Playing the saxophone Altissimo ... too screechy?

So, to match tone, what do you use on the E, and how does it match the sound? What about F# and G on the way back up again (…”the rain-bow”) ?

Also the high A - do you finger D ?
Make sure you enable subtitles/annotations - this was before the restoration of the saxello

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nTvAwyAoew0


I had a bunch of discussions with JBTsax about this way of playing/fingering - he fully approved after trying himself.
 
OMG... really? @mrblackbat I am not comfortable with the tone of your responses - I am feeling unnecessarily peeved given that this was initially a lighthearted post.

Yes I "know what altissimo is", otherwise how would I have asked the question in the first place?😡

Look, I get it, some people on here are much more advanced in their musical journey than I am, but we all have to start somewhere and for the most part, I feel people are genuinely trying to be helpful for which I am grateful. But please, stop with the thinly veiled condescension @mrblackbat jeeze.....

@Pete Thomas - sorry if I have broken any rules but I have had enough! 😳
Be peeved if you like; if you read my first reply to you I spent a lot of time trying to help, the rest is responses to a different member of the forum.

FWIW I know plenty of saxophone players and teachers who don't call F and F# when played with the front fork altissimo and that altissimo starts at G as there's a significant difference in being able to play G and upwards than being able to play F and F#. As others have also said, there is some lack of clarity generally in what altissimo means on the saxophone, and so as someone relatively new to the horn it wouldn't surprise me if there were some confusion.

Anyway, whatever.
 
Yes, what I just said. The instrument "chalumeau" had an approx. one octave range, no overblown notes. It was turned into the clarinet by extending the keywork to bridge the twelfth overblow and adding the register key to access the clarion register.
You said “Chalumeau = fundamental “. This is what I found confusing.
 
Make sure you enable subtitles/annotations - this was before the restoration of the saxello

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nTvAwyAoew0


I had a bunch of discussions with JBTsax about this way of playing/fingering - he fully approved after trying himself.
After the B section, just before repeating the A section a normal 3-finger G is played and sounds no different. In fact, there are other places where the harmonic fingerings could be used yet aren’t (not because of fast transitions) - so I don’t see the purpose. They do match well on this instrument though, but I can’t imagine that to be the case on my SA80 series 2.
 
Be peeved if you like; if you read my first reply to you I spent a lot of time trying to help, the rest is responses to a different member of the forum.

FWIW I know plenty of saxophone players and teachers who don't call F and F# when played with the front fork altissimo and that altissimo starts at G as there's a significant difference in being able to play G and upwards than being able to play F and F#. As others have also said, there is some lack of clarity generally in what altissimo means on the saxophone, and so as someone relatively new to the horn it wouldn't surprise me if there were some confusion.

Anyway, whatever.
"sent from my iPhone" ? :rofl:
 
After the B section, just before repeating the A section a normal 3-finger G is played and sounds no different. In fact, there are other places where the harmonic fingerings could be used yet aren’t (not because of fast transitions) - so I don’t see the purpose. They do match well on this instrument though, but I can’t imagine that to be the case on my SA80 series 2.
There is always the thing about recording soprano and reproducing the actual tone of the instrument. If I play it, I can hear the difference in timbre between the 3-finger G and the harmonic G and the audience certainly does at well, I have tried it a few times but the listeners were experienced/professional sax players (Air Force Band). I have no doubt that at least some of it will be lost on layman listeners.

The harmonic fingering has become so ingrained with me that I am using it on my Buescher and Conn sops as well, even on my tenor if somebody calls the song and I don't have the sop with me. Admittedly, it "speaks" best on the saxello and my Buescher c-sop (one of my vocalist friends insists on doing the song in the key of concert G), so I definitely see that on some instruments it may not be a good match.

Anyway this is too off topic from the OP - @Jeanette or @Pete Thomas please feel free to move these posts to a separate thread.
 
There is always the thing about recording soprano and reproducing the actual tone of the instrument. If I play it, I can hear the difference in timbre between the 3-finger G and the harmonic G and the audience certainly does at well, I have tried it a few times but the listeners were experienced/professional sax players (Air Force Band). I have no doubt that at least some of it will be lost on layman listeners.

The harmonic fingering has become so ingrained with me that I am using it on my Buescher and Conn sops as well, even on my tenor if somebody calls the song and I don't have the sop with me. Admittedly, it "speaks" best on the saxello and my Buescher c-sop (one of my vocalist friends insists on doing the song in the key of concert G), so I definitely see that on some instruments it may not be a good match.

Anyway this is too off topic from the OP - @Jeanette or @Pete Thomas please feel free to move these posts to a separate thread.
I thought that there might be more call for it, or let's say a better argument for it with your horns. They're not usually problematic notes though. Not like clarinet throat notes, which need equalising.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,379
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom