- Messages
- 700
- Location
- USA
high notes just are relatively painful
They do have that nails on a chalkboard effect, yeah. I wonder if out-of-tune notes are more grating the higher you go too.
high notes just are relatively painful
On both my saxophone app and the TE Tuner the high F# called F#6. So who am I to argueFirstly, what do you mean by F#6? I'm assuming you don't mean three octaves above the normal range of the instrument (where F1 would be F at the bottom of the horn, F2 with the octave key, F3 palm keys or front fork, F4 an octave above that, F5 another octave.... and F6 another one from there..... which would be nuts). If you mean F played with an F# key.... well that's not altissimo (which would be A5 in concert pitch)
Exactly..... Thank you!Do you mean two fingerings or two notes an octave apart?
Really very very confusing
😉
Still. Where you really confused by the OP?
FWIW the OP is a beginner... waddyathink?
I specifically looked up the octave names for clarity. I am using the terminology from TE Tuner and the 3D saxophone app. Maybe if they are wrong someone ought to let them know.......Referring to notes in this way becomes extremely confusing when talking about fingerings and cross saxophone talk, and so instead referring to the register of the saxophone makes far more sense.

No. Not confrontational. Curiosity. Critical curiosity.Sorry Mizmar, you're being unnecessarily confrontational, as always.
It’s only because it’s referring to a “universal “ measurement, one which covers all instruments, but one which most people won’t be using too often unless they’re piano players or talking about the range covered by a full orchestra possibly.It did not seem confusing to me. I am using the terminology from TE Tuner and the 3D saxophone app. I did not make it up!
Sort of, maybe. It is the first note that you can't play unless you play altissimo but F6, E6 are below that (DUH) and very easy to play, especially when you have sequences like F-F# or E-F#. Moreover, at least for me, those have a much fuller tone than the palm keys.On both my saxophone app and the TE Tuner the high F# called F#6. So who am I to argueI am a beginner.
I actually thought I was being clear in naming the octave, but hey-ho . To my understanding that is the first altissimo note.
Exactly..... Thank you!
We have tried. I have communicated to the “creators” of several such products on several occasions. Once a product is launched, they’d rather have your money than add more effort to make it right.I specifically looked up the octave names for clarity. I am using the terminology from TE Tuner and the 3D saxophone app. Maybe if they are wrong someone ought to let them know.......
![]()
I am not sure I understand what you mean?Does anyone know an alternative for harmonic A when slurring from top F
I am quite happy with both of these products, despite the comments in this thread from others. Still as I am not experienced enough to know whether it is "defective", I will leave it for others to argue that point.We have tried. I have communicated to the “creators” of several such products on several occasions. Once a product is launched, they’d rather have your money than add more effort to make it right.
On the other hand, why should I help make their product better and not get paid for it? The onus should be on them to do their own homework, but people seem to be happy buying a poor product for a low price.
Maybe you should let them know their product is defective and have them either refund your money or send you an upgrade.
Yeah, you do.I am not sure I understand what you mean?
Thank you, this is helpful.It’s only because it’s referring to a “universal “ measurement, one which covers all instruments, but one which most people won’t be using too often unless they’re piano players or talking about the range covered by a full orchestra possibly.
There’s no right or wrong in this - just as using concert pitch vs our own transposed pitch as note names is preferred by different people.
When sat in an ensemble you’d always talk in concert pitch. But, if you were in a sax section or a sax quartet, even though different keys are in play the fingering table / system is the same, so it makes more sense to me to ask, for example:
Does anyone know an alternative for harmonic A when slurring from top F
Within your own instrument group, conversation tends to be more colloquial -
Front F
Chromatic / forked F#
Side C
Low C
Etc
As sax players we know this stuff and it’s easy to reference.
This isn’t -
My concert F#6 is sharp
Personally, I wouldn’t know which octave that is off the top of my head.
In years of clarinet lessons none of my teachers ever referred to notes on the page in concert pitch.
I’d immediately think of the note you meant by “high F#” - 3rd octave of the sax, 3 ledger lines etc.I was referring to the notes in saxophone pitch in my original post. The high F#, the third octave on the saxophone. I used the terminology used by TE Tuner and 3D saxophone. If anyone has those apps and wants to know what note I was referring to, they could easily whip it out and have a listen.
Amazingly enough, there are those who are not conversant with a particular specific app. Given that I've seen at least three or four different numerical designations for the different octaves, you can't assume people know what you're talking about.I specifically looked up the octave names for clarity. I am using the terminology from TE Tuner and the 3D saxophone app. Maybe if they are wrong someone ought to let them know.......
![]()
The difference is the register key vs. the octave key but you can play in the clarion mode (2nd harmonics) just as well on the sax. Especially on soprano when you want to keep the notes inside the horn as long as you can for a better tone or if you play split tones (just a difference in embouchure).I also wonder if there’s a naming mistake (?) with the use of the word altissimo with the sax. On clarinet, it refers to a distinct range of/ set of notes. The clarinet is broken into these registers -
Chalumeau
Clarion
Altissimo
Extreme Altissimo
“Harmonic” fingering / terminology doesn’t apply in the same way as sax.
Has the terminology - “harmonics” and “altissimo “ been confused on the sax?
No one was at risk of answering your question badly because you used "F#6" other than getting hung-up on that issue.I specifically looked up the octave names for clarity. I am using the terminology from TE Tuner and the 3D saxophone app. Maybe if they are wrong someone ought to let them know.......
![]()
I haven’t specifically tried this but I would have thought that would sound tonally wrong and too dense.For example "Somewhere over the rainbow" I prefer playing the G1-G2 octave jump by playing C1 "in clarion mode" because it sounds soo much better.
OMG... really? @mrblackbat I am not comfortable with the tone of your responses - I am feeling unnecessarily peeved given that this was initially a lighthearted post.Given the OP was also talking about just a few semitones, I'm questioning whether they really know what altissimo is (not in a bad sparky way, just so that I can help them).
When I was learning, (and before I found cafe sax), I understood that altissimo was those 'extra notes' that could be played above high F#.I also wonder if there’s a naming mistake (?) with the use of the word altissimo with the sax.
