Saxophones Better Sax Session vs. Selmer Signature vs… tenors at NAMM

@skeller047

I believe Bob Mintzer now plays an Eastman (?)
They even have a 52nd Street that was designed with his input (well, that's what they say anyway).
I played it in London a litle over a year ago and I liked it very much, especialy with the M-neck ("M" from Mintzer). It has a very rich sound, remided me of my 10m. To me it sounded and played quite similar to the Rampone & Cazzani R1-Jazz. Both of these horns were very interesting to me.
 
At the Eastman booth, the tenor was nice, but low C#, B and Bb wouldn’t play. The little arm on the RH stack key had come loose. @PigSquealer asked the manager for a screwdriver, got one, and proceeded to do 5 minutes of regulation. The horn played like a dream afterwards.
Now I am curious if Eastman will add a tech for next Namm.
 
Reminds me of "Vintage" brand guitars...
Ohh!
We're experts on that!

 
Now I am curious if Eastman will add a tech for next Namm.
They bloomin' well ought to.
When I reviewed one last year it did rather well - and I'd say if they put another, say, 5% of effort into the build they'd push if from being a good horn into a properly great one (though that's something players can do if they want to splash out on some tweaks).
I think it would serve them very well if all their demo horns were in tip-top playing order - because even a small hint of instability can mean a lost sale if a punter finds a competitor's horn plays with a touch more response simply because it's been set up nicely.
 
Just another confirmation that setup of a horn is probably equally important as design. And,, to be fair, after doing some 50+ tradeshows as exhibitor, there is always something that will go wrong during shipping, packing, unpacking, you name it. And it is not like you have a lot of time, setup is the last day before the show opens, with all kind of folks laying carpets, building booths etc. , knocking things over ...

And then you discover that somebody messed up something, a tool is missing, it's an endless struggle. If you're lucky you can borrow from the neighbor booth.

After day 2, you are usually up and running to the point where you were supposed to be on day 1.

It's great when you are able to try all the goodies but the bad ones often don't really count. The good ones are what matters, and the experience. Kind of jealous that I couldn't make it. Keep up the reporting!
 
I want to add a couple points regarding the Eastman horn. Two things impressed me a great deal.

1, the so-called “DS mechanism”. This is a difference in how the stacks are regulated. Rather than having the keys lift a bar attached to the stack key, this uses a separate flap attached to the hinge rod of the stack key, with a matching flap attached to the key doing the lifting (LH- A & B; RH- D, E & F). Like a flute mechanism. This is supposedly quieter, and could be easier to regulate. The horns at the show had felt on both the stack key and actuating key flaps. It felt very solid.

2, the pinky table low C# key touch has a kind of ramp built in to it, so that your pinky slides down from C# to B, rather than across. A tech installed a similar epoxy riser on my C# key touch, and I like it so much I will adopt similar risers on my other horns.

Eastman is really thinking about ergonomics and keywork, which is refreshing. Again, that tenor was by far the best one I played at the show.

Today I just played a few sopranos, I’m really a just feeble old man, and had to take many breaks for “jest sittin” today. I did run into @PigSquealer again, and we spent a good amount of time at the Rampone & Cazzani booth. I played all four of their sopranos, and was quite impressed. All of their horns are full body, no removable necks. I played a straight one, their saxello-style one in silver plate, and two curved ones - Two Voices and one in gold plate. I loved the tone of the saxello style one the best, it has a larger bore, and reminded me a little of my Martin Handcraft. The gold plate curvy was the most free-blowing and responsive, but the tone was a bit reedier and thinner. It was great, though. All the sopranos sounded wonderful, which I attribute to their emphasis on tonal richness and the fact there is no neck joint which I believe is a weakness in most modern sopranos. Mr. Squealer and R&C’s owner Claudio had a long discussion on history and C-melody horns; both interesting but irrelevant to me today. LOL.

I wanted to try an 82ZR, but Yamaha only brought an 875. It was OK, but to be frank I preferred the BetterSax soprano. Neither Jupiter or Yanagisawa had sopranos at the show. I reported previously on the fee BetterSax and Chateau sopranos. Companies need to up their soprano games for this show !!!

Bottom line for me, I am most excited about the Theo Wanne x Babbitt collaboration, and was impressed by Eastman, BetterSax and Rampone with regard to saxophone manufacturing. I think we’re in a state of flux in saxophones particularly, with a couple of newer companies producing excellent instruments, and one old guard company showing what OG craftsmanship is all about. The new CONNfirmation alto is also excellent, but it’s unclear if this will become a standard model. I’m less impressed by Selmer’s new direction, I think the Signature has some design flaws, at least in the tenor. I still want to try a Supreme…

I didn’t get to try everything I wanted to, partly because of my ability to walk miles (or rather the lack of same) and partly because not every horn was completely represented. Maybe next year! And maybe I’ll go to the Symposium instead…
 
I also spent quite a bit of time with @PigSquealer, @lig and Soybean from SOTW. We should become known as the West Coast Contingent - Lig from Seattle, Squealer and Soybean from LA and me from the SF Bay Area.
The West Coast Contingent having proper moment of fun.
1769330060902.webp

@Soybean
1769329932196.webp
 
Most of our chat centered around a beautiful display of a Model 22 alto that was specially built for an exhibition somewhere back in the 1920s. Absolutely gorgeous. Mr. Piggy and I took pictures.
IMG_2311.webp

1769330858588.webp

SN# 9909, restored at the Paris factory with what appears to be silver paint.
1769331225471.webp


Inside of bell looks like polished silver.
IMG_2312.webp


Look at the additional plate decorations under the feet of bell wire guard.
IMG_2313.webp


I have a very good idea where those came from.
IMG_1380.webp

IMG_2314.webp
IMG_2315.webp
 
At the Eastman booth, the tenor was nice, but low C#, B and Bb wouldn’t play. The little arm on the RH stack key had come loose. @PigSquealer asked the manager for a screwdriver, got one, and proceeded to do 5 minutes of regulation. The horn played like a dream afterwards.
Pigs on duty. Drive thru service available. Eastman is local to me and not far from Chateau. With luck, I may be doing some setup and service work both
IMG_2322.webp
 
This thread is more like the “NAMM report thread” so I’ll just make my posts here.

I didn’t look at the Selmer Signature.
The Connfermentation was SN#46. Clean, well prepared and ready. No loose neck or parts. Solid fabrication with smooth action. A bit heavy on the touch feel. Ergonomics were good for my medium size hands. The RTH rims seemed to be rolled a bit smaller than a 1947.
IMG_2318.webp


The LHP key high E could use better clearance from the local pillars.
1769337467028.webp


@lukehuang77 gave it a nice honk while I listened. Smooth with nice vibrato the horn had great projection. Loud with a dark smoky tone. Selmer S80 C*, reed ? He works on Sunday so dunno when he’ll post his NAMM experience.

@skeller047 sounded brighter and played a more traditional jazz attack style. I didn’t hear anything abnormal from either player or several other players.
 
Looks like you guys had a great time, BTW i think its crazy that some of theses horns are not setup to be in tip top condition, i mean they are going to be tried by 100s of players over the days of the show, not only do players leave disappointed, but they then tell other players, its like a car not being cleaned and polished at a car show.
 
Day 3. The 52nd Street tenor was still alive kicking.
The rib build is solid. The big square block keyfeet really cut down the body key noise. The new DS regulation system IMHO has great potential. Solid engineering and nice to see a company making change. Why their website doesn’t show these improvements in full detail I don’t understand. Small stuff like the curved key arm supports on G touch and key cup.


1769338921412.webp
 
I wanted to try an 82ZR, but Yamaha only brought an 875. It was OK, but to be frank I preferred the BetterSax soprano. Neither Jupiter or Yanagisawa had sopranos at the show. I reported previously on the fee BetterSax and Chateau sopranos. Companies need to up their soprano games for this show !!!
No Yani sops and no Yamaha 82Z?
That's astonishing.
In terms of what clients bring in to the workshop, Yanagisawa totally dominate sopranos - and for top end Yamahas the 82Z easily appears way, way more often than the 875 series.
 
No Yani sops and no Yamaha 82Z?
That's astonishing.
In terms of what clients bring in to the workshop, Yanagisawa totally dominate sopranos - and for top end Yamahas the 82Z easily appears way, way more often than the 875 series.
In other words, they already sell enough of those. No need to promote them anymore.
....
Marketing logic .....
 
Keep up the reviews guys, what I save by not going to the convention I can spend on a horn.

I wanted to vsit this year but a questionable time to fly from Toronto and our dollar makes accommodation very expensive. Maybe next year. We may get 25cm of snow today.

Excellent insights ....

Just watched off the Eastman site ...
View: https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/tXgzsy1e4YI?playlist=tXgzsy1e4YI&autoplay=1&iv_load_policy=3&loop=1&start=


Mintzer seems to be back on his Freddie Gegory mouthpiece.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,378
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom