I was going to post more about my Thomann C melody in Ads's Sakkusu thread, on the grounds that it may well be off the same production line - though it remains to be seen whether it's the exact same version. Maybe not.
I was thinking of this thread as one for classic C melodys, originally, but that's not what I put in the title, so I'll just talk about it here, instead.... EDIT: Oops. Yes, that is what I put in the title. Oh well. I'm talking about it anyway. More context 😀
I like it. Definitely. I even like the included mouthpiece (Zinner 4C), which I didn't think I would. It has to be further out on the cork than I expected though - with the neck adjuster wound out almost as far as it will go without wobbling, I just need to push the mouthpiece on far enough to get a decent grip. That was with a medium soft Fibracell alto reed though (a couple of years old). Maybe that's not the ideal reed, and the right one might tune a little differently.
I couldn't get anything useful with a Rico Graftonite on - I tried my A7, with the same reed, which would work on an alto. Very odd. Partly, I couldn't get it in tune (too sharp) because the neck just didn't seem long enough to take it. I'm used to pushing mouthpieces a long way down onto the cork to get them where I want them too - not necessarily where they really ought to be, just where I like the tuning, with my embouchure (which no doubt isn't great).
So, my initial conclusion is that just any alto mouthpiece may well not work on it. The Zinner 4C does though - and it appears to be more open than I was expecting. They don't give the details of the facing / tip opening on their site.
I could play the full range, almost immediately, which is great, apart from the physical difficulty of reaching a low B or Bb (due to smallish hands, and not great ergonomics, in that respect). It needs the adjusters tweaking too, because if I lean on the C# key while I'm doing it, it pops the C# key cup open - not a fault, just sloppy set up. I'm used to that, so it's not a problem. I just haven't got to it yet.
The side key placement isn't as bad as I was expecting, with the standard thumb position, but the rest does dig in to the side of your thumb a bit, as Ads mentioned in his review of the Sakkusu.
I found I could reach side Bb and C easily enough, but I had to move my hand up to find the high E side key. Even so, I could live with that, and the thumb rest comes off, so I could just have filed down that edge to make it more comfortable.
Instead, I've adapted another thumb rest - a cheap alto one from Dawkes, for about £2.50, which is a little longer, for a higher thumb position.
I made a little wedge out of tough, slightly flexible plastic, to go between the new thumb rest and the plate it sits on. That tilts the rest out a little bit, so it clears the F# key cup, but only moves my thumb back a few millimetres. I can now tilt / rotate the rest too, which will hopefully make it more comfortable.
I need to refine it a bit more - it's possible to rotate the rest to a position where the F# cup can just make contact, but it's not a position I'd have it in to play. I'll try to improve on it though.
I needed a longer screw, of course. It's M4 thread. It can't be too long because there's only so much depth for it to screw into, and digging it in further wouldn't be a good idea. I didn't have one with the nice big dome head, so I've used a short countersunk head bolt, and a washer.
I haven't played with it like that, yet. I've just held it and twiddled the keys. So far, it seems promising though - and I can always just put the other rest back.
I'll take some pictures when I'm feeling less lazy.