Saxophones C Melody Saxophones

Yep, those are what Dawkes are selling, Jim. It's kind of their own brand, I think - or maybe they just have a deal with them. Their budget/student range of instruments are called Windcraft too.
Prof Anton Weinberg who is based at Dawkes designs all of the Windcraft mpcs I believe. Nice guy, very helpful and a blooming good player!
 
I have a Weinberg D3 Bb clarinet mouthpiece (ebay). It's currently on my C clarinet, which is built to take one. It's one of my favourites. I've tried (i.e. spent money on) a few different Vandorens that I like a lot less.
Google him! He is a talented man and very humble. Extremely helpful as they all are at Dawkes
 
I was going to post more about my Thomann C melody in Ads's Sakkusu thread, on the grounds that it may well be off the same production line - though it remains to be seen whether it's the exact same version. Maybe not.

I was thinking of this thread as one for classic C melodys, originally, but that's not what I put in the title, so I'll just talk about it here, instead.... EDIT: Oops. Yes, that is what I put in the title. Oh well. I'm talking about it anyway. More context 😀

I like it. Definitely. I even like the included mouthpiece (Zinner 4C), which I didn't think I would. It has to be further out on the cork than I expected though - with the neck adjuster wound out almost as far as it will go without wobbling, I just need to push the mouthpiece on far enough to get a decent grip. That was with a medium soft Fibracell alto reed though (a couple of years old). Maybe that's not the ideal reed, and the right one might tune a little differently.

I couldn't get anything useful with a Rico Graftonite on - I tried my A7, with the same reed, which would work on an alto. Very odd. Partly, I couldn't get it in tune (too sharp) because the neck just didn't seem long enough to take it. I'm used to pushing mouthpieces a long way down onto the cork to get them where I want them too - not necessarily where they really ought to be, just where I like the tuning, with my embouchure (which no doubt isn't great).

So, my initial conclusion is that just any alto mouthpiece may well not work on it. The Zinner 4C does though - and it appears to be more open than I was expecting. They don't give the details of the facing / tip opening on their site.

I could play the full range, almost immediately, which is great, apart from the physical difficulty of reaching a low B or Bb (due to smallish hands, and not great ergonomics, in that respect). It needs the adjusters tweaking too, because if I lean on the C# key while I'm doing it, it pops the C# key cup open - not a fault, just sloppy set up. I'm used to that, so it's not a problem. I just haven't got to it yet.

The side key placement isn't as bad as I was expecting, with the standard thumb position, but the rest does dig in to the side of your thumb a bit, as Ads mentioned in his review of the Sakkusu.

I found I could reach side Bb and C easily enough, but I had to move my hand up to find the high E side key. Even so, I could live with that, and the thumb rest comes off, so I could just have filed down that edge to make it more comfortable.

Instead, I've adapted another thumb rest - a cheap alto one from Dawkes, for about £2.50, which is a little longer, for a higher thumb position.

I made a little wedge out of tough, slightly flexible plastic, to go between the new thumb rest and the plate it sits on. That tilts the rest out a little bit, so it clears the F# key cup, but only moves my thumb back a few millimetres. I can now tilt / rotate the rest too, which will hopefully make it more comfortable.

I need to refine it a bit more - it's possible to rotate the rest to a position where the F# cup can just make contact, but it's not a position I'd have it in to play. I'll try to improve on it though.

I needed a longer screw, of course. It's M4 thread. It can't be too long because there's only so much depth for it to screw into, and digging it in further wouldn't be a good idea. I didn't have one with the nice big dome head, so I've used a short countersunk head bolt, and a washer.

I haven't played with it like that, yet. I've just held it and twiddled the keys. So far, it seems promising though - and I can always just put the other rest back.

I'll take some pictures when I'm feeling less lazy.
 
Last edited:
Google him! He is a talented man and very humble. Extremely helpful as they all are at Dawkes

I did look him up once. I watched a youtube video where he compared one of his mouthpieces to a couple of others, by playing them. I thought it was a bit of an uneven comparison, because he used the same reed on all three - and only his really suited that strength reed 🙂 It was still interesting to watch though.

He seems to prefer softer reeds, which I prefer too - hard reeds might be what's needed for playing classical music really loud, but that's not what I want from my instruments. So, his designs are probably more suitable for me than Vandorens.

I like the Yamaha customs (ebonites) too, incidentally. I think they've discontinued them though. I bought a 6CM on ebay as my first decent clarinet mouthpiece. I really liked it, but I never could get to the top of the clarion register with it. I realised much later, the tip rail is a bit knackered. I've now bought a 5CM - Ackermans have some Customs left, at a fair price. I like that too, and it reminds me a bit of the Weinberg. I can get a similar range on both, with the same reed. I can with any of the Vandorens too, but there's a lot more random squeaking involved.
 
Last edited:
Hi Andy, I'm away at the moment, and only seeing threads sporadically.

I've had a C mel for quite a while, a vintage Conn, and have tried a number of different mouthpiece options on it. I tend to use a tenor Brilhart Level Air 9, but I have a curved Aquilasax neck for it. Makes a good noise. For anyone playing with a conventional neck, I'd suggest either a Rico Metalite or Graftonite tenor piece. What you need to do is slice 1cm off the shank, using a junior hacksaw, or similar. Then you will have a good modern mouthpiece which will tune on a C mel for next to no money.
 
Cool. Thanks, jonf.

I'm not sure sawing shorter will be needed on mine but I'll see. The neck on mine seems weirdly short, based on my attempt at using the Gratonite alto mouthpiece on it - as far as I can see, you can't, basically.

There's lots of cork left with the included Zinner 4C C melody mouthpiece too. Maybe the neck is a different length than on the Sakkusu that Ads had. I suppose it could be so it can take an unmodified tenor mouthpiece, at the expense of some, most or almost all alto mouthpieces not fitting properly.

I have a Graftonite A7 tenor one, and a Yamaha 7C, from when I briefly owned a Jericho tenor. And a couple of Fibracell tenor reeds - softish and medium softish, I think. I expect playing it with a tenor reed and mouthpiece will make quite a difference to the sound. I like it with the Zinner, but it's good to try different things out.

I don't get to play just whenever I want, unfortunately. I have to wait for the neighbour above my flat to be out. Hopefully tomorrow, or the next day maybe, I'll get to play with it a bit more, and try out different things.
 
I tried a Grafton B5 on the Sak and it tuned perfect , worked well too - so well, I gave it away with the sax when it went - I`m not a fan of the Graftonite pieces at all but the Sakkusu C-Melody was the one sax I could tolerate it on .......... sounded better with my LAW LCM 7 On though (as all Altos do also) 😀
 
Yep, I'm thinking quite possibly the neck on the Thomann is shorter than on the Sakkusu - maybe a different iteration of the design, if it really is from the same factory.

I needed the micro adjuster adjusted out as far as it would go, almost, with the Zinner, and it wasn't pushed on very far at all - less than an inch. I couldn't get the Graftonite A7 alto one to stay on and be in tune - it was much too sharp, and making a weirdly thin sound. It felt like there was a sock stuffed up it too... so I guess it was probably leaking, from trying to get it out far enough...

I may be close to the source of the mooing problem 🙂 If you put totally the wrong mouthpiece on, that's probably what happens. It works great with the Zinner.

I do have other alto mouthpieces I can try, but they all fit about the same on my Trevor James, so I'm guessing there won't be one that works with it. Fitting a tenor one sounds like a much better prospect, because there's all that extra cork I haven't used yet 😀
 
I have a B5 too, Ads. I wasn't all that keen on it on my alto - it was okay, just not my idea of fun, somehow. I liked the A7, but I bought it a Super Session F, and now just use that.

Anyway, I'll give it a go. I'm not actually expecting it to work with this one though - same length, and internal bore for fitting on the neck as the A7, so it probably isn't going to fit either, unlesss maybe I try for a C# or D melody sax. Lots of good tunes in D 😉
 
The Sak I had was Rose-Brass (light Bronze) and it weighed as much as a Yamaha 23 Tenor - the keywork was typical high end Chinese (well made but heavy) - they`ve still not seem to have managed the light but quality build which the Taiwanese have mastered - at least it wasn`t usual Chinese (cheap) .

I`ve always doubted that the Thomann was the same horn due to the design and that Sax.co actually commissioned the maker (which sounds like DongBu but isn`t as that`s a Korean image sensor maker) to do the horn as is -- a kinda stretched out Yani Alto .. there`s no saying where the design originally came from or who made it first, I believe there was an Antigua of similar design but with the Tenor style neck .. others simply copy the vintage Heiffer designs but there aren`t many about even so
 
Yep. Mine is bronze looking and heavy too. It feels pretty sturdy.

It's always the case that there are more brands of Chinese tech than there are factories making it. Model plane motors are a case in point. You can pay a tenner, or pay £40-£50 for the same motor in a posh box, with a sexy brand name on it. Take your pick. It's the same motor. There might be better quality control on the dearer one, but there probably isn't.

In this case, it may well not be the same sax. It might have a lot of parts in common though, and come off the same production line.

I'm inclined to think they made these with a shorter neck for some reason (as yet, I'm not sure what that was), then Thomann bundled them with a mouthpiece that works with that neck - not a cheap one, incidentally. Zinners are among the more reasonably priced ebonite mpcs, and quite respectable. Boutique clarinet mouthpiece makers often use their blanks, as I understand it.
 
Maybe they are the same then .. some Saks were Bronze and some weren`t , I got lucky and mine was - it`s proper bronze too not a lacquer colouring (you can tell as the pillars are different to the body/bow/bell) ......... I`d stick with the Zimmer MPc - I didn`t get one with the Sak , I believe they come without anything new too
 
Maybe they are the same then .. some Saks were Bronze and some weren`t , I got lucky and mine was - it`s proper bronze too not a lacquer colouring .... I`d stick with the Zimmer MPc - I didn`t get one with the Sak , I believe they come without anything new too

Cool. Yes, it does strike me as died in the wool, rather than lacquered over some sort of brass. I wondered how good a deal the Sakkusu was - paying extra for a good set up is fine, if they do one, but I wasn't impressed with the condition of the Vibratosax I bought from them (weird plastic beast). I suppose, to be fair, they just didn't know enough about those though.

I like the Zinner, so if that's the only type of mouthpiece in the entire world that fits it, I'll just stick with those 🙂 There are wider facings to try, when I'm feeling flush. About £80, IIRC, so not too bad, as these things go.

I've just tried the Yam 7C tenor mpc for fit. It feels a touch wobbly, but it's firm enough if it's pushed up against the end of the micro tuner - which might be where it belongs. I'd want to expand the cork, if I was using that permanently, and I'm not going to, but I might try a bit of PTFE plumbers tape if needed, just to see how it sounds.

I like the size of alto mouthpieces and reeds better - they're closer to a clarinet, which I've been attempting to play for longer. Having a tenor one in my mouth felt less comfortable, if I put enough of it in to play properly.

I'm not very good at tonguing, but I was worse at it on the tenor. I didn't have long to get used to one, of course, but I'm already used to alto sized ones.


I have one ODD no name modern mouthpiece in my drawer. Slightly too big for an alto, much too small for a tenor.
Could it be a C-Mel?

Could be! Are you in a photo taking mood? I'm not, but I always admire it in others 😀
 
...I got lucky and mine was - it`s proper bronze too not a lacquer colouring (you can tell as the pillars are different to the body/bow/bell)

Hmm... I've just had a look, and I couldn't swear to it about the pillars. They seem different, but it could just be the way they catch the light. I can see a small mark on one where someone slipped with a screwdriver, and it looks like it scratched through lacquer. I'm not about to scratch the body to compare it though 🙂

The inside of the bow section is unpolished, or unlacquered, and looks a different shade, but it could just be the effect of the rougher surface. To me, the outer surface of the body, bow and bell does looks like polished metal, rather than lacquered brass (as on my alto, trumpets, cornets, etc). I can't be sure though. I'm not going to obsess over it, anyway.

But yes, it weighs quite a lot for its size. I always play sitting down, so I don't mind that. It seems more robust than my alto.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,458
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom