Thanks to
@jbtsax for posting such an interesting question and generating so many informative and thought-proving responses! The thread prompted me to look up what 'free jazz' was and some of its pioneers such as Ornette Coleman, John Coltrane and his wife Alice.
In my teens (60'S and early 70'), I grew up listening to 'famous (symphonic) rock bands' but also - thanks to the the UK pioneering DJ
John Peel - to alternative bands with 'less structured' music. Bands such as the '
Third Ear band', '
The Soft Machine', etc. This broadened my musical horizons. I discovered that music didn't necessarily need to have a fixed rhythm or instruments playing in harmony to make the 'listening experience' enjoyable.
On my first ever flight (to the US) in 1973, I remember listening to Alice Coltrane's 'World Galaxy' album on the flight's headphone 'jazz' channel. Without (to my ears) not much structure or traditional harmonies, it still made a big impact on me. What really got me interested in Jazz (aged 23) was Joni Mitchell's 1978 album 'Paprika Plains' album with Wayne Shorter and Jaco Pastorius. I later became a fan of Keith Jarret's live improvisational concerts which had few melodies, changing harmonies, little structure, form, and occasional (changing) rhythms.
Bottom line: I don't really mind if there's no melody, non-traditional (or ad-hoc) harmonies, no or occasional rhythms or no fixed form. Just as long as I enjoy listening to it.
Don't quote me on this, but I suspect that there are 'free jazz' parallels in classical music too. Usually termed 'experimental music'. By composers such as Stockhausen and John Cage who deliberately aimed to make performances of their compositions 'unpredictable' in terms of rhythm and harmony.