Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

C mel will only take you down to Bb in bass clef, though. You need a bari (speaking of lugging heavy instruments around...)! That transposition is a piece of cake, you just pretend it's treble clef and adjust the key sig/accidentals.
They aren't fussy about what octave I play in.

I don't get the bass clef bit. Follow me through this and see where I go wrong.....

So the note written below is a concert pitch C. It looks like an A, if you pretend it's written in treble clef. So I play it as a written A, on my Bb tenor, and it therefore 'comes out' as a G.

image.webp

It works doing that in tenor clef I think - again, check my logic?

The note written below is a C. But if you pretend it's written in the treble clef, it looks like a D. Play a D on my Bb tenor and it 'comes out' as a C,

image.webp
 
The first example (bass clef read as treble clef) works for Eb transposition - an A on an alto (or baritone) plays a concert C - they play three semitones higher than written, give or take an octave.

I'm still wondering about the accidentals and key signatures part. I'll shut up and wait for Martin to explain it properly 🙂
 
So the note written below is a concert pitch C. It looks like an A, if you pretend it's written in treble clef. So I play it as a written A, on my Bb tenor, and it therefore 'comes out' as a G.



It works doing that in tenor clef I think - again, check my logic?
I meant if you're playing baritone, sorry if I didn't make that clear.. To get a C you play an A.

Key signatures: add 3 sharps for bari/alto 2 for tenor/sop/clarinet /trumpet (or remove flats)

Some of the accidentals need to be interpreted carefully. Eg suppose part is in concert pitch and the key is C. Then bari is playing in A, tenor in D. If you see a Bb, then that's a flattened G# (bari) or C# (tenor) ie a G or a C respecively. The ones you really have to watch out for are the natural signs which can go up or down. Sounds horrible but you get the hang of it with practice, like everything else. Eventually you just know what the notes are without thinking about it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
LOL, and you think this is easier than learning to get a decent sound out of a C mel and carrying two cases into orchestra!
In the long term, yes. Your transposing skills will stay with you (+ you can play those pesky F horn parts). Your C Mel chops won't unless you keep working on them.
 
I never got the Sakkusu to really let its hair down but didn`t have it long enough to find the perfect mouthpiece and this I think is the issue ..

I`d guess that 99% of people use either Alto or Tenor pieces on them because there is no real choice in Proper C-Mel ones and the modern Alto style necks are designed to tune with Alto pieces which probably aren`t suitable . given a decent selection of top C-Mel pieces and a C-Mel optimised neck, they`d no doubt wail with the best of them
 
In the long term, yes. Your transposing skills will stay with you (+ you can play those pesky F horn parts). Your C Mel chops won't unless you keep working on them.

Hmmm - so playing a pesky F horn part seems to be in my immediate future! He wants me on the Bb tenor doing that.

So: When a horn plays a written C, it sounds as an F (so a perfect 5th down). When I play a written C, it sounds as a Bb (so a major 2nd down). So in order to sound like a horn playing a C, I would need to play a G - ie a fourth down from what's written??
 
They take less air than a tenor (smaller, with a narrower cone angle), so they can't make quite as much noise, but there doesn't seem to be a good reason why they can't make a similar sort of noise, on a slightly smaller scale.

I think the mouthpiece has to be the biggest factor - assuming there aren't any serious leaks, which an old one is likely to have, unless it's been looked at properly.

I've heard classical alto sax playing that sounded like an oboe, to me, until he went a bit lower in the range, so it's possible to really alter the sound of those too - to the point of just not sounding like a saxophone any more. At least not the sound I normally associate with one anyway.

It's a shame the Zinner C melody mouthpieces cost quite so much. Their regular tenor mouthpieces are more affordable, but I suppose it's economies of scale. Their Cs are still cheaper than Selmer tenor mouthpieces though.
 
Yes.

Or you could take up the French horn 🙂 I could recommend someone to sell you a nice one for a very reasonable price.
:rofl: I think I'd better stick to saxophones for now - I don't keep up with practising those (and a full time job, and a single-handed smallholding, and learning to ride a motorbike, and forget the house and garden) let alone learning the French horn too! :w00t:

(I have emailed and asked if he's decided what parts he wants me to play so I can transpose them in advance - but he probably doesn't know yet, cos it depends who turns up - saxophones 'fill in' in this mostly-classical scratch orchestra.)
 
They take less air than a tenor (smaller, with a narrower cone angle), so they can't make quite as much noise, but there doesn't seem to be a good reason why they can't make a similar sort of noise, on a slightly smaller scale.

I think the mouthpiece has to be the biggest factor - assuming there aren't any serious leaks, which an old one is likely to have, unless it's been looked at properly.
I'm not so sure. I tried many different alto and tenor mouthpieces on mine and it sucked the life out of all of them.
 
I'm not so sure. I tried many different alto and tenor mouthpieces on mine and it sucked the life out of all of them.
Ed Pillinger seems to have a C melody mouthpiece - bronzite NY from the photos in the 'What's new' photos, but I can't find any info about it, so I don't know which NY.
But from what everyone's said about his mouthpieces, he's likely to have made it specifically to suit the Cmel. £210 - I will have to save up.......
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,455
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom