Saxophones Yani Necks

Hi all.
My 901 Yani alto had both its standard neck and a bronze one, and there did seem a very slight difference, but very difficult to quantify. I always thought that buying a different m/p would have been a much cheaper way of getting a sound change, and probably a more marked one at that!
I also had a Yani 880 sop with two necks, one straight and one curved, and the difference between the two was very noticeable. So is it the material, the shape, or what?:confused::confused::confused:
 
Hi all.
My 901 Yani alto had both its standard neck and a bronze one, and there did seem a very slight difference, but very difficult to quantify. I always thought that buying a different m/p would have been a much cheaper way of getting a sound change, and probably a more marked one at that
My bet (FWIW) would be that the intrernal dimensions weren't quite the same

I also had a Yani 880 sop with two necks, one straight and one curved, and the difference between the two was very noticeable. So is it the material, the shape, or what?:confused::confused::confused:
Another possibility with the sop would be that holding it at a different angale was affecting your embouchure.
 
My bet (FWIW) would be that the intrernal dimensions weren't quite the same

Another possibility with the sop would be that holding it at a different angale was affecting your embouchure.

I actually did wonder about either that or the difference in playing angle relative to my ear............BUT, the sound was also different on recordings, and since you adjust the way you hold the instrument the embouchure/playing angle was much the same.
I really do think the curved neck sound was warmer and more mellow, and the straight neck sound more `punchy` and bright, and rather louder too!
Interestingly `curly` sop`s also seem to sound rather different again.
 
Cripes (as Billy Bunter used to say) I didn't expect all those responses and discussion. Thank you everyone.
My T901u is, I feel, a bit lightweight as sound goes. Like it doesn't have a lot of bottle. I'm thinking more volume and a rougher sound if that makes sense.
I have for the past few months been using a Yani metal m/piece which has shown a substantial improvement, in my ears and my teacher's, over the metal Otto Link used previously, which was quite dead or lifeless. Now whether a change in crook/neck is the way to go I am not sure. I have experimented with reeds and have no particular preference regards cane. I play a 3 strength and like the Legere signature I have been blowing for the last couple of months
 
Cripes (as Billy Bunter used to say) I didn't expect all those responses and discussion. Thank you everyone.
My T901u is, I feel, a bit lightweight as sound goes. Like it doesn't have a lot of bottle. I'm thinking more volume and a rougher sound if that makes sense.
I have for the past few months been using a Yani metal m/piece which has shown a substantial improvement, in my ears and my teacher's, over the metal Otto Link used previously, which was quite dead or lifeless. Now whether a change in crook/neck is the way to go I am not sure. I have experimented with reeds and have no particular preference regards cane. I play a 3 strength and like the Legere signature I have been blowing for the last couple of months

Hi Jake. I used both the metal and ebonite 7 m/p`s with mine, depending on the circumstances. They gave me quite a sound range, and I had no problems on the power front with the 901, using the bronze neck. The 9903 was a warmer and more complex sound though.
 
Hi Jake!

I think that the Bronze neck made a good bit of difference, but the sax is not going to naturally make a "vintage sound" IMO. The mouthpieces that have worked for me are the Francois Louis Spectruoso 280ML, and the Phil Barone Jazz. The PPT sounds good, also, but I think that a good mouthpiece would require a bit of a search - See Morgan Fry's work for other possibilities - Paul plays a Link that has been worked on by Morgan, and he seems quite happy with that.

Kind regards
Tom
 
Hi Andy
I'm new here and interested to see you use a 92 bronze neck on your T901. I have the T901's predecessor, just marked with a Greek "u", and wondered about the effect of the change in neck or crook.
Thanks

When I bought my T901 I found the sound very bright and I wanted to warm it up. I found the bronze neck does that but not by a massive amount, the change was based on recommendations from forum members as I'm new to the forum too. The biggest change for me was the mouthpiece, I use an Otto Link Tone Edge and it really gives a warm sound. Tomorrow night I'll put the brass neck on and see the difference it makes and report my findings 🙂
 
I actually did wonder about either that or the difference in playing angle relative to my ear............BUT, the sound was also different on recordings, and since you adjust the way you hold the instrument the embouchure/playing angle was much the same.

Interesting. I've just been playing my new sop with the curved neck to save my arms some work, but I can see I'll have to have a play with the straight one.

I really do think the curved neck sound was warmer and more mellow, and the straight neck sound more `punchy` and bright, and rather louder too!
Interestingly `curly` sop`s also seem to sound rather different again.
In any case, we're talking about shape rather than material here.

The reason I'm sceptical about the material affecting the way air passes through it is that any metal (or other solid) surface will have a layer of gas adsorbed (ie stuck) onto it so the moving air wouldn't be hitting the metal anyway. I may have mentioned this here before, but one of my pet science facts is that on the first space walks the astronauts were surprised to find their gloves and boots sticking to the surface of the spacecraft because this adsorbed gas layer wasn't there to lubricate the contact.
 
I'd be more interested in measuring Nick's vibrations when he reads threads like this one. Perhaps he needs a good sanding down, might make him play brighter.................................;}

Right we need to form a committee to elect the members to their jobs (holding him down, superglueing the accelerometers to his neck etc.) Only the first ten applicants will be successful >:).

John.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Such as the subtle differences between a Brass and Bronze Saxes. I find that a Bronze Sax has more warmth and subtlety whereas Brass gives a more unrelenting power and projection. I’m thinking of the T992 and the T991 when I say that. Why is that? What is the different between those Saxes apart from material?

The T991 and T992 Yanis do sound different. I spent ages play testing them (and loads of other saxes as well) before settling on the T992. However, there is a difference in them other than body material - completely different pads, which I think is likely to make more difference to the sound than bronze vs brass.
 
The T991 and T992 Yanis do sound different. I spent ages play testing them (and loads of other saxes as well) before settling on the T992. However, there is a difference in them other than body material - completely different pads, which I think is likely to make more difference to the sound than bronze vs brass.

Thanks! I didn't notice the different pads when playing them side by side. That would make a difference.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,572
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom