Mouthpieces Bargain metal mouthpieces !

Lead is not in the top ten of risks but is still known as the single unvoluntary ingested toxic substance that does the most damage to people.
When it comes to the saxophone body, I am less concerned about handling it with my hands, because any lead used in alloying is lock in its matrix. I'd have to go back to my material science book (it's been about 45 years since I took the class), to observe how the lead molecules are interstitched with the copper and zinc. Then my corrosion books on effects and mechanisms on leaching.

IMHO, I'd be more concerned with handling lead-tin used for soldering. I recall reading of ancient upper crust civilisation using lead cups to drink out of, many were going mad.

Perhaps then it is a good argument that one purchases a sax with a coating instead of a non-coated sax for additional prophylaxis. Perhaps a wax product adds additonal prophylaxis on bare spots.

Just a few thoughts for nothing more than discussion.
 
Lots of old teapots, Victorian era stuff, were Pewter, which is mainly lead. in fact we used to have (and use) one of these.
Made a lovely cup of tea it did too :thumb:
 
Probably drinking from that kept the lead in your pencil.
Sorry to dissapoint you but most modern pewter is made without lead. The silverite used by Dukoff for mouthpieces was a type of pewter that according to a measurement by Hardbob (sax on the web) contains:
98.32% Sn (Tin) and 1.68% Cu (Copper).
 
Sorry to dissapoint you but modern pewter is made without lead. The silverite used by Dukoff for mouthpieces was a type of pewter that according to sax on the web contains:
98.32% Sn (Tin) and 1.68% Cu (Copper).
The teapot in question was a 100% original 19th cent item, definitely mostly lead.. :thumb:
What they call 'pewter' nowadays for jewellery etc is what you're thinking of and tbh isn't really pewter, it's just a name to flog it by.
 
He was younger than I am. But TBF I am old…. well, I don’t FEEL old in my mind, but my body has a way of reminding me that I am approaching my 8th decade.

Ozzie had a harder life than I did, though indulgence for musicians of my generation was the rule rather than the exception. I got smarter sooner than he did…

I’m sorry he’s gone, the world was a richer, more interesting place with him in it.

Wearing my pedantic hat, .... if you are over 69 you are in your 8th (or more) decade.

Rhys
(some way into my 7th decade but still feeling young)
 
There's lead in everything now. After decades of use as a fuel additive it's in every living thing on the planet at 1000x the level it was before the 1920's. It was already in your bones and in your brain before you could crawl. We're all dumber, angrier and more violent than we ought to be because of it.

It's great that you're concerned. You should be. Awareness is key to prevention, but the lion's share of the damage lead will do to your health was already done whilst you were unaware.
 
There's lead in everything now. After decades of use as a fuel additive it's in every living thing on the planet at 1000x the level it was before the 1920's. It was already in your bones and in your brain before you could crawl. We're all dumber, angrier and more violent than we ought to be because of it.

It's great that you're concerned. You should be. Awareness is key to prevention, but the lion's share of the damage lead will do to your health was already done whilst you were unaware.
I very much doubt lead is the cause of change in behaviour even if theoretically it can cause it.
If it has one major cause it is more likely to be the increase in population; people become far more irritable herded together.
 
No. Not all brass contains lead. If you are truly interested, check the archives at SotW where it has been discussed for many years. I agree that the risk from lead is low, but not for the reasons you ascribe.

@Vlad If one is concerned regarding biologically accessible lead in/on a mouthpiece, buy a lead detection kit, and perform a swipe test on the mouthpiece in question. There is no cause for conjecture when one can actually perform the test.

I bought some lead testing swabs and did this test on a USA-made gold plated brass mouthpiece. Some of the gold plating had worn off at the edge of the table. This area tested positive for lead. The beak area that goes in the mouth tested negative for lead. The plating was intact here.

I’d like to do the same test on a French-made brass mouthpiece but my old Vandoren T75 has excellent plating which isn’t broken anywhere. If anyone has a tatty old Vandoren mouthpiece and some lead testing swabs please post the results here.

Regarding the effects of lead ingestion, here’s some info on the correlation between lead pollution and crime rates: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0166046222000667

“Overall, the results suggest that declines in lead pollution reduce crime but are not the cause of the majority of the fall in crime observed in many western countries.”
 
I am suprised how the subject of cheap mouthpices sprouts discussions on crime and behaviour. Crime, behaviour and mouthpieces are all subject to a large number of influences. There are lots of different opinions here, which is different from trumpet players who have less hesitation to go for the lead mouthpieces. This doesn't mean that all trumpet players are criminals.

As there are more than 20 serious studies showing a relation between lead blood content and behaviour it is something that is as difficult to ignore as global warming. Lead content in people is going down in most countries by hard work from health consious people. Two other known variables to affect the crime rate are city size and large differences in income. Legally we can't do much to decrease city sizes, but we can diminish differences in income to make more expensive mouthpieces afordable. This will end this discussion and reduce crime.
 
I very much doubt lead is the cause of change in behaviour even if theoretically it can cause it.
If it has one major cause it is more likely to be the increase in population; people become far more irritable herded together.
More likely all the nasty dodgy chemicals and additives they shove in most food and drink etc, no doubt responsible for much ill health generally, and virtually impossible to avoid consuming this c'rap unless you grow all your own food !
 
Pollutants in water, air and soil are a major problem in most current and former industrialised countries. Prior to the 80's there was little thought about environmental protection, the ground, rivers and the sea were handy dumping grounds for all sorts of waste.

What concerns me more than lead toxicity from mpcs is micro plastics. They are literally everywhere, water, food, us. What the long term effects are is currently unknown but to me it is worrying.

One of the last research projects I was involved in was looking at the incidence of microplastics (mostly from fibreglass) in estuarine seawater used to culture edible oysters, marine sediments and the oysters themselves. They were found in all samples and accumulated in certain tissues of the mussels including gills, digestive tract and gonads.😳
 
This doesn't mean that all trumpet players are criminals.
Perhaps not, but I do like the theory! 😉

From what I can recall, many of those brass mouthpieces were chrome or nickel plated, so unless a trumpetist continues to use a mouthpiece where the plating was significantly wore or flaked off, would not be exposed to any lead alloying in the brass.
What concerns me more than lead toxicity from mpcs is micro plastics. They are literally everywhere, water, food, us. What the long term effects are is currently unknown but to me it is worrying.
I remember back in the 1960's that soda pop was sold in glass bottles. One would return these to any grocery store, receive 2 cents for small bottles, 3 cents for larger. They were of heavier duty thicker glass. The bottling companies would wash, sterilise and reuse them.

If we returned to such a system would get rid a good portion of plastics and aluminium dumped in our oceans.
 
........

I remember back in the 1960's that soda pop was sold in glass bottles. One would return these to any grocery store, receive 2 cents for small bottles, 3 cents for larger. They were of heavier duty thicker glass. The bottling companies would wash, sterilise and reuse them.

If we returned to such a system would get rid a good portion of plastics and aluminium dumped in our oceans.
Pop, milk and beer bottles were all returnable for reuse, metal caps and silver foil were gathered for recycling and charities got the money.

No doubt some bean-counters totted-up the costs involved and recommend the companies go 'modern'.....plastic the saviour of humankind :rolleyes: Like so many aspects of 'progress' the benefits are outweighed by the drawbacks, which are often not known at the time or ignored.
 
No doubt some bean-counters totted-up the costs involved and recommend the companies go 'modern'.....plastic the saviour of humankind :rolleyes: Like so many aspects of 'progress' the benefits are outweighed by the drawbacks, which are often not known at the time or ignored.
The bean counters may scream b****y murder, but universally enforced would to wonders for our environment. They made a profit back then, I cannot see why they couldn't continue in profitability as people overall love soft drinks and their competitors must do likewise.

You are correct, it would also include beer bottles (and wine cooler bottles).
 
More likely all the nasty dodgy chemicals and additives they shove in most food and drink etc, no doubt responsible for much ill health generally, and virtually impossible to avoid consuming this c'rap unless you grow all your own food !
Good excuse for lawyers, not my scumbag defendant's fault, your honour, it was all the crap he's been forced to eat.
 
Two other known variables to affect the crime rate are city size and large differences in income. Legally we can't do much to decrease city sizes, but we can diminish differences in income to make more expensive mouthpieces afordable. This will end this discussion and reduce crime.
Or eliminate any expensive mouthpieces from the market. If there exist no expensive mouthpieces, then the situation becomes more equitable. Same thing with saxophones - no horns over <insert favorite random number here>.

Crime solved!

P.S. Could we figure out how to get rid of trumpets as well? Has anyone else noticed that there was less industrial pollution before trumpets were invented?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,376
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom