Mouthpieces Alto mouthpiece for high school student?

She plays in regular band, marching band, and jazz band in school.
β€œRegular band” is presumably a wind band (classical-ish); marching band - play loud enough to fill the stadium or town; and big band playing.

Metal pieces on alto are widely accepted to be β€œmore difficult β€œ, though plenty of choice exists. The point about many being very slender in the mouth can be awkward - from a comfort point it can be that the mouthpiece is less wide than the reed itself and the rails of the reed can cut into the lip. Yes, the edges can be sanded a little, but…

I think that @skeller047 gave good advice - Yamaha 5C - a bit more open than the 4C but a very good piece - despite the low cost. It’s very playable and won’t upset any of the 3 bandleaders.
 
Thank you for explaining that.
You are welcome. :thumb: On your question of why I have broken more mouthpieces that you:

This is my 60 year historic woodwind legacy: 1965 - 6th Grade in Mississippi (started clarinet), 7-12th Grades in rural Hawaiian school bands (picked up sax), 1972-1975 active duty clarinet & sax with 264th Army and 25th Infantry Division Bands in Hawaii; after in Reservist Bands: 111th in Hawaii, 300th and 91st Division in California, 44th in New Mexico until transferred to retired reserve in 2001; 2011&12 - Holloman Chapel Band; 2013 - Cannon Chapel Band; 2014 to Present - Clovis Community Band, plus since 1988 to present: church musician & worship leader on keys, ukulele, guitar and occasional sax, not to mention also sax at various nursing homes, retirement homes, motorcycle & city rallies/events, guest sax player at churches and camp bands, and etc.

So, I've been a bit busy ... :mrcoolπŸ˜‰
 
You are welcome. :thumb: On your question of why I have broken more mouthpieces that you:

This is my 60 year historic woodwind legacy: 1965 - 6th Grade in Mississippi (started clarinet), 7-12th Grades in rural Hawaiian school bands (picked up sax), 1972-1975 active duty clarinet & sax with 264th Army and 25th Infantry Division Bands in Hawaii; after in Reservist Bands: 111th in Hawaii, 300th and 91st Division in California, 44th in New Mexico until transferred to retired reserve in 2001; 2011&12 - Holloman Chapel Band; 2013 - Cannon Chapel Band; 2014 to Present - Clovis Community Band, plus since 1988 to present: church musician & worship leader on keys, ukulele, guitar and occasional sax, not to mention also sax at various nursing homes, retirement homes, motorcycle & city rallies/events, guest sax player at churches and camp bands, and etc.

So, I've been a bit busy ... :mrcoolπŸ˜‰
I have been playing for 50+ years as well - coincidentally in Hawaii, CA, and NM, as well as a few other regions. But the answer to not breaking mouthpieces is more likely associated with not dropping as many. πŸ˜‰
 
Ten paces, turn and throw.
Metal MPs at dawn.
Although the Cutlass,
is more my style. πŸŽΆπŸ΄β€β˜ οΈπŸŽΆ

This one was not pre-screened.
Might be good for a free-jazz sawtooth cadenza.

After I spoke with Berg, about the inside shank diameter of the new Bronze vs my old HR, and was advised, that they were close, I went looking for a supplier.
Found this pic on the Sweetwater site.
When I ordered one from Weiner, I sent the Bossman that pic, and asked that they
pre-screen one, before sending it, and make sure it was something he would play.
They did good. 🎯

IMG_4953.webp

IMG_4952.webp


We do Kendo, Yankee style, with our Ice Hockey gear.
Good upper body workout.
You can re-purpose a worn out Shinai,
for reeds. πŸ™„
 
My local store told me the graftonite pieces were out of production, or at least some of them maybe reducing the range?

My Select Jazz D5M is decent piece, with it being machine made, should a replacement be required in future it shouldn't be far off the previous one.
 
Despite @ghostler β€˜s enthusiastic support of Graftonite, IMO it’s a good thing they are out of production. I would never recommend them to anyone.

Metalites, which are Graftonites on steriods, are good only for marching band and maybe punk/progressive, where niceties like tone don’t matter. I admit they are a good choice for those genres. But a Graftonite is just a bad mouthpiece. A better solution for a young player is a Bari Esprit, or a Hite Premier or a Fobes Debut. For a little more money, still way under $200, the Selmers and possibly the D’Addario Select Jazz, as well as the ubiquitous Yamahas are the best options.

Again, my opinion, but I own examples of all the mouthpieces mentioned here (yes including Graftonite) and stand by it.
 
Despite @ghostler β€˜s enthusiastic support of Graftonite, IMO it’s a good thing they are out of production. I would never recommend them to anyone.

Metalites, which are Graftonites on steriods, are good only for marching band and maybe punk/progressive, where niceties like tone don’t matter. I admit they are a good choice for those genres. But a Graftonite is just a bad mouthpiece. A better solution for a young player is a Bari Esprit, or a Hite Premier or a Fobes Debut. For a little more money, still way under $200, the Selmers and possibly the D’Addario Select Jazz, as well as the ubiquitous Yamahas are the best options.

Again, my opinion, but I own examples of all the mouthpieces mentioned here (yes including Graftonite) and stand by it.
Graftonites are still being actively marketed by D'Addario and sold on lots of websites.

What don't you like about them? I've found they play fine, and the different options give a range of tones from bright to more mellow. I used to work with a guy who always used one on soprano, and his tone was great.

Everyone's different, I'm just curious.
 
Graftonites are still being actively marketed by D'Addario and sold on lots of websites. ... I've found they play fine, and the different options give a range of tones from bright to more mellow. I used to work with a guy who always used one on soprano, and his tone was great. Everyone's different, ...
I'm currently using the D'Addario Rico Royal Graftonite B5 on bari and sop. The tips appear to be jazz spaced at 0.060 in. (1.52 mm, face 18 mm) and 0.100 in. (2.54 mm, face 25 mm), medium chambered, they both play great.

I would not recommend those to a beginner, but after one has a few years under their belt and want to expand into jazz play, could possibly work for them.

A better solution for a young player is a Bari Esprit,
I suggested that, and someone else here in the forum said they had very poor results with it. It works well for me on my tenor in community band.

As @jonf alluded to, everyone's embouchure due to their anatomy is different. That is why we have many choices in the market place. This is where it is helpful for the student to work with their instructor initially, until they have sufficient experience and knowledge to experiment on their own.
 
The Metalite is a very misunderstood piece. I use an M11 on clarinet and it's the sweetest, loudest, piece I've ever owned. I've tried them on SATB and they were fun but not to my taste.

Having said that I wouldn't recommend it for a beginner.

Graftonites are OK imo. Consistent and a bit boring. Things have moved on since they appeared. Lots of better budget pieces out there. Two stars.
 
As @jonf alluded to, everyone's embouchure due to their anatomy is different. That is why we have many choices in the market place. This is where it is helpful for the student to work with their instructor initially, until they have sufficient experience and knowledge to experiment on their own.
Is everyone’s anatomy really that different? I posit that we have so many choices because so many companies want a piece of the pie. The marketing department has made a lot of people believe they need something special. In most cases, we are more alike than different.

You were around in the β€˜60s-β€˜70s. Do you remember how so many people sounded great on the β€œlimited” number of choices? Selmer, Meyer and Link, oh my! In clarinet world, it was Selmer and Vandoren. Bamn!
 
Not so much anotomy as physiognomy. So many different lip sizes, sinus cavities etc.

A limited number of people sound great on saxophone. Always have, always will. The instrument is no help at all. Constant battle.
Thanks for the correction.

Bottom line, tho’: Do any of the myriad mouthpieces actually correlate best with these variations in lips and cavities? Wouldn’t it be interesting to see a line of mouthpieces marketed for various degrees of overbite/underbite? Or β€œHere, try this if you have a thick tongue.”
 
Is everyone’s anatomy really that different? I posit that we have so many choices because so many companies want a piece of the pie.

Yes, and also true are my comments on those two sentences.

I think there's the combination of the sound we make, the sound we like and the sound we hear that colours our perceptions on the quality of a mouthpiece.

But undoubtedly there is a significant market in items being sold to musicians, including but not limited to mouthpieces, which are claimed to be the thing you need to make great music. This is mostly marketing twaddle, as once you get to a basic level of quality, what you really need is practice.

That said, I relatively recently bought a new tenor mouthpiece, from SYOS - 'Shape Your Own Sound'. Really does sound like marketing puff, but it plays better than any other piece I've played over the last 42 years. It just suits me. Someone else might hate it.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,301
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom