Saxophones Yas 62 Mark ?

.It's purely rather having a sax that is easier to move on if the need arises,
It’s back to what I said above. You have a saxophone you think is difficult to sell so the solution is to sell it !!

I wish I could make a cheap sax sound as good as you.. and I mean that genuinely....

Again, what is it that makes people think the more you pay the better a saxophone sounds? It’s actually the more you play the better it sounds.
 
already said I admire your philosophy @Colin the Bear I wish I could make a cheap sax sound as good as you.. and I mean that genuinely....
Would I sound that much different on an expensive horn? These are very shiney.

 
I guess you'll just have to take my word for it about sounding the same.

I just try to discourage beginning players from constantly buying/selling horns. It's not going to make any difference. You've already had horns in the past that were easy to move on. So you could have just kept those to begin with.

Regardless, it's your money, so do what you like.
Butvl i don't honestly know how it slwys turns out like this tbf...ive had 2 tenors in three years really didn't get on with the raw...happy and settled with the z...this is alto not tenor..its not about cash the initial post was if all mk 1s had 1 piece guards..i take your advice and have embarrased myself doing your quizes because i learnt a bit and am not afraid to show my weaknesses. Its the only way to turn them into strengths.
 
i learnt a bit and am not afraid to show my weaknesses. Its the only way to turn them into strengths
Well said!

I was thinking about what I said before. In my case I did previously think if I bought a more expensive horn I would sound better. In my case it was mainly lack of self confidence, and it took a long time for me to get over that and have the confidence to choose a saxophone based on playing it and having faith in my judgement .
 
Well said!

I was thinking about what I said before. In my case I did previously think if I bought a more expensive horn I would sound better. In my case it was mainly lack of self confidence, and it took a long time for me to get over that and have the confidence to choose a saxophone based on playing it and having faith in my judgement .
I don't honestly think you would sound better @Pete Thomas the same as @Colin the Bear..but there are ( must be) differences between cheap and more expensive saxes..keeping regulation, better quality pads, speed of playing, laquer quality etc otherwise no one would buy a more expensive sax..I guess if like @Colin the Bear you have learnt to maintain your own sax its easier..i loved the tone of my jp 141 blues but it was a nightmare on other fronts.
 
" Well I got this guitar
And I learned how to make it talk"
(some lines from "Thunder Road", Bruce Springsteen.)

For me, 100% rocksax, it's just to make my stuff (saxes, mouthpieces reeds) "talk". 8 persons out of 10 thought I was terrible on the sax. So I played for myself and the remaining two. Nowadays just for myself. So try to do your own thing. A pro player/teacher/instructor can help you with what type of music (style and groove) that's suit you. And be prepared that you might get answers that you don't expected.
but there are ( must be) differences between cheap and more expensive saxes..keeping regulation, better quality pads, speed of playing, laquer quality etc otherwise no one would buy a more expensive sax.
Yes, there are differences. My Martin Comm II alto was probably a much better sax than any other modern altos. Wellbuilt, solid nickel silver keys, even scale, a powerful and focused tone, custom pad job (good pads, oversized sterling silver reflectors/resonators, quick and distinct action and the sax was renovated and set-up by a guy that are familiar with Martin saxes. But nodody wanted to buy even if the price was low. So what are saxplayers searching for?

The sax and all the other stuff it's just a small part. It's the total that counts. I went to see and listen to Van Morrisson the other day. I'm a big Van Morrison fan. Great songwriter, singer ..... and he also play the saxophone. It's the total that counts.

Here is another great musician, Jimmy Hall. He is also a saxplayer. He replaced his Mk VI for a Bundy II.
View: https://youtu.be/PZAUgMC_ZVM
 
" Well I got this guitar
And I learned how to make it talk"
(some lines from "Thunder Road", Bruce Springsteen.)

For me, 100% rocksax, it's just to make my stuff (saxes, mouthpieces reeds) "talk". 8 persons out of 10 thought I was terrible on the sax. So I played for myself and the remaining two. Nowadays just for myself. So try to do your own thing. A pro player/teacher/instructor can help you with what type of music (style and groove) that's suit you. And be prepared that you might get answers that you don't expected.

Yes, there are differences. My Martin Comm II alto was probably a much better sax than any other modern altos. Wellbuilt, solid nickel silver keys, even scale, a powerful and focused tone, custom pad job (good pads, oversized sterling silver reflectors/resonators, quick and distinct action and the sax was renovated and set-up by a guy that are familiar with Martin saxes. But nodody wanted to buy even if the price was low. So what are saxplayers searching for?

The sax and all the other stuff it's just a small part. It's the total that counts. I went to see and listen to Van Morrisson the other day. I'm a big Van Morrison fan. Great songwriter, singer ..... and he also play the saxophone. It's the total that counts.

Here is another great musician, Jimmy Hall. He is also a saxplayer. He replaced his Mk VI for a Bundy II.
View: https://youtu.be/PZAUgMC_ZVM
Can you pm me rockschool stuff.. like to get out is fligjt best...
 
Only you Eddie can decide whether its right for you to buy, but you could help yourself by going to a shop and trying a few alto's it would at least give you an insight to what you don't want, and you could compare them to your Hanson.
If you like your Hanson"s sound then why would you worry that it might be difficult to sell, you already own it.
If you are buying without trying first then you are really taking a big risk unless you can get the horn cheap enough to move it on.
As Pete has said spending more money doesn't always mean better.
 
Only you Eddie can decide whether its right for you to buy, but you could help yourself by going to a shop and trying a few alto's it would at least give you an insight to what you don't want, and you could compare them to your Hanson.
If you like your Hanson"s sound then why would you worry that it might be difficult to sell, you already own it.
If you are buying without trying first then you are really taking a big risk unless you can get the horn cheap enough to move it on.
As Pete has said spending more money doesn't always mean better.
Ooh ive had a couple of altos..lol. issue is with a shop i don't want to buy new. Tried the vintage route conn 6m but current sax of choice is tenor..Had a mk 1 before and liked it enough so was just thinking of getting nother as at least they retain value..saying that the Hansons is a fine sax, and i got it as px for the Conn at a price I can't lose on..
 
There is no issue with shops because you don't have to buy from them although you might just find one that blows you away like what happened to me when I went to try the Raw alto, but its good to try others to rule out makes that don't suit.
Actually why not keep the Hanson, you keep saying it's a fine sax so what are you expecting to get more from another horn?
 
There is no issue with shops because you don't have to buy from them although you might just find one that blows you away like what happened to me when I went to try the Raw alto, but its good to try others to rule out makes that don't suit.
Actually why not keep the Hanson, you keep saying it's a fine sax so what are you expecting to get more from another horn?
Only piece of mind not anything more..think I would prefer a name..mk 1 has stood the test of time and holds it's value..used the price is good and if i don't ever pick up the alto It should retain its value...I had one but swapped that and a S6 for a 6m..it really is a shame Hansons aren't availlable anywhere but yorkshire..its the only bad thing about them.
 
Well its your money, doesn't make sense to me but we are all different.
Not sure what you mean with the Hansons, why should it matter where you can buy them from, if its a good horn then that's all that should matter, I have a Viking M60 alto which is no longer made, its a fine horn so its a keeper, I would never buy a horn just because it might hold its value, it has to be a player otherwise its useless to me.
 
My way of only buying bargain used, and some new, horns (maximum 50% of what you'd expect to pay) allows me to try all sorts, including the three 62 PL altos, without fear of losing money on resale.

It also allows me more recently, now I know better, to compare horns side by side for a good while before selling on the "loser/s".

However, whereas in my early days I'd decide to get rid of the loser the day a seemingly better sax arrived I'm finding it more difficult nowadays. That may be because I'm a more experienced player (on alto) or that I know how to spot potential or indeed issues with a used sax.

If I were to sell my current Vito 23 alto or the new (to me) Yany Super Penn alto I may regret it as they all have characteristics I like. I remember years ago playing a mint £200 Vito for the first time, after two of the the 62's, and thinking "...this can't be right, it's so easy to play and sounds better than the 62 did." I sold that one on, thinking it can't be possible for it to be better than a 62, it just didn't seem logical.

Anyway, my point is that I seem to be getting to a point where I sound similar on any good horn I pick up. That's scary because my initial approach of "one in, one out" doesn't work anymore. I'm keeping more.

And it's followed through to tenor now, my lesser played horn (alto in your case) as I'm finding and buying bargain tenors, giving them a blow, thinking "that has potential" and putting them back in the case for posterity for fear of ditching something I later regret selling, if and when I decide to play more tenor.

I had a mint YTS-62 PL years ago, which didn't do anything for me due, I think, to inexperience on tenor. The YTS-62 MkI and the Yany Super Penn T4 I now have tucked away give me comfort for the future, and won't lose money.

Oh... and don't forget the slumbering MkVII Bari. I may never get around to playing it. Nice to have though... just in (its) case.

My other point here is that you may also fall foul of switching about with altos whereas your experience is on tenor. I bet if you played a 62 alto every day for a year, then switched back to the Hanson, you'd probably sound very similar on both. You might even prefer the Hanson.

Unless horns you buy are very cheap and won't lose you money on resale, changing your preference so often is a dangerous path to tread financially (unless you can do what I do). And also psychologically, and when trying to grow as a player.
 
Last edited:
Well its your money, doesn't make sense to me but we are all different.
Not sure what you mean with the Hansons, why should it matter where you can buy them from, if its a good horn then that's all that should matter, I have a Viking M60 alto which is no longer made, its a fine horn so its a keeper, I would never buy a horn just because it might hold its value, it has to be a player otherwise its useless to me.
Oh it goes without saying playing... liked the yas 62..Its only if i sell now id get what i paid as the hansons brand new...start playing it there may be less chance of selling..add 300 and id have enough for a 62..warped logic I know..
 
The most important thing about a horn, for me, is how it feels under the fingers.
They all sound much of a muchness apart from subtle nuances that take the right reed, the right mouthpiece and a ton of practice and experience to coax out of them.
A pro sax is built to take the rigours of gigging and ease of maintenance. So build quality is precise.
A new cheapie may be all an amateur ever needs. Ten years down the line, bin it.
The sound is you. Some cheapies play great. Straight out of the box. Tweaked even better.
Anything not "free blowing" top to bottom, is leaking and needs tweaking.
A prestige instrument is a thing of beauty, a pleasure to own and a sight to behold, but anything that fits your hands and plays in tune is a pleasure to play.
I have no idea why a collectable, prestige horn is needed to knock out the occasional solo tune.
Go for the £220 Thomann. 30 day no quibble returns. Three year guarantee. Set up and ready to go.
A 30 year old prestige horn may need subtle tweaking that makes it hard to play.
 
My way of only buying bargain used, and some new, horns (maximum 50% of what you'd expect to pay) allows me to try all sorts, including the three 62 PL altos, without fear of losing money on resale.

It also allows me more recently, now I know better, to compare horns side by side for a good while before selling on the "loser/s".

However, whereas in my early days I'd decide to get rid of the loser the day a seemingly better sax arrived I'm finding it more difficult nowadays. That may be because I'm a more experienced player (on alto) or that I know how to spot potential or indeed issues with a used sax.

If I were to sell my current Vito 23 alto or the new (to me) Yany Super Penn alto I may regret it as they all have characteristics I like. I remember years ago playing a mint £200 Vito for the first time, after two of the the 62's, and thinking "...this can't be right, it's so easy to play and sounds better than the 62 did." I sold that one on, thinking it can't be possible for it to be better than a 62, it just didn't seem logical.

Anyway, my point is that I seem to be getting to a point where I sound similar on any good horn I pick up. That's scary because my initial approach of "one in, one out" doesn't work anymore. I'm keeping more.

And it's followed through to tenor now, my lesser played horn (alto in your case) as I'm finding and buying bargain tenors, giving them a blow, thinking "that has potential" and putting them back in the case for posterity for fear of ditching something I later regret selling, if and when I decide to play more tenor.

I had a mint YTS-62 PL years ago, which didn't do anything for me due, I think, to inexperience on tenor. The YTS-62 MkI and the Yany Super Penn T4 I now have tucked away give me comfort for the future, and won't lose money.

Oh... and don't forget the slumbering MkVII Bari. I may never get around to playing it. Nice to have though... just in (its) case.

My other point here is that you may also fall foul of switching about with altos whereas your experience is on tenor. I bet if you played a 62 alto every day for a year, then switched back to the Hanson, you'd probably sound very similar on both. You might even prefer the Hanson.

Unless horns you buy are very cheap and won't lose you money on resale, changing your preference so often is a dangerous path to tread financially (unless you can do what I do). And also psychologically, and when trying to grow as a player.
Hi @DavidUK.. I dont frequently change saxes now I want a keeper..playing the 82z tenor for a year now..gave the raw 18 months but didn't care for it in the end well happy with the z ..after 6 years im not looking to biy a sound i like the 62..it enables good articulation is flexible mouthpiece wise and holds it's value. Confidence in your equipment is key..im not unconfident in the Hansons, but they don't hold any value outside yorkshire..As I said its a shame like frosties theyre greatttt. Anyhoo I think weve strayed a we bit off topic as my initial post was whether mk1s all had a one piece guard..
 
The most important thing about a horn, for me, is how it feels under the fingers.
They all sound much of a muchness apart from subtle nuances that take the right reed, the right mouthpiece and a ton of practice and experience to coax out of them.
A pro sax is built to take the rigours of gigging and ease of maintenance. So build quality is precise.
A new cheapie may be all an amateur ever needs. Ten years down the line, bin it.
The sound is you. Some cheapies play great. Straight out of the box. Tweaked even better.
Anything not "free blowing" top to bottom, is leaking and needs tweaking.
A prestige instrument is a thing of beauty, a pleasure to own and a sight to behold, but anything that fits your hands and plays in tune is a pleasure to play.
I have no idea why a collectable, prestige horn is needed to knock out the occasional solo tune.
Go for the £220 Thomann. 30 day no quibble returns. Three year guarantee. Set up and ready to go.
A 30 year old prestige horn may need subtle tweaking that makes it hard to play.
But your a tweaker @Colin the Bear...id spend so much time at the repairers there would be no practice time...Its comming out of my sax budget mates got a gearcfor music but bought a Hansons because of the issues he had with it. We cant all do what you do on a cheapie...I don't think you can go wrong with a yam. Its not about blaring a few tunes out on my own; i want more than that from my years of practice..I am not by any stretch saying that you cant be a pro on a cheaper sax but at the mo i need a wee bit of help..62 fits the bill so does the Hansons...
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom