Tech/maintenance Why do old saxes and cases smell like that? And how can it be stopped?

I've had great succes putting a bowl filled with activated charcoal in the case and leaving the case closed for a week or two.
The charcoual absorbs the bad smell. It can be reused several times after a rinse in running water and drying it.
I bought 5 kilos of activated charcoal sold for use in aquariums. That's the cheapest solution.
I've also used it in my car, my fridge, my house and so on
If the charcoal absorbs the smell, are you saying that after two weeks the smell disappears never to return? In other words, the smell has "run out"? Surely this would be the same as simply leaving the case open so the smell wafts off somewhere else?
I can understand the charcoal absorbing the emitted smell whilst it's close by, but when removed from the case I'd have thought the smell would return?

What I did with my silver Buffet, once polished, was to buy 200g of activated charcoal for £3 delivered, then use a cotton glove (as comes with cheap horns). Glove then goes in the case with the sax. One glove takes 100g approx. Too early to say if it will help keep tarnishing at bay. This might be a good option to fend off the smell?

P6172524.webp


I too have heard of Febreze being used and then leaving the case open outside in the dry to "air".
 
I've been meaning to ask, what the hell are the gloves for?! I see saxes advertised with a mouthpiece, lig, sling and gloves. I don't have any white gloves. Have I been doing something wrong?
 
The gloves are to warn off buyers from buying the advertised model?

Seriously, I think they're supposed to be for cleaning but I've never used any. I did buy some nylon gloves locally when cleaning/assembling my silver plated Buffet. They worked well for that purpose, keeping fingerprints at bay whilst holding the sax.
 
If the charcoal absorbs the smell, are you saying that after two weeks the smell disappears never to return? In other words, the smell has "run out"? Surely this would be the same as simply leaving the case open so the smell wafts off somewhere else?
I can understand the charcoal absorbing the emitted smell whilst it's close by, but when removed from the case I'd have thought the smell would return?

Yes - the activted charcaol absorbs the smell, so that the reduction or removal of the unwanted smell does not return after removal
 
Yes - the activted charcaol absorbs the smell, so that the reduction or removal of the unwanted smell does not return after removal
I'd say you'd need to remove the source of the smell, not just the smell, to ensure it doesn't return. That means some physical intervention with the material holding whatever is causing the smell by washing, cleaning, disinfecting...
 
I like old saxes but I don't old sax cases! I have Hicox cases for my saxes. Fit most ols saxes but The Tonking tenor (Keilwerth it's to big for my Hicox). I tried to make new shaped cases for "The Martin ... "saxes (low Bb bari). I was going to buy an empty shaped case and have two half of of the interior done by foam. Firmer outside and softer closer to the sax. We took a "The Martin" sax into a big plastic bag and pressed it in to a form of gipsy. Both right and feft side. The the sculpture the gipsy and made that the could spray foam into the sax shell. He did very nice job. 3D computer soft ware. The problem was that no manufactor of glasfiber/plastic cases wanted to sell an empty shell to me. I tried in EU and USA. The chinese cases were not good enough. We just did one alto case. I bought a case in USA. Not a top case but it worked. The secret for a good case is to have no organic (or less) material.
 
This is one subject where I've had considerable experience. I've owned many trumpets, cornets, saxes, guitars, and other instruments in old cases.

After vacuuming the inside, and finding a spray that will help kill off any bacteria, leave the case open, or propped open with a clean, rolled up t-shirt. Give it days to dry out thoroughly. Avoid, or at least use great caution about leaving it in direct sunlight, there's glue holding the lining down in many cases, and direct sun can cause the glue to let go of the lining.

Note: Febreze spray used to be recommended often for eliminating case odor. IMO, it replaces case odor, and I haven't found a Febreze flavor smell that I like that much! There's many brands of dryer sheets with orange, or other pleasant smell. Place a dryer sheet in the case after cleaning-no sax, just an empty case with a dryer sheet, or possibly two. Don't close the sheet in there unless the case is completely dry after cleaning or vacuuming. If you have a dryer sheet in an empty, closed case, remove it after 2-3 days.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, plaster is gips in Swedish. I took a chance! The one we made for "The Martin Alto" is realy good.

Back to topic. Don't use old cases from the 20's, 30's ...... it's not good for your sax.
 
I agree with the one other person who liked the smell of old cases, reminiscent of when you get into a very old car, ( 60s or earlier ) the smell is part of the 'time travelling' experience..
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom