces on mine and it sucked the life out of all of them.They take less air than a tenor (smaller, with a narrower cone angle), so they can't make quite as much noise, but there doesn't seem to be a good reason why they can't make a similar sort of noise, on a slightly smaller scale.
I think the mouthpiece has to be the biggest factor - assuming there aren't any serious leaks, which an old one is likely to have, unless it's been looked at properly.
Ed Pillinger seems to have a C melody mouthpiece - bronzite NY from the photos in the 'What's new' photos, but I can't find any info about it, so I don't know which NY.I'm not so sure. I tried many different alto and tenor mouthpieces on mine and it sucked the life out of all of them.
