Miscellaneous Wouldn't dream of it

Some people here are saying that they begin on alto and move on to tenor as they progress. I absolutely love the alto and wouldn't even dream of 'moving on'. Anyone else feel like this?

I started on alto, tried tenor,back to alto,tried soprano and fell in love! I play soprano only,I like a challenge! I went smaller! Perhaps it comes with age?
 
Some people here are saying that they begin on alto and move on to tenor as they progress. I absolutely love the alto and wouldn't even dream of 'moving on'. Anyone else feel like this?

Hi Miss Saxophone and well done for creating a blog, which I am enjoying reading 🙂
I have been teaching myself saxophone for 8 months and am really enjoying it, I started on alto and after a few months and listening to lots of music found that I loved the sound of the Tenor, so I bought one but found it heavy and awkward to play and stuck with alto. Mind you I couldn't even hold my alto correctly for months! Just recently I bought the Guest Spot Blues book (which I love) for Tenor and have got used to the weight and size of the Tenor. I really seem to have connected with it and where with alto I just don't seem to get it right despite having an amazing alto sax, with Tenor somehow everything has just started to fall into place and feels right. It totally relaxes me. Having said that I will definitely still be playing alto too, it is nice to have a change sometimes.
So rather than waffle any more I think my point is that maybe people don't "progress" onto Tenor, maybe they just find their instrument? Maybe one day I will be equally as comfortable with both but massively enjoying the journey 🙂
Jo x
 
One of the standard beliefs out there was that the Alto was better to start on as it was lighter to hold for teenage music students (it IS lighter than a Tenor) and was easier to play than a Soprano. Hence everyone should start on an Alto, period. It is more common, especially for adult students and Late Bloomers that people are encouraged to play what they want to, irrespective of any particular challenges. I started on Soprano, then Alto, and my interest has spread wider. At the same time I prefer the Alto above all the saxes, but do enjoy playing the appropriate instrument for any particular music - so prefer trumpet for any Miles Davis music, and trombone for Ska music etc.

So it is fair to conclude that the Alto does not need to be seen as a starter instrument, but has been seen that way by music teachers in school setings for fairly valid reasons, which have become the norm even though many adults now start learning to play musical instruments after they have left school, where any strength issues are far less important!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I get terrible back ache which limits me from standing up too long - I'm fine sitting down though. So my teacher asked me why I didn't go for a soprano instead. Well, I just adore the alto too much! 🙂 ... and if it means backache then so be it! I can always sit down and play!
 
I started seven years ago on the alto, but realised after about three months that I preferred the sound of the tenor. When I first started I had this plan to play the soprano, alto and the tenor. I don't think I even knew that there were saxes lower than a tenor or higher than a soprano.
It didn't take me long to realise that I didn't want a soprano and, at around the same time, I discovered the baritone, although I had to wait until October 2009 before I had the opportunity to buy a one.
I won't say that I neglected the alto, I just didn't play it much. The tenor held my attention until the bari arrived and now I play tenor and bari in equal amounts. I'm not as dedicated or as strict with my practice as some people are, I don't play bari one day and tenor the next, I just play whichever takes my fancy that day.
However, the band I play in have just thrown a large spanner in my works and they have decided that they want to add some different tunes to the set list. One is played on the alto (which had it's first public outing last Friday night and went down an absolute storm) and the other is alto and soprano!!! So maybe I'll have a rethink and get myself a little squawker after all! (Although it'll have to wait until some money comes rolling in!)

Loving the blog by the way
 
I get terrible back ache which limits me from standing up too long - I'm fine sitting down though. So my teacher asked me why I didn't go for a soprano instead. Well, I just adore the alto too much! 🙂 ... and if it means backache then so be it! I can always sit down and play!

You could have done worse than learn to play soprano.................

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7prKXfvWD3w&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mjgr9UJuODM&feature=related
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom