Playing the saxophone Avante-guard or Free Jazz

It’s very well played. It sounds like an extended intro though, and a cross between David Bedford and Heinrich Gruber.

I don’t think I’m good material for turning
Ha, well again, it doesn't matter. You can like whatever you want. I took this thread as coming from the place of, I don't get this stuff, can someone help? It's a really vast range of music that's happened all over the world for about 60 years so there's probably going to be stuff out there you'd like. But if you're not interested, that's fine too!
 
Q

Quite stock really
I mean, is it more stock than a lot of jazz or easy listening that you enjoy?
Not being argumentative, just trying to understand. Or do you only like Burt Bacharach in the easy listening department?
I'm not saying it's very complex, but it's simple melody to me is striking. And it's not atonal, so I find it confusing. When people say there is no melody or harmony, well... there is. It's a bit more complex than a lot of other jazz I enjoy. I'm just saying, you can't say it doesn't have harmony or voice leading...
 
Ha, well again, it doesn't matter. You can like whatever you want. I took this thread as coming from the place of, I don't get this stuff, can someone help? It's a really vast range of music that's happened all over the world for about 60 years so there's probably going to be stuff out there you'd like. But if you're not interested, that's fine too!
Cool - I think JBT might be more prone to appreciating the Threadgill - see if he comes back on it.
A valiant effort though sir!
 
I mean, is it more stock than a lot of jazz or easy listening that you enjoy?
Not being argumentative, just trying to understand. Or do you only like Burt Bacharach in the easy listening department?
I meant the chordal movement to be quite stock - I didn’t listen. I like loads of stuff. Knowing exactly why I like it is an interesting thought.

The thing I love about stuff like Dan is the use of complex harmony, but essentially hiding it from Joe Blow. Clever, but not demonstrably clever.

Orchestrally (is that a word?), I like orchestration. Holst is incredibly beautiful to my ear and I like the writing too. Stravinsky is raw power but coupled with some very folk-like melodies. Takemitsu can be beautiful too - even though all 12 semitones are present - why is that? The collage is lovely though.
 
I'll keep adding examples as they come to me, for anyone that wants to check them out.

This was a favorite of mine as a teenager. As far as I'm concerned this definitely ticks all the boxes of "music" as previously described. And I can definitely sing the melodies and tap some rhythms. Incredible sax sound as well, you have to give him that!
View: https://youtu.be/AiPDpoF_X9U?si=5pf-mCm9oCIOas-i
 
I meant the chordal movement to be quite stock - I didn’t listen. I like loads of stuff. Knowing exactly why I like it is an interesting thought.

The thing I love about stuff like Dan is the use of complex harmony, but essentially hiding it from Joe Blow. Clever, but not demonstrably clever.

Orchestrally (is that a word?), I like orchestration. Holst is incredibly beautiful to my ear and I like the writing too. Stravinsky is raw power but coupled with some very folk-like melodies. Takemitsu can be beautiful too - even though all 12 semitones are present - why is that? The collage is lovely though.
Well... you have to listen!

Or not I suppose.

I hear what you're saying about Dan. That's how I feel about Bacharach actually. Never really got into Steely Dan myself. It's on my long list of someday I gotta finally check out....

How do you feel about Ives? I think his 4th Symphony is breath taking though I could imagine it'd be hard for some to deal with.

I like Takemitsu by the way. Haven't listened to much in a while.
 
Well... you have to listen!

Or not I suppose.

I hear what you're saying about Dan. That's how I feel about Bacharach actually. Never really got into Steely Dan myself. It's on my long list of someday I gotta finally check out....

How do you feel about Ives? I think his 4th Symphony is breath taking though I could imagine it'd be hard for some to deal with.

I like Takemitsu by the way. Haven't listened to much in a while.
Haven’t listened to Ives since in college and was a bigger fan of Copland back then - but being a clarinet major - the concerto..
 
I'll keep adding examples as they come to me, for anyone that wants to check them out.

This was a favorite of mine as a teenager. As far as I'm concerned this definitely ticks all the boxes of "music" as previously described. And I can definitely sing the melodies and tap some rhythms. Incredible sax sound as well, you have to give him that!
View: https://youtu.be/AiPDpoF_X9U?si=5pf-mCm9oCIOas-i
Fab drummer. Great groove and feel. I like the match up of tenor and P Accordion (one of my fav instruments). I like B3 too and yes, terrific tenor player. I don’t really like it - but there’s some cool stuff in it.
 
Thanks to @jbtsax for posting such an interesting question and generating so many informative and thought-proving responses! The thread prompted me to look up what 'free jazz' was and some of its pioneers such as Ornette Coleman, John Coltrane and his wife Alice.

In my teens (60'S and early 70'), I grew up listening to 'famous (symphonic) rock bands' but also - thanks to the the UK pioneering DJ John Peel - to alternative bands with 'less structured' music. Bands such as the 'Third Ear band', 'The Soft Machine', etc. This broadened my musical horizons. I discovered that music didn't necessarily need to have a fixed rhythm or instruments playing in harmony to make the 'listening experience' enjoyable.

On my first ever flight (to the US) in 1973, I remember listening to Alice Coltrane's 'World Galaxy' album on the flight's headphone 'jazz' channel. Without (to my ears) not much structure or traditional harmonies, it still made a big impact on me. What really got me interested in Jazz (aged 23) was Joni Mitchell's 1978 album 'Paprika Plains' album with Wayne Shorter and Jaco Pastorius. I later became a fan of Keith Jarret's live improvisational concerts which had few melodies, changing harmonies, little structure, form, and occasional (changing) rhythms.

Bottom line: I don't really mind if there's no melody, non-traditional (or ad-hoc) harmonies, no or occasional rhythms or no fixed form. Just as long as I enjoy listening to it.

Don't quote me on this, but I suspect that there are 'free jazz' parallels in classical music too. Usually termed 'experimental music'. By composers such as Stockhausen and John Cage who deliberately aimed to make performances of their compositions 'unpredictable' in terms of rhythm and harmony.
 
What about this from Wayne Horvitz. I actually played on this one (sorry). Some of his composing reminded me of Copland.

Just don't mind the out of tune horns. (there is something to be said about free jazz guys not playing in tune. But shoot, Ellingtons sections aren't exactly perfect either)

John, this really is on the cusp of functional harmony! 🙂

Closest yet.
 
It's funny how different we all are. I play in a band sometimes and we just got a super negative review, the critic commenting, the compositions are all just based on functional harmony. How boring!
Oh. Well, they find almost everything ever written to be boring then. Never listen to critics. I think the old adage for teachers can be more aptly applied to critics - those who can, play; those who can’t, critique.
 
Why would you write something like that? You can't possibly know what I really want or why I started this thread. 🙁
Sorry if I offended you, it was just the way I interpreted your post.
I have to be honest I also interpreted it like that. I think it was the sweeping statement that implied there was no melody harmony, rhythm or form that came across as a bit confrontational and possible closed minded. I also apologise for misinterpreting.

I can see now that maybe your experience is of a very specific type of free or avant garde, and I shouldn't have interpreted that as narrow-minded.

I am very grateful as you have started off what has become a very interesting thread
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,056
Messages
578,175
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom