Mouthpieces Bargain metal mouthpieces !

Facing length about 19mm, at a guess the tip opening looks like approx what I'd think of as a 5 ( I know the 'numbers' are different between makers ) I'm not fussed about doing macho weight lifting competitions and being a proper geezer with a 11* and a lolly stick reed !
The rails look to be well finished and symetrical , the table flat, has a modest step baffle but isn't thin sounding or a 'screamer' it's a well made usable mouthpiece that plays perfectly adequately. Well worth the price of admission (especially with a free alto MP thrown in ! ) 🙂
I believe that would be 38mm for the facing curve in MP parlance.
 
Blimey still with this 'toxicity' already ! ..but hey, you might get hit by a piece of falling space debris on your way to Tesco's 😵
Chance of getting hit by space debris after leaving Tesco falls in the miracle class. Getting lead in your blood after sucking on a leaded mouthpiece for a few hours a day , 100% chance. Difference , almost infinity.

Here is a short 1845 history:

 
Getting lead in your blood after sucking on a leaded mouthpiece for a few hours a day , 100% chance.
But presumably not a mouthpiece that is gold plated. If you were to play an old Otto Link with worn off gold plate, made before current much stricter codes, it would be a different matter. Even so, have any cases of lead poisoning due to brass mouthpieces been documented?

I would advise anyone who uses a brass mouthpiece, whther old or new, to have it replated if the plating begins to wear off. And if your brass saxophone has no lacquer or plating, do not lick it too ofetn.
 
Last edited:
Chance of getting hit by space debris after leaving Tesco falls in the miracle class. Getting lead in your blood after sucking on a leaded mouthpiece for a few hours a day , 100% chance. Difference , almost infinity.

Here is a short 1845 history:

I knew about the guys in the Victorian era dying after eating canned food due to rather crudely done lead soldering in the early days of tinning, hardly in the same league is it !
I'd put my chance of dying as a direct result of playing this mouthpiece along with the space debris theory !
I realise in this mad era it's fashionable to be terrified of everything 🙂
 
I realise in this mad era it's fashionable to be terrified of everything
I think this partly is the world we live in today, and people are right to be concerned.
I always think that manufactures who produce items that are stupidly cheaper than others are cutting corners, yes you are safe with mouthpieces they are very low risk, but there are unscrupulous people out there who don't give a dam that will sell you a bicycle battery that has a great risk of fire when charging them and will sell cheap vapes that are marketed towards children with really bad things in them, this is the reality of the world we live in.
Blimey still with this 'toxicity' already ! ..but hey, you might get hit by a piece of falling space debris on your way to Tesco's 😵
I m safe from this, as we only shop at Sainsburys.:rofl::rofl:
 
I would advise anyone who uses a brass mouthpiece, whther old or new, to have it replated if the plating begins to wear off. And if your brass saxophone has no lacquer or plating, do not lick it too often.
To have the missing gold replaced makes good sense. Regarding licking a sax, I sense facetiousness, no? 😉

Out of curiosity I did a little 'net searching. So far seems all brass contains a small amount of lead alloying, a fraction of to 1%. Can the lead be leached out by the acidity or alcalinity of human saliva? I don't know. Has someone a link or access to such information, it would be good to share with the community.

A side note, there appears an insistence that saxophones use Cartridge Brass (C2600), lead content 0.07%, but according to several metal manufacture sites, there was no mention of musical instrument use. One site,
Mentions musical instrument use.

Thus far I gather brass uses more or less about 1% (please have your first cup of coffee or tea before commenting) 😉 one could determine the amount of wetted surface area of the brass mouthpiece in one's mouth. Then choose a reasonable depth that over time, would erode by saliva.

Calculate the amount of lead alloying in that volume based the mouthpiece contact area and depth.

I think it possible that one would find that the amount assumed leached is so miniscule that one will probably die of something else.

But as a bobby might say, "Nothing to see, move along." 😉
 
To have the missing gold replaced makes good sense. Regarding licking a sax, I sense facetiousness, no? 😉

Out of curiosity I did a little 'net searching. So far seems all brass contains a small amount of lead alloying, a fraction of to 1%. Can the lead be leached out by the acidity or alcalinity of human saliva? I don't know. Has someone a link or access to such information, it would be good to share with the community.

A side note, there appears an insistence that saxophones use Cartridge Brass (C2600), lead content 0.07%, but according to several metal manufacture sites, there was no mention of musical instrument use. One site,
Mentions musical instrument use.

Thus far I gather brass uses more or less about 1% (please have your first cup of coffee or tea before commenting) 😉 one could determine the amount of wetted surface area of the brass mouthpiece in one's mouth. Then choose a reasonable depth that over time, would erode by saliva.

Calculate the amount of lead alloying in that volume based the mouthpiece contact area and depth.

I think it possible that one would find that the amount assumed leached is so miniscule that one will probably die of something else.

But as a bobby might say, "Nothing to see, move along." 😉
The reference point for lead toxicity if 3.5 µg/100 ml.
A 100g MPC contains 70,000 µg lead
at 100 kg body weight it comes to 3500 µg to reach that threshold
How many mouthpieces do you need to eat?
 
This is the first one they sent in error, ie it's an Alto MP when I ordered a Tenor, doh.. again i'ts a closer tip opening that what it claims to be, regardless, it's another (imho) nicely made and finished piece, and as it ended up being a freebie, I'm not going to argue 🙂
Looks rather like the ones they used to sell as 'Sharkbite' years ago, I had a Tenor one of those too at the time they were around, which also played well enough to use. I think it got thrown in with a tenor I flogged so don't still have it.
No doubt playing this Alto one will be deemed tantamount to suicide as well >:), nevertheless I shall be using it when I fancy a slightly different timbre to the olde ebonite job, whatever. again it plays in a perfectly acceptable manner (imho again )

mpa.webp mpaa.webp
 
Another take on lead export from China is that both the exporter and importer are aware of lead content in (for example) jewelry.


The manufacturer makes what the importer wants and at the price they want, so if it's cheaper with more lead, that's what ask for. If you are to believe the article.

And in this case of Temu that is moot anyway as (a) the mouthpieces are plated with gold and (b) Temu ships direct from China to consumer.

I would have no worries about these mouthpieces while the plating is intact.
 
The plating on these looks to be very decent and solidly done, I don't envisage it to be coming off any time soon.
Ironically you see a number of 'holy grail' old Otto Links and the like that have sold for mental money£££, with all the finish come off, you don't seem to hear much about these being 'lethal'... just sayin'
 
Even with electronics, everything now has to be RoHS-compliant. The Corpwatch article was published 18 years ago when things were still in the Wild West/East (take your pick).

I remember our company ordering a bunch of cryogenic coolers for overclocking of computers. They did not sell and 2 years later with RoHS coming into effect, we could not even give them away unless customers picked them up (RoHS shipping restrictions) and ended up paying a huge amount for safe disposal.

Electronic manufacturing became a PITA with lead-free solder until they finally caught up with the mix and the correct temperature etc. parameters. But none of this is anything to worry about anymore.

And then we all had leaded gasoline for cars and I am pretty certain about the exposure levels exceeding any potential hazard from playing brass mouthpieces.
 
To have the missing gold replaced makes good sense. Regarding licking a sax, I sense facetiousness, no? 😉

Out of curiosity I did a little 'net searching. So far seems all brass contains a small amount of lead alloying, a fraction of to 1%. Can the lead be leached out by the acidity or alcalinity of human saliva? I don't know. Has someone a link or access to such information, it would be good to share with the community.

A side note, there appears an insistence that saxophones use Cartridge Brass (C2600), lead content 0.07%, but according to several metal manufacture sites, there was no mention of musical instrument use. One site,
Mentions musical instrument use.

Thus far I gather brass uses more or less about 1% (please have your first cup of coffee or tea before commenting) 😉 one could determine the amount of wetted surface area of the brass mouthpiece in one's mouth. Then choose a reasonable depth that over time, would erode by saliva.

Calculate the amount of lead alloying in that volume based the mouthpiece contact area and depth.

I think it possible that one would find that the amount assumed leached is so miniscule that one will probably die of something else.

But as a bobby might say, "Nothing to see, move along." 😉
No. Not all brass contains lead. If you are truly interested, check the archives at SotW where it has been discussed for many years. I agree that the risk from lead is low, but not for the reasons you ascribe.

@Vlad If one is concerned regarding biologically accessible lead in/on a mouthpiece, buy a lead detection kit, and perform a swipe test on the mouthpiece in question. There is no cause for conjecture when one can actually perform the test.
 
The reference point for lead toxicity is 3.5 µg/100 ml. A 100g MPC contains 70,000 µg lead at 100 kg body weight it comes to 3500 µg to reach that threshold How many mouthpieces do you need to eat?
I was referring to not ingesting a whole mouthpiece, but assuming if the lead is not locked sufficiently in its metallurgic matrix, the wetted area inside ones mouth and an assumption, that this wetted area would erode over time. Seeing that there are old metal mouthpieces being sold, do metal mouthpieces show any significant wear around the mouth region? If the gold plating is more or less significantly intact with small areas indicating erosion showing, are we talking in micrometers depth? Not even a hair's width?

The artic expedition deaths, the lead-tin solder used to seal can joints were the culprit, but this lead was flowed over the joints to seal the cracks. It was easily dissolved by the damp food contents. It was not locked in an alloy matrix.

With the death of Ozzie Ozborn at a young age, I don't think he had much contact with sax metal mouthpieces. (But maybe I am wrong.) I gather it was other factors, perhaps abuse of recreational drugs?
 
No. Not all brass contains lead. If you are truly interested, check the archives at SotW where it has been discussed for many years. I agree that the risk from lead is low, but not for the reasons you ascribe.

@Vlad If one is concerned regarding biologically accessible lead in/on a mouthpiece, buy a lead detection kit, and perform a swipe test on the mouthpiece in question. There is no cause for conjecture when one can actually perform the test.
Yes and yes. Lead solubility is highly temperature-dependent and increases by ~300 % from ice cold to boiling water.

Dip the tip of the MPC in vinegar, wait 5 min and then try whether it tastes sweet - it would probably not work but if anyone wants to try and report back.
 
, check the archives at SotW where it has been discussed for many years. I agree that the risk from lead is low, but not for the reasons you ascribe.
If I recall, my main takeawy from the experts (which probably included you) any lead content was sealed within the alloy lower than the surface or something like that.

I also thought the lead content in brass was to make it better/easier to machine, hence is not necessary in all brass. And if (at least the early) Otto Links were cast then maybe not necessary. Or were they cast then machined?

Even then though weren't they cast in two pieces? Would those pieces then be soldered together and then we get the possibility of more lead from the solder. But I'm no expert, just specualting away on a sunny Sunday afternoon waiting for the footy.
 
I was referring to not ingesting a whole mouthpiece, but assuming if the lead is not locked sufficiently in its metallurgic matrix, the wetted area inside ones mouth and an assumption, that this wetted area would erode over time. Seeing that there are old metal mouthpieces being sold, do metal mouthpieces show any significant wear around the mouth region? If the gold plating is more or less significantly intact with small areas indicating erosion showing, are we talking in micrometers depth? Not even a hair's width?

The artic expedition deaths, the lead-tin solder used to seal can joints were the culprit, but this lead was flowed over the joints to seal the cracks. It was easily dissolved by the damp food contents. It was not locked in an alloy matrix.

With the death of Ozzie Ozborn at a young age, I don't think he had much contact with sax metal mouthpieces. (But maybe I am wrong.) I gather perhaps it was other factors, perhaps abuse of recreational drugs?
Please desist the arm chair “science”. FWIW, chemicals can diffuse without erosion. This is the type of hand waving misleading “information” and “research” that I find sooooo frustrating.

As I wrote, if one is concerned about whether mobile lead is available for biological uptake at the surface, do a test to see if lead is present.
 
The artic expedition deaths, the lead-tin solder used to seal can joints were the culprit, but this lead was flowed over the joints to seal the cracks. It was easily dissolved by the damp food contents. It was not locked in an alloy matrix.
In most cases, the food was heated inside the can, and that causes the lead to dissolve.
In my inorganic chemistry labs, this was the easiest way to detect lead, take your specimen, boil it and then chill it. If you get a precipitation like snow flakes as soon as it chills, that's lead. And then you can add iodine to bind with the lead and it turns into the prettiest gold flitter you can imagine.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,375
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom