Saxophones Better Sax Session vs. Selmer Signature vs… tenors at NAMM

I suspect then that the left thumb rest placement is only a problem for those like me, afflicted with the ability to palm... and even juggle... basketballs.

Ryan is the first guy you see when walking in through the main entrance to the Symposium vendor room at the Selmer table. A genuinely nice guy for what he's there for. But yeah, the big difference with NAMM and the Symposium is that the former is geared towards the industry when the latter is purely a gift for players given all the performance options in addition to a room full of horns, and now these days more mouthpieces to try. The very best part? Very few guitars are spotted. If at all.
Yeah well, you’ve got fat mitts. That can be as challenging as thimble fingers. I have a King 662 tenor that my LH pinky is at least an inch too short. I’m completely worthless at any ball larger than a hardball baseball.
How your fat mitts work that beautiful ‘20s curved SOP is really dedication and love of music.

Ryan is really a fun engaging guy. The right person for the job for sure.

NAMM I’m sure is extremely different than the Symposium. Like a collector’s show with watches is different from a watch show. Different crowd.
At least NAMM keeps woodwinds separate from the guitar, drums & others. The only painful encounter was at the Chateau booth. The neighbor vendor of accordions had a mariachi band playing a demo. Steve, Liggy & Soybean had bad timing luck.

This area below is about the size of a football field.
1769560191154.webp
 
You only go around once, if you can afford it enjoy it.

I am locked on my Series III tenor and my trio of Jupiter Artists, steady reliable work horses. I gig a lot so my gear more than pays for itself yet recently I am flirting with new horns to me. I am not a flipper. I have no time or expertise for that but when a nice clean horn presents itself I may buy if at a decent price. Always buy 2nd hand at a price that allows me to send it down the road without cost hopefully. If I were to buy new I would have to commit to a long term relationship.

I am not recording for pay just playing and enjoying the scene and playing setups that work best for me at the moment.

This attached review below gives me pause as I am considering buying a CSS80 soprano. Now I get tempted by Pig squeaks & @lukehuang77 review on the new Jups! My Artist Jups are about 15 years old, bought new with the soprano and tenor overhauled with Pristini pads and new springs two years ago. Pads were shredded and a broken spring on the tenor when I finally sent it in.

"Wrecking Crew member @lukehuang77 did the test drive. “Way better sound and easier to play than my CAS80 Chateau.” Short of doing a repad on his 80 I can’t make it any better. Although I will say at 19 years old it has zero mechanical wear issues. I’m the first person to service it."

Keep the reviews coming "Wrecking crew"!
In all fairness the Chateau is still a quality product equal to Jupiter. Just different. Think of this like choosing between equal price point automobiles. Magazines or report threads only get you so far. Your mileage may vary !
It would be interesting to do a side by side comparison of your old Jupiter to the same age Chateau. I think both (yours & Luke’s) are around a 2007 vintage ?
Each currently available has evolved. So ?
 
In all fairness the Chateau is still a quality product equal to Jupiter. Just different. Think of this like choosing between equal price point automobiles. Magazines or report threads only get you so far. Your mileage may vary !
It would be interesting to do a side by side comparison of your old Jupiter to the same age Chateau. I think both (yours & Luke’s) are around a 2007 vintage ?
Each currently available has evolved. So ?
I was thinking the same thing, my Jupiter Artist had a total overhaul two years ago and it had Pristini pads installed at that time. I bought it close to 2008 it was a discontinued model a dead stock inventory clear out to make room for the next model generation.
They must have improved tuning and action over that time. But still a great horn to play.
 
…
Still consumers first impression feedback is important.
Not bringing your products in the very best condition to an international show is just stupid.
“Stupid” or lazy. Sometimes there’s little difference.

Ever hear the axiom “Every performance is an audition for your next gig”? It applies here too. I cannot imagine that they are not aware of musicians reporting their impressions on the interweb.
 
The Jupiter altos impressed me. Was a nice surprise to see such a well made product. I couldn’t find a single flaw on the two display altos. The not in public yet JAS1150Q and the JAS1100GOQ in "Gilded Onyx" finish.
The keywork action was smooth as warm butter. Touch feel firm but not by much. For calloused finger tips a positive contact was noticeable (unlike a Conn 6M).

Wrecking Crew member @lukehuang77 did the test drive. “Way better sound and easier to play than my CAS80 Chateau.” Short of doing a repad on his 80 I can’t make it any better. Although I will say at 19 years old it has zero mechanical wear issues. I’m the first person to service it.

Luke was playing the 1150 and didn’t get a picture.
The JAS1100GOQ in Gilded Onyx was beautiful. I especially liked the LH adjustable height palm keys.

View attachment 32694
To be honest, this JAS1100GOQ fits my hands the best. The actions are smooth and quiet, and I like the adjustable height palm keys. If I am going to buy a new alto sax, this will be the one I choose...although the Conn was excellent, too.
 
On a hunch….Some vendors don’t bring everything to generate new contacts. Post show business calls.
First this is a trade show. Makers and distributors to retailers.
Second tier attendees are the pro working musicians testing products.
There were very few low end student / intermediate models on the floor. Most retailers already know this level of goods.
The new Conn products being the exception.

FWIW overall most all saxophones were in better than average mechanical condition. Far from being at their best, but fairly representative of what Joe consumer would receive on ordering.
The playability setup on 90%+ was disappointing. I witnessed a record amount of mouthpieces shoved almost all in.
Our Wrecking Crew ( aka West Coast Contingent) included. Playing style or mouthpiece didn’t matter.
@skeller047 on Rampone playing Jazz.
@lukehuang77 on Confirmation playing Classical / Gospel
@lig playing Funk

View attachment 32691
@PigSquealer Thank you so much for taking me to this booth; it's the first sax I played that day. This horn is the most expensive alto sax I've ever played. Very smooth; no "force" is needed to play any key. I would say it's "almost" perfect. My only dislike is the RH side high E key; it's way too close to one of the long rods.
 
Wrecking Crew funkateer brief recap:

Played the CONNfirmation. Better than expected. Not $7K good though. 🙂

I hope the whole project does well.


Played the new Wanne Link. Nice. Not replacing the Robusto nice but a solid offering.
I also like my Lakshmi more than any Link I've ever played.

Wouldn’t pay $775 for it but $300-$450 or so for a great Link? Would probably do well at that price point. There are just so many good pieces out there. The whole booth seemed very excited and the guy from Babbitt was really stoked.


Was a real pleasure meeting Ryan Lillywhite - engaging, enthusiastic and informative.
Very open and willing to share/clarify. Definitely appreciated the interaction. Left me with a much more positive take on Conn/Selmer tbh.

Never tried a Signature but underwhelmed by the Supreme last year. Disappointed that R&C didn’t bring a copper R1 alto. Relieved at the same time because I may not have been able to resist.

Forestone horns looked great and played well.

Keilwerth - I remain a fan of the sound but they don’t feel good to me and altissimo is too much work for me on them. Weird but consistently my experience. It's a me thing vs. Keilwerth but it'll keep me from ever getting one of their tenors. Not quite the same difficulty with alto.

Then again - I have an absolutely beautiful P Mauriat Black Pearl that is a stunning looker and a solid player.

This year my favorite alto was a Yani Elite. Very responsive. Malleable sound. Best keywork ever imo.

Picked up a backup Jazzlab Saxholder. So nice having the horn held slightly away from your body - much easier on the thumbs.

Bought another bag of Silverstein mouthpiece patches. I think their stuff is generally overpriced 😀 but love the patches. Best I've ever used.

Spent a lot of time at the Cloudvocal booth. I remain a big fan of their gear and the people there.

It's just perfect for the weekend warrior player such as myself. Receiver with built in EQ and effects that you can power by power bank. No body pack on the transmitter / clip on mic. LOVE that.

Better against dropouts/signal loss than the NUX B6 in my experience. I've played in crowded settings where some of the guys using the NUX had interference issues and I did not. I haven't tried the B6 Pro so no opinion on how that one compares.

I have a NUX B7PSM 5.8GHz IEM kit but will be selling that off as I've picked up the Cloudvocal Eversync IEM. The NUX B7 Pro setup looks interesting - I didn't get a chance to try it but like that it is a full on stereo IEM.

If you don't play with effects at all I think the Evno mic sound a bit better but I always like to have a little reverb and delay and prefer to roll off my highs a bit so the overall package of the Cloudvocal Prime is the best solution for my use case.


Biggest surprise - a no name Chinese horn. Matte black. $508. Played it and couldn't believe how good it was. Went back to the booth to buy it and another player just purchased it.

Played a tenor at the same booth. Meh. Oh well. Wasn't meant to be. I need another alto like I need an additional hole on the head anyway. 🙂

If you put a gun to my head and said you need to buy an alto today I would still go with Ishimori. Back in November I had a chance to visit Ishimori again for fun and played the Super Custom X. That is my favorite alto period. Loved it.

Fun connecting IRL with the rest of the West Coast contingent aka Wrecking Crew.

Sorry I missed you, Luke!
 
Last edited:
This year my favorite alto was a Yani Elite. Very responsive. Malleable sound. Best keywork ever imo.

...

Biggest surprise - a no name Chinese horn. Matte black. $508. Played it and couldn't believe how good it was. Went back to the booth to buy it and another player just purchased it.

Played a tenor at the same booth. Meh. Oh well. Wasn't meant to be. I need another alto like I need an additional hole on the head anyway. 🙂

...

If you put a gun to my head and said you need to buy an alto today I would still go with Ishimori. Back in November I had a chance to visit Ishimori again for fun and played the Super Custom X. That is my favorite alto period. Loved it.
Agree with you, the Yani Elite was fantastic; fits better than AWO37 in my hands.

The Matte black no name Chinese horn, I heard it's a "Keilwerth-inspired" design. They sold it right after you played it; they wouldn't allow me to try. And, other "Selmer-inspired" horns weren't as impressive to me, although the prices were unbelievable low.

"If you put a gun to my head and said you need to buy an alto today I would still go with Ishimori." I didn't see this horn...how can I miss it?
 
Agree with you, the Yani Elite was fantastic; fits better than AWO37 in my hands.

The Matte black no name Chinese horn, I heard it's a "Keilwerth-inspired" design. They sold it right after you played it; they wouldn't allow me to try. And, other "Selmer-inspired" horns weren't as impressive to me, although the prices were unbelievable low.

"If you put a gun to my head and said you need to buy an alto today I would still go with Ishimori." I didn't see this horn...how can I miss it?

Sorry - I should have clarified. We were in Japan in November and I had a chance to try the alto and just released tenor Super Custom X horns.

Last year at NAMM my favorite tenor was a surprise - it was the TJ Raw XS. Great player. Husky sound. Loved it.

Echoing a recurring theme - setup is a huge part of the the deal. Last year the Yamahas I tried weren't in very good adjustment. Disappointing. My main alto is an old 62S and it outplayed everything at the Yamaha booth.

Ishimori horns are just set up perfectly imo.
 
Played the CONNfirmation. Better than expected. Played the new Wanne Link. Nice. Not replacing the Robusto nice but a solid offering.
I have been reading comments in this thread on the various familiar faces in this forum sampling the new Conn-Selmer CONNfirmation. For $7K US price tag, one would expect it to be worthy of its price, glad to hear that it did make a good debut.
Wouldn’t pay $7K for it but $3-4K? Would probably at that price point. There are just so many good pieces out there. The whole booth seemed very excited and the guy from Babbitt was really stoked.
It would not surprise me that there may be a future follow-up with a model in a simpler standard finish or in several finishes from basic to better. Thus one in standard or tint lacquer with maybe nickel plated keys could be offered in the $4k mark.

For me these are pipe (oops! sax) 😉 dreams. My GAS though humbler are all decent players.

But it is good to hear that there are some decent saxes being debuted. Some with further tweaking by our seasoned repair maestros would bring even greater smiles.
 
Biggest surprise - a no name Chinese horn. Matte black. $508. Played it and couldn't believe how good it was. Went back to the booth to buy it and another player just purchased it.
By mid day Saturday that vendor had one tenor and a couple trumpets left. No clue was the maker or who the seller is. Sing & Site link is all in Chinese. Maybe Luke can help on that ?
Funny you, we all followed you back to that booth after your findings. The seller stated the black tenor as “JK” like in build. A polite way of saying copy. It did sound good. @ $5k less than real JK makes pulling the trigger easier.
 
I have been reading comments in this thread on the various familiar faces in this forum sampling the new Conn-Selmer CONNfirmation. For $7K US price tag, one would expect it to be worthy of its price, glad to hear that it did make a good debut.

It would not surprise me that there may be a future follow-up with a model in a simpler standard finish or in several finishes from basic to better. Thus one in standard or tint lacquer with maybe nickel plated keys could be offered in the $4k mark.

For me these are pipe (oops! sax) 😉 dreams. My GAS though humbler are all decent players.

But it is good to hear that there are some decent saxes being debuted. Some with further tweaking by our seasoned repair maestros would bring even greater smiles.

That was the only thing I couldn't get Ryan to answer definitively. I'm pretty sure you're right - there will be a similar model that isn't a limited edition but essentially the same horn.

And yes - the value of a tech that can set up a horn to your taste and preferences cannot be overstated.

@PigSquealer - still having a hard time getting over how good that super cheap alto was! 😀
 
@PigSquealer Thank you so much for taking me to this booth; it's the first sax I played that day. This horn is the most expensive alto sax I've ever played. Very smooth; no "force" is needed to play any key. I would say it's "almost" perfect. My only dislike is the RH side high E key; it's way too close to one of the long rods.
You played the ConnFirmation first. Second was the New Conn 411 behind it to the right. I don’t think anyone has reported on this one.
Thanks for noting the side key issue.
Reposting this picture again as the player contact is already visible.
IMG_2327.webp
 
The Wrecking Crew. I like it! We have a name for our east coast group, but it's a long story. I'll just give the punchline: The Aristocrats!
Since my most recent acquisition in mobility, my all terrain walker, if I were to form a local group, I guess we could call it:

The Mechanised Coffin Dodgers.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,336
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom