Reeds Alto sax reed advice please

Whoah now you've done it! Are you suggesting I'm a beginner because I like to use soft reeds? To make the best of a soft reed you need a lot of skill, air support and experience.
Well, no, of course not. But let's face it, most players settle in somewhere harder than a Rico 2. I was trying, probably not very well, to make the point that between a Rico 2 and a Vandoren 2.5 there's a BIG jump in hardness, aside from the difference in how they play, with the Rico low spine cut and the high spine and thin tip of a Vandoren. I don't know about V21, but the advertising material kind of implies it's a "premium" version of the blue box reed. If that's not correct and it has a totally different kind of cut then disregard that last bit there.
 
You're right. My misuse.

My reeds store showed me both against a light. The Vandoren has more visible "strength" to the top and platau. The Rico is a little point below the top. As you say, expect one to be more resistant.

I was trying to say, from my understanding, that " in effect " it would seem / feel / act like a full point difference and maybe too much of a change in one day. To wit, they suggested I move from Rico 2 to 2.5 for strengthening prior to trying the 2.5 Vandoren. I was literally living the same idea as the O P. Wild!

They had a Vandoren 2.5 pack on sale yesterday and hence why I was in there. But I was talked off the ledge by the explanation above.
The Vandoren blue box have a thicker spine and thinner tip; Rico has a lower spine and (relatively) thicker tip. This affects how they play and how you want to blow them in addition to the differences in strength rating.
 
Well, I guess once again we prove we're two peoples divided by a common language.

The "spine" of the reed refers to the part close to the centerline. If you have played so-called "American cut" reeds all your life, like the Rico products, first time you play a Vandoren you'll actually notice that the center part of the reed's thicker. So if one could take a cross-section view of the reed somewhere in the vamp, you'd see that your Rico (for example) top surface has kind of a gentle rise from the left side to the center and then of course the same gentle descent to the right edge. The Vandoren, by contrast, would rise more steeply to a higher point (greater thickness) in the center and then go back down to the right edge.

I also find the tips (let's say the 3/8" back from the tip or so on a baritone reed) are thinner on Vandoren than on Rico and the like.

This all affects the way they blow, so you've got to get accustomed to the differences. As you well know, of course.
 
Well, I guess once again we prove we're two peoples divided by a common language.
I don't think it is like different languages, as in pavement vs sidewalk, just that I've never heard of that word to describe that bit of a reed either in American or UK English.

It's good to learn because of compiling the glossary.
 
This all affects the way they blow, so you've got to get accustomed to the differences
This thread got me thinking of why we talk of a reeds hardness... Surely it's stiffness that matters? Stiffness is structural... The material (elasticity etc) and construction... The the layout of the fibers probably affect stiffness?
 
In the vernacular, we use "hard reed" to mean "stiff reed". Yes, the correct technical term is "Stiffness". But even then we have to define it a bit more, if we want to be fully consistent. You've got two different things in play here, the modulus of elasticity of the reed material, a bulk characteristic (and it's even more complex because grass stems are not a true "Hooke's Law" material with a linear stress-strain curve), and the thickness of the material (which is more complex, because the thickness of a reed is not constant across the width nor along the length of the vamp.

In practice, the reed makers cut a bunch of reeds, measure the deflection at a given point under a given force, and stamp them with numbers. This is a crude way to sort, which is why in a box of #3 reeds they won't all play the same way.
 
You're right. My misuse.

My reeds store showed me both against a light. The Vandoren has more visible "strength" to the top and platau. The Rico is a little point below the top. As you say, expect one to be more resistant.

I was trying to say, from my understanding, that " in effect " it would seem / feel / act like a full point difference and maybe too much of a change in one day. To wit, they suggested I move from Rico 2 to 2.5 for strengthening prior to trying the 2.5 Vandoren. I was literally living the same idea as the O P. Wild!

They had a Vandoren 2.5 pack on sale yesterday and hence why I was in there. But I was talked off the ledge by the explanation above.

Cute argument, but incomplete. You can examine reed profiles and shadows but fail to appreciate that mouthpiece facings are different too - tip opening, lay length, etc. Then there are considerations of baffle and chamber. Beak profile matters to some. Different reed cuts were intended to work best for a particular mouthpiece geometry - your mileage will vary.

Bottom line: Pick a mouthpiece. Find what reeds work best. Listen to your sound. If unhappy, iterate.
 
My reeds store showed me both against a light. The Vandoren has more visible "strength" to the top and platau. The Rico is a little point below the top. As you say, expect one to be more resistant.

Different cuts. French and American. Originally for different mouthpieces with French and American facings. Not so much these days.
French and American cut is not an issue, it actually makes no difference, I compared Ri — er, D’Addario select jazz both “filed“ (French) and “unfiled” (American), and there is no difference.

What is different is the cut profile of the reed. Vandoren have a very strong heart that is closer to the tip, whereas Rico have a weaker heart AND a longer tip. This is why there is about a one-half strength differential, maybe more, between the two. I.E, Vandoren 2.5 = Rico 3 or 3.5.

Colin the Bear you are right about these being made for different facings. Vandorens (and V21 as well) work best on shorter facings; Ricos are best on longer facing/more open mouthpieces. I actually play Rico 3.5 on a 7* mouthpiece (this is on tenor), and it seems a little soft to me. Though I love the tone 🙂
 
What is different is the cut profile of the reed. Vandoren have a very strong heart that is closer to the tip, whereas Rico have a weaker heart AND a longer tip. This is why there is about a one-half strength differential, maybe more, between the two. I.E, Vandoren 2.5 = Rico 3 or 3.5.
What I find interesting here is how a reed grading machine works. Does it measure the stiffness at a certain point on the vamp, or various points to get an average?

It would seem to me to make more sense to do the latter so that there is a better way to judge the grade across various different designs where the heart may have a different shape/dimension.
 
Last edited:
Well...If you like the V21, try a softer one.

I'm not a fan of struggling with a tough reed just to build up your chops. Your chops are where they are and a suitable reed to accommodate them is what's needed. imo

Is a 2 a beginners reed?

When trying different brands and cuts, a reed comparison chart can guide you for strength/hardness, but it's all a bit hit and miss. You'll end up with a drawer full, which is handy for when you get mouthpiece gas.

There are lots of techniques to adjust reeds. I'm a scraper and clipper myself. A clipper changed the game for me, after a lot of trial and error. Scraping is the same. A little weight removed from the heart works wonders for me.
Then there's the flicking the trick. Some swear by it but it doesn't work for me. Maybe I'm doing it wrong.
Sometimes I wonder if brass wouldn't be easier.

This is graduate school! Awesome.

I will love when I know when I'm ready for scraping and clipping sax reeds. Is this level of finishing AFTER the reed search is concluded / reasonably settled for time being? And is there a specific effect after particular affect? I surmise it takes an advanced proficiency.

I feel settled for now. 5C and Rico 2.5 on import tenor. It took reading online and bouncing GAS attacks off the local teachers to get focused. I calculate 1,065 MP reed combinations. I'm lucky my combination really clicks for me making sounds.

I think I'll stick and develop all I can before getting into that process again.
 
Regarding scraping, I always, as in every reed I play, balance the reed side to side. I post about this a lot, so do a search.

I do this when I first take a reed out of the box, and maybe revisit it the second time I play it. Then it just stays in the case till it dies (somewhere around 20-30 play sessions). I find that about 90% of reeds play well enough to record or gig with this treatment.

If you clip, be sure to sand the very tip just a bit afterwards (400 grit or higher, old is best). The clipper can leave a few fibers uncut, and raise a small burr on the tip, which will not help your sound.

You may find if you start doing this that you have to go up 1/2 strength, because you will be sanding/scraping every reed. Some brands (Rigotti and D’Addario Select Jazz, in my experience) require less of this. Rico a bit more. But it really varies from reed to reed.
 
The part of the reed described above as the spine, I've always called the heart.

Back in the day we used to hold reeds up to the light to inspect the spread of the veins in the vamp. Supposedly a compact even spread was supposed to play better. Also checking the symmetry of the heel was important.

Being a skint busker I used to clip a great reed that had died to resurrect it. I still do with the bigger ones. To fiddly on sop and clarinet.

These days an uneven spread with a lop sided heel seems to play just fine.

Lately I'm finding that the reeds with the grey patches on the bark play best and for longer.
 
I don't think it is like different languages, as in pavement vs sidewalk, just that I've never heard of that word to describe that bit of a reed either in American or UK English.

It's good to learn because of compiling the glossary.
Just take a kook at the reed article and the liked Vandoren article (from the glossary thread), it has everything in there that everybody is quibbling about. A little reading sometimes goes a long way .....

Just pulling your leg, Pete 🙂
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,534
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom