- Messages
- 2,778
- Location
- Black Forest
Not at all but one person's owl is another's nightingale.I haven’t specifically tried this but I would have thought that would sound tonally wrong and too dense.
Not at all but one person's owl is another's nightingale.I haven’t specifically tried this but I would have thought that would sound tonally wrong and too dense.
I’m sure it’s what I grew up knowing too. What happened to your other ear?When I was learning, (and before I found cafe sax), I understood that altissimo was those 'extra notes' that could be played above high F#.
That's still how I think of it but don't bother with it as makes my ear hurt
I am done with this threadAmazingly enough, there are those who are not conversant with a particular specific app. Given that I've seen at least three or four different numerical designations for the different octaves, you can't assume people know what you're talking about.
If you mean "three ledger lines and a space above the staff", call it that.
What about the difference between the “false” fingering G and the following F#?Not at all but one person's owl is another's nightingale.
The saxophone has these same registers, but the clarion register and altissimo register have some overlap. High E and F, and on horns with the high F# key, and on a very few with a high G key, can be accessed either as clarion notes (overblown one octave from the fundamental) or altissimo) overblown an octave and a fifth, or more).I also wonder if there’s a naming mistake (?) with the use of the word altissimo with the sax. On clarinet, it refers to a distinct range of/ set of notes. The clarinet is broken into these registers -
Chalumeau
Clarion
Altissimo
Extreme Altissimo
“Harmonic” fingering / terminology doesn’t apply in the same way as sax.
Has the terminology - “harmonics” and “altissimo “ been confused on the sax?
Ok. Never heard the names of the registers (even written in books) be anything other than low, middle, high, and either altissimo or harmonics - though, granted, this isn’t the best use of the word.The saxophone has these same registers, but the clarion register and altissimo register have some overlap. High E and F, and on horns with the high F# key, and on a very few with a high G key, can be accessed either as clarion notes (overblown one octave from the fundamental) or altissimo) overblown an octave and a fifth, or more).
Of course on clarinet the clarion register is overblown a twelfth, because you can't overblow clarinet fundamentals an octave; but it's the same thing - the range of notes that are the first harmonic that's available.
I stay in the clarion mode and play B (F#) before returning to standard D fingering in the first harmonic. Because you are already in a "harmonic" wave, you don't even need the octave key, it just jumps right in.What about the difference between the “false” fingering G and the following F#?
Chalumeau and clarion are not terms commonly used in saxophone, but the registers are there. Chalumeau = fundamental; on sax from low Bb to all-open C# (and if you use the palm D without octave key as an alternate fingering, that's the same register). Clarion - first harmonic, an octave above the fundamental on sax; a twelfth above the fundamental on clarinet. On sax, from all-fingers-down middle D to high F or F# if there's a high F# key. Altissimo: overblown more than an octave on sax, more than a twelfth on clarinet - from front E on up on sax.Ok. Never heard the names of the registers (even written in books) be anything other than low, middle, high, and either altissimo or harmonics - though, granted, this isn’t the best use of the word.
Always used in relation to clarinet tho.
Acoustic neuroma - totally useless even for balance.I’m sure it’s what I grew up knowing too. What happened to your other ear?
I think of it as the semitone above the normal range of the saxophone, ie above the F you can play with either the palm keys or the front (fork or aux) keySo what's altissimo F#? I play two F#s that some might consider to be altissimo.
I didn’t perceive that.Sorry Mizmar, you're being unnecessarily confrontational, as always.
Yes it can be either F#6 in more conventional music terms or F#3 using saxophone specific terminology.On both my saxophone app and the TE Tuner the high F# called F#6. So who am I to argueI am a beginner.
My understanding alsoTo my understanding that is the first altissimo note.
Yes, that one.I’d immediately think of the note you meant by “high F#” - 3rd octave of the sax, 3 ledger lines etc.
I don’t think you have broken any rules. No need to apologise, I think we all knew what note you meant.@Pete Thomas - sorry if I have broken any rules but I have had enough! 😳
Don't worry about it.I am done with this thread![]()
So, to match tone, what do you use on the E, and how does it match the sound? What about F# and G on the way back up again (…”the rain-bow”) ?I stay in the clarion mode and play B (F#) before returning to standard D fingering in the first harmonic. Because you are already in a "harmonic" wave, you don't even need the octave key, it just jumps right in.
Well, are they?! 😬🫣Don't worry about it.
Someone will be along soon to ask if those three ledger lines are counted from base, alto or treble clef
That really deserves a thread off it's own!For example "Somewhere over the rainbow" I prefer playing the G1-G2 octave jump by playing C1
I suppose I have a 1-in-88 chance of being correct. That’s more than 1%!!! (Slightly less if you have a Bosendorfer…)OK. I’m thinking of a pitch. What is it?
Do you have balance issues?Acoustic neuroma - totally useless even for balance.
I don’t understand this, the clarinet was borne out of the Chalumeau, a speaker / register key being added.Chalumeau = fundamental
Yes, what I just said. The instrument "chalumeau" had an approx. one octave range, no overblown notes. It was turned into the clarinet by extending the keywork to bridge the twelfth overblow and adding the register key to access the clarion register.I don’t understand this, the clarinet was borne out of the Chalumeau, a speaker / register key being added.
I used to have one, baby grand players piano using punch cards. An old lady donated it to my high school, the school did not want to shell out the money to do repairs/maintenance and threw it out so I picked it up and a good friend of mine who was a very good piano tech / tuner fixed it for ~ $1000.- Gorgeous instrument but I couldn't take it with me across the pond so I gave it to a band mate who then gave it to a friend who was an excellent classical pianist.I suppose I have a 1-in-88 chance of being correct. That’s more than 1%!!! (Slightly less if you have a Bosendorfer…)
