Tech/maintenance Why do old saxes and cases smell like that? And how can it be stopped?

Not a gipsy:
SeleniteGypsumUSGOV.jpg
 
I once bought an old Yamaha YTS 61 years ago that had an exceptionally smelly case, it was just rank, I was aware of it before I even opened the case, it was that bad. Luckily the horn was cheap so I bought it and ditched the case at the local dump on my way home. I don't think the YTS61 had ever seen a pull through, it was full of snot and grunge plus god knows what else. The deposits were a around 2- 3 mm thick Inside the bow.

This, however, is not to be confused with the smell that Saxlicker mentioned, that's quite a pleasent smell in comparison. Like a combination of aged brass, leather and oil.

In my experience there is no permanent cure for this apart from a new case. Any deodorisers or such like just temporarily mask the smell, as said before you have to remove the cause (really difficult) not just treat the smell.
 
I like old saxes but I don't old sax cases! I have Hicox cases for my saxes. Fit most ols saxes but The Tonking tenor (Keilwerth it's to big for my Hicox). I tried to make new shaped cases for "The Martin ... "saxes (low Bb bari). I was going to buy an empty shaped case and have two half of of the interior done by foam. Firmer outside and softer closer to the sax. We took a "The Martin" sax into a big plastic bag and pressed it in to a form of gipsy. Both right and feft side. The the sculpture the gipsy and made that the could spray foam into the sax shell. He did very nice job. 3D computer soft ware. The problem was that no manufactor of glasfiber/plastic cases wanted to sell an empty shell to me. I tried in EU and USA. The chinese cases were not good enough. We just did one alto case. I bought a case in USA. Not a top case but it worked. The secret for a good case is to have no organic (or less) material.
This is great advice. Old cases are fertile ground for fungus, which is the number 1 culprit of the smell and really hard to eradicate. Also, vintage style cases are recipes for banana bends. Toss them. The old saxes are well deserving of a new case no different than new saxes. The horns of vintage may be better but the cases are/were not.
 
Last edited:
I like old saxes but I don't old sax cases! I have Hicox cases for my saxes. Fit most ols saxes but The Tonking tenor (Keilwerth it's to big for my Hicox). I tried to make new shaped cases for "The Martin ... "saxes (low Bb bari). I was going to buy an empty shaped case and have two half of of the interior done by foam. Firmer outside and softer closer to the sax. We took a "The Martin" sax into a big plastic bag and pressed it in to a form of gipsy. Both right and feft side. The the sculpture the gipsy and made that the could spray foam into the sax shell. He did very nice job. 3D computer soft ware. The problem was that no manufactor of glasfiber/plastic cases wanted to sell an empty shell to me. I tried in EU and USA. The chinese cases were not good enough. We just did one alto case. I bought a case in USA. Not a top case but it worked. The secret for a good case is to have no organic (or less) material.

It'd be nice to see how it looks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sorry to revive this thread but...We have two Yamahas, a YTS and a YAS 61 in daily use for undergraduate study. We have the original cases but don't use them. The alto case still smells of the smoke filled bars of its youth and the tenor case is a bit droopy but OK.
Question. If we ever have a windfall and want to sell the saxes to upgrade, will the old cases add to the value or should we just dispose of them?
 
It will enhance saleability rather than value at this moment in time (even if a buyer changes the case).
If the 'classic' value of the 61's go up in the future then the case being present will possibly increase the value depending on how nuts people are for 61's.

Not much in it at the present time I think.
 
It will enhance saleability rather than value at this moment in time (even if a buyer changes the case).
If the 'classic' value of the 61's go up in the future then the case being present will possibly increase the value depending on how nuts people are for 61's.

Not much in it at the present time I think.

Good point. Saleability is probably the question I was asking. The value of the saxes is that these are what my daughter uses for university study. I suspect that these 61s won't be disposed of any time soon because the cost of upgrading makes my eyes water, and anyway she sounds good on them. Mind you, University teachers do like the sound of the word Selmer!
 
I've never had to do this, but I think I would attemp to attempt something quite drastic.

But I would accept there are some risks, so would not attempt with a very valuable case or a family heirloom.

Assuming that it's best to attack the problem at the root cause, not just symptoms, I would bathe the case and then scrub it out. I assume this would help towards removing fungus/mould spores.

I would use a solution that includes some antifungal chemical, maybe the stuff you get at Wickes for masonry that has got fungus/lichen.

Be careful not to use anything for scrubbing that is too harsh on velevt/felt (ie not a wire brush) maybe a nail brush or toothbrush to get into nooks and crannies.

Then it must be dried quite quickly and thoroughly (hair drier or space heater) so moisture doesn't remain too long and add to the problem. I'd also look into whether some kind of spirit such as meths (without igniting) might help kill anything, it would dry out and I like the smell. Maybe Vodka but a bit of a waste.

Once dry i would then try Charcoal, Febreze or shake n vac, then finally something that you find smells nice to help mask any residual odour. (Lavendar, Sandalwood, Linseed Oil or whatever you like the smell of.)

If that doesn't work, burn it.
 
Last edited:
I tried to salvage the original case my Selmer SBA alto came in which had a horrible odor. I tried sprays, charcoal, baking soda, sunshine, etc. to no effect. Then I removed all of the inner lining and padding from the case and the odor was still prevalent. At that point I tried bleach and other wood cleaners along with fresh air and sunshine for a few weeks, and the odor was still in the wood. This was before I discovered Dr's. Case Odor Eliminator. I don't know if it would have worked or not.
 
I tried to salvage the original case my Selmer SBA alto came in which had a horrible odor. I tried sprays, charcoal, baking soda, sunshine, etc. to no effect. Then I removed all of the inner lining and padding from the case and the odor was still prevalent. At that point I tried bleach and other wood cleaners along with fresh air and sunshine for a few weeks, and the odor was still in the wood. This was before I discovered Dr's. Case Odor Eliminator. I don't know if it would have worked or not.

I get the feeling giving the wood a good going over with turpentine (while not smoking) and then rubbing a lot of linseed oil and /or varnishing would do the trick
 
I get the feeling giving the wood a good going over with turpentine (while not smoking) and then rubbing a lot of linseed oil and /or varnishing would do the trick
You may be right. It never occurred to me to put an airtight coating over the wood. In any event, I have re-covered a few old wooden cases and it is a lot more work than it is worth. 🙂
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,439
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom