Saxophones Yas 62 Mark ?

Like me you're trying the field and not giving anything a chance, especially if you seldom play alto. I'd stick with the Hanson and not go for the 62 the fan-boys all rave about. Or, if you do have to go 62, keep the Hanson and give both equal time playing regularly before you decide which you prefer. That's what I do now. Never let the newcomer displace what you have already without a fair fight.
The VIII looks better too, if it's just something you like to stroke occasionally.
 
Like me you're trying the field and not giving anything a chance, especially if you seldom play alto. I'd stick with the Hanson and not go for the 62 the fan-boys all rave about. Or, if you do have to go 62, keep the Hanson and give both equal time playing regularly before you decide which you prefer. That's what I do now. Never let the newcomer displace what you have already without a fair fight.
The VIII looks better too, if it's just something you like to stroke occasionally.
True that...sad thing is I am so focused on the tenor I would only buy it and stick it under the bed til the times right....that's the thing with the alto I'm not sure it will be....think I may move the Hansons on and make a decision when i'm playing it...
 
Exactly

It’s very likely that the Hanson may be better. Don’t make the mistake of equating price with quality. It can be relevant but often isn’t especially when the assessment of quality is subjective.

This is why I chose a cheap Bauhaus baritone over a Yanagisawa and happily used it professionally.


Not much at all. I believe Colin was pointing out that for only 25% more you get a brand new one. Some instruments depreciate a lot more/quicker.
To be pedantic on the mathematics it is 33.3r% more.
 
I don't understand? You sold a nice Conn 6 M. Now you wan't a to buy a YAS 62. And you already have a Hansson?

I mainly play tenor but theres a few songs id like to try which suit the alto..
Are the songs so important that you must play them on a Yamaha 62 alto? They don't fit the Hansson alto?

It's not my meaning to kill the topic. But I just don't understand.

I'm playing again. I'm 66+ years (old) and I'm just playing the music I like. I'm not going play in group again. Just on my own. Backing tracks and some necessary excercises. But I was also hesitating about my gear. A new sax, mouthpieces, better microphone ...... ? I would probably play out of tune on a new and modern sax as well. I decided to just play my old saxes and mouthpices. No more searching ... just play and have fun. Tonight I'm going play again. Last Thursday is was so glad that I could honk the high D (D3), D# (d#3), E (E3) good (?) again and some altissimo tones are slowly coming back as well. I just play 2-3 altissimo tones, so it's maybe not so much to talk about. It's fun to play again.

eb424 , I hope I can meet you someday. Some honking, RocksSax workshop, or even better, Rocksax Training Camp ...... . 😉 With or without YAS 62, just bring your mouthpiece and reeds. This summer it was not possible to arrange something with RockSax. Today it's just me and a guy from Copenhagen that are 100 % Rock & Roll Saxophone. Used to be two more guys but they started to play in big bands ......:confused:.

Back to topic.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand? You sold a nice Conn 6 M. Now you wan't a to buy a YAS 62. And you already have a Hansson?


Are the songs so important that you must play them on a Yamaha 62 alto? They don't fit the Hansson alto?

It's not my meaning to kill the topic. But I just don't understand.

I'm playing again. I'm 66+ years (old) and I'm just playing the music I like. I'm not going play in group again. Just on my own. Backing tracks and some necessary excercises. But I was also hesitating about my gear. A new sax, mouthpieces, better microphone ...... ? I would probably play out of tune on a new and modern sax as well. I decided to just play my old saxes and mouthpices. No more searching ... just play and have fun. Tonight I'm going play again. Last Thursday is was so glad that I could honk the high D (D3), D# (d#3), E (E3) good (?) again and some altissimo tones are slowly coming back as well. I just play 2-3 altissimo tones, so it's maybe not so much to talk about. It's fun to play again.

eb424 , I hope I can meet you someday. Some honking, RocksSax workshop, or even better, Rocksax Training Camp ...... . 😉 With or without YAS 62, just bring your mouthpiece and reeds. This summer it was not possible to arrange something with RockSax. Today it's just me and a guy from Copenhagen that are 100 % Rock & Roll Saxophone. Used to be two more guys but they started to play in big bands ......:confused:.

Back to topic.
I will definately try to get out.. sounds fun..Completely agree with what you say and am glad that your playing again and its going well...thats what its suppossed to be about playing and fun...
 
FWIW, I've played many Yamahas on and off since the 70s. All were excellent horns. Some a bit darker or brighter than others, but nothing that can't be overcome with technique.

I think the purple logo thing is complete nonsense. But I'm grateful for it since I've made a lot more money than I would have otherwise when selling all my purple logo horns over the years.

Similarly all the mark this and mark that business is also nonsense, IMO. All have miniscule differences that don't make a bit of difference in how the horn plays. I acknowledge Yamaha made a few out of tune necks along the line, but that's easily rectified.

In any case, you don't need more horns. You just need to play what you've got. It's not the equipment, it's the player.
 
Last edited:
FWIW, I've played many Yamahas on and off since the 70s. All were excellent horns. Some a bit darker or brighter than others, but nothing that can't be overcome with technique.

I think the purple logo thing is complete nonsense. But I'm grateful for it since I've made a lot more money than I would have otherwise when selling all my purple logo horns over the years.

Similarly all the mark this and mark that business is also nonsense, IMO. All have miniscule differences that don't make a bit of difference in how the horn plays. I acknowledge Yamaha made a few out of tune necks along the line, but that's easily rectified.

In any case, you don't need more horns. You just need to play what you've got. It's not the equipment, it's the player.
Hi @lydian...its not that I want a pl particularly, engraved mk 1 will do.. its just that boutiqe saxes which are just as good are harder to move on if and when the time comes..its purely knowing that i have a horn that I enjoy playing but that holds its value is important..thats the only reason I wouldn't buy new again lost a grand in a year...
 
Hi @lydian...its not that I want a pl particularly, engraved mk 1 will do.. its just that boutiqe saxes which are just as good are harder to move on if and when the time comes..its purely knowing that i have a horn that I enjoy playing but that holds its value is important..thats the only reason I wouldn't buy new again lost a grand in a year...
That's good to hear. I've never bought a new horn due to the massive drop in value the moment you buy it. It's taken me 40 years to buy/sell/trade up to the horns I have today, all of which are virtually free considering the profits I've made. My Mark VI alone appreciated 700% in those 40 years, enabling me to buy an alto, tenor and bari with that money. So I'll never fault anyone for trying to get a good deal, only for trying to buy chops in a box. I never sounded any different from one horn to the next, but I never expected to. I was just working my way up to more and better quality horns that had better action and needed less repairs.
 
If you like the Hanson there’s no reason to move it on. You wanted a tenor that was easier to blow but if the Hanson plays comfortably for you then why change it? Nobody knows what horns will be worth in the future or how the market will play out and we’re not talking gaining or losing thousands, although if you keep moving horns on you will lose quite a lot quite quickly, and it all takes such a lot of your time. If you want it because you want it and it will make you happier that’s a different matter altogether.

Buying horns to make a profit is also a different game, good luck to people who do it but you’re a player. The horns I’ve got would probably lose money if I sold them but I play them and don’t have any plans to sell them in the near future. If/when I do I’ll have had years of pleasure just playing them and I’m prepared to factor that in. If I sell a horn I’ve been playing for 20 years and lose a grand it will have cost me £1 a week.
 
So I'll never fault anyone for trying to get a good deal, only for trying to buy chops in a box.
Excellent comment.

I would also never criticise anyone who decided to treat themselves, indulge themselves with a new sax. You can certainly find far worse things to spend your hard earned cash on. But anyone who thinks a shiny new Selmagisaha is going to make them a great player is being a fool to themselves.
 
Bought a band new Gear4music alto loved it and played it for 11 years, alongside selmers, yanis, conn's etc. Probable 100% depreciation. £320. Full repair kit en route from China. £27. Oil can and cleaning cloth on standby. Resurrection imminent. 😉
 
Excellent comment.

I would also never criticise anyone who decided to treat themselves, indulge themselves with a new sax. You can certainly find far worse things to spend your hard earned cash on. But anyone who thinks a shiny new Selmagisaha is going to make them a great player is being a fool to themselves.
I see so many beginners online get perfectly good horns that would last anybody a lifetime, yet buy another slightly different horn 6 months later, then another and another. I like shiny new things as much as the next guy, and if you like to collect shiny new things, knock yourself out. Just don’t expect any horn to make you a better player.

Similar story with mouthpieces. If you don’t yet know how to make a good sound, how do you know what sort of mouthpiece to buy? So some just keep buying and buying hoping the next piece will magically make them sound like Kenny G.

If you’re a beginner and already have good equipment, just give it a chance for a couple of years before you go on a shopping spree.
 
That's good to hear. I've never bought a new horn due to the massive drop in value the moment you buy it. It's taken me 40 years to buy/sell/trade up to the horns I have today, all of which are virtually free considering the profits I've made. My Mark VI alone appreciated 700% in those 40 years, enabling me to buy an alto, tenor and bari with that money. So I'll never fault anyone for trying to get a good deal, only for trying to buy chops in a box. I never sounded any different from one horn to the next, but I never expected to. I was just working my way up to more and better quality horns that had better action and needed less repairs.
oh come on @lydian 🙂 lets not do the chops in a box thingy...For a fun player I don't half put in the hours and am loving the tenor...It's purely rather having a sax that is easier to move on if the need arises, no doubt the Hansons is a quality sax and i have had the conversation with him about why he doesn't market like TJ he follows the same model and IMHO the saxes are just as good..but TJ market their saxes openly..making the value greater...I can't believe that you sounded the same on all saxes...
 
If you like the Hanson there’s no reason to move it on. You wanted a tenor that was easier to blow but if the Hanson plays comfortably for you then why change it? Nobody knows what horns will be worth in the future or how the market will play out and we’re not talking gaining or losing thousands, although if you keep moving horns on you will lose quite a lot quite quickly, and it all takes such a lot of your time. If you want it because you want it and it will make you happier that’s a different matter altogether.

Buying horns to make a profit is also a different game, good luck to people who do it but you’re a player. The horns I’ve got would probably lose money if I sold them but I play them and don’t have any plans to sell them in the near future. If/when I do I’ll have had years of pleasure just playing them and I’m prepared to factor that in. If I sell a horn I’ve been playing for 20 years and lose a grand it will have cost me £1 a week.
true that @Jimmymack...just preping for the future..Ive so much to learn still on the tenor so it doesnt matter what alto is sitting around for a while...I swapped the conn 6m for cash plus the Hansons so wont work out a loss...but initialy thought I would be happy with any sax on the wardrobe ready to play...I have had a series one before and just think I'd rather have a well known sax up there because if I never play it ( which I think I will) it's easier to move on...ergo I might as well get the difficult bit ( i.e. selling the Hansons) out the way and buy a mk 1 whilst I am not playing the alto....lunacy I know..
 
Bought a band new Gear4music alto loved it and played it for 11 years, alongside selmers, yanis, conn's etc. Probable 100% depreciation. £320. Full repair kit en route from China. £27. Oil can and cleaning cloth on standby. Resurrection imminent. 😉
already said I admire your philosophy @Colin the Bear I wish I could make a cheap sax sound as good as you.. and I mean that genuinely....
 
I see so many beginners online get perfectly good horns that would last anybody a lifetime, yet buy another slightly different horn 6 months later, then another and another. I like shiny new things as much as the next guy, and if you like to collect shiny new things, knock yourself out. Just don’t expect any horn to make you a better player.

Similar story with mouthpieces. If you don’t yet know how to make a good sound, how do you know what sort of mouthpiece to buy? So some just keep buying and buying hoping the next piece will magically make them sound like Kenny G.

If you’re a beginner and already have good equipment, just give it a chance for a couple of years before you go on a shopping spree.
settled now with the tenor custom z to many mouthpieces but gradually whittling down selling Gaia keeping Durga got Phil tone impulse and vandoren medium chamber metal V16..I cant do everything on one piece yet fine up to palm key F# down to bottom B on them all, durga great for really lairy high songs, V16 deep and darker and the impulse a great fun piece..size 8...I have learnt that I don't like a large tip opening large chamber the med chamber V16 is great..I like baffled pieces for the high stuff but the v16 size 7 is easier for ballads tho with the right reed the phil tone is cool...I'm really not playing alto believe it or not I like consistency so sticking with the tenor..just trying to prepare for the time when i will play alto again I started on a Hansons Alto 6 years ago and it was great but...need to know in my head that the sax i have will hold it's value..
 
Excellent comment.

I would also never criticise anyone who decided to treat themselves, indulge themselves with a new sax. You can certainly find far worse things to spend your hard earned cash on. But anyone who thinks a shiny new Selmagisaha is going to make them a great player is being a fool to themselves.
Ive been playing for six years and it has been a long journey on tenor to get settled been through the vintage vs modern thing and I'm finally settled..I've just got my mouthpiece reeds and tenor sorted and have had a Mk1 alto before so would like to get the difficulty of buying and selling the alto out the way so when the times right I can focus on playing... but...I would also quit like to fool proof the future and have a sax that I am comfortable playing but that will hold it's value in case of the need to move it on...chops in a box i'm not expecting...
 
oh come on @lydian 🙂 lets not do the chops in a box thingy...For a fun player I don't half put in the hours and am loving the tenor...It's purely rather having a sax that is easier to move on if the need arises, no doubt the Hansons is a quality sax and i have had the conversation with him about why he doesn't market like TJ he follows the same model and IMHO the saxes are just as good..but TJ market their saxes openly..making the value greater...I can't believe that you sounded the same on all saxes...
I guess you'll just have to take my word for it about sounding the same.

I just try to discourage beginning players from constantly buying/selling horns. It's not going to make any difference. You've already had horns in the past that were easy to move on. So you could have just kept those to begin with.

Regardless, it's your money, so do what you like.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom