Saxophones Why aren't saxes lighter?

If the weight of a modern sax, built using rib construction, (that is all the key work and other gubbins, pillars etc are mounted on a seperate plate or rib, then atached to the sax) is becoming to heavy for you why not look at a vintage sax, something like a Conn 10m? were everything is attached to the sax without the rib.



Fraser...

My two main horns are a Yani T902 (ribbed keywork)
and a 1939 Buescher Aristocrat

When I first got the Yani (which was my first serious horn) It seemed humungously heavt and when I was out with the street band I used to use a neck strap but have a harness under my jacket if the weight got too much after a couple of hours. These days I don't seem to need to do that so much, I think my neck muscles must have strengthened.

By comparison the Buescher feels a bit like a toy it is so light.
 
I weighed two of my altos last night, just out of interest. A 1926 Buescher True Tone and a Yanagisawa A6. The Yanagisawa was heavier, but not much in it. Buescher was 2.17kg, Yani 2.38, so just over 200g or about 10%. Enough to be noticable but not a huge amount.
 
I've just changed from a Selmer MK VII to a Yani T901, and the Yani is wonderfully lighter. In fact I was worried whether I had bought something of quality at first as we perceive heaviness with quality. I have heard the bronze models are heavier and even the T991 model is heavier. I personally would never buy a plastic saxophone. After a couple of hours practicing it still gets heavy round the neck but is bareable.
 
A Selmer Mk VI alto weighs in at 2.3Kg, whereas a Selmer BA alto is 2.2kg - both have ribbed construction.

Compare that to a Mauriat System 75 alto which comes in at 2.59Kg and a generic Chinese alto at 2.6Kg

Regards,
 
Got a neck like a formula one driver schlepping my Mauriat PMXT 66R around, weighs a bloody ton. well i do normally but have a bout of carpal tunnel at the mo so not playing much. Oh! that's why i've grown an inch these last two months.
 
In an article written for the CASS magazine, Prof. Michelle Gringras (Miami Uni.) mentioned that most of her students changed from Yamaha saxes to Selmer, to get the darker sound, even though the Selmers were harder to play. The Selmers darker sound was put down to the heavier gauge metal used in their construction.

Jim.
 
In an article written for the CASS magazine, Prof. Michelle Gringras (Miami Uni.) mentioned that most of her students changed from Yamaha saxes to Selmer, to get the darker sound, even though the Selmers were harder to play. The Selmers darker sound was put down to the heavier gauge metal used in their construction.

Jim.

Which only means that Prof. Gringras isn't a professor of acoustics.

Regards,
 
The recent introduction of the vibratosax has brought lots of people to think that they might need a lightweight saxophone and indeed many have been speculating, again, that a light metal or light plastic material (much reference to carbon fibre of course) could be " needed" from the market. Personally, I have had an unpleasant brushing with the Vibratosax and I don't think that that product has any appeal other than its novelty, but that's me, I don't want to go into that discussion here and now.

I don't think that anybody really needs (aside from people who have some physical limitations or bari as bass saxophone marching players) a lightweight saxophone but that doesn't mean that lightness of weight couldn't be part of the introduction of a new product within the market strategy for a new and innovative saxophone.

Frankly speaking I think that there would be a niche market for a considerably expensive , innovative, horn. Saxophones are, in fact, in my opinion, and with very few exceptions, not occupying the top market segment which exists in any market for any product.

Let me explain.

A market, any market, is not made of all the products on the market and their buyers but of segments. to each segment correspond a certain amount of buyers who are prepared to buy products positioned in any of the segments constituting the market.

In other words at any time in history a market has a low, medium-low, medium-high, high and VERY high segment and has people who would buy , or not, a product , simply based on its positioning and the fact that the product fulfils or appears to fulfil their expectations for a product of a certain price.

Regardless of which product we are talking about, it is possible to introduce in any market a product which fulfils that particular segment expectations in terms of its price and uniqueness providing the buyers with the " needed" or coveted product in that particular niche.

So, from food to musical instruments, you can decide , at the drawing table, to design a product to fulfil a particular market segment and not based on what kind of product YOU as a maker can produce but basing it on what the public expects to receive for a certain amount of money that they are prepared to spend.

In other words FIRST you decide its price and THEN you design the product and how it would be fulfilling the needs of that particular market segment providing you the return that you seek to achieve. So, you don't get first the idea of the product and then derive its price (which is what Vibratosax is doing in my opinion) but proceed exactly the other way around.


Having said this, in the musical instruments market , there are many many examples of instruments costing above the 10.000$ mark.

So, there is a market there, we know that.

How many saxophones cover that market segment? Very few. What do they offer in terms of product uniqueness, image and identity? Something (the Inderbinen looks for example were a good move) but .........not enough.


In my view there is the space to produce an unique and innovative, perhaps lightweight product (such as the Matit flutes) with high technology and unique characteristics to be sold for a market which would buy a saxophone above the 10.000$ mark and my estimation is that that market segment could absorb at least 100 instruments a year on a global scale. The scale would allow a distribution model without intermediaries (as Inderbinen does) hence maximising revenues for the maker.

So, Any plans!? >:):w00t:
 
I think it would end up being extremely costly.
Part of the problem is that the sax, and other woodwind instruments, are nowhere near what you might call 'precision instruments'.
Cost is one reason, and practicality the other. They get knocked about, they get wet and dusty - and then you have to take into account the characteristics of the pads...which are, basically, organic.
If a sax was a car, it probably wouldn't even start - let alone whizz off down the road.

I think the future will be in plastics - though not for the keywork. The Grafton got it right (at least in theory).
A synthetic body with brass ribs embedded into it would shave a lot off the total weight and still provide a viable action.

Regards,

I agree with practically everything you say especially that saxophones today are not precision instuments, and that is the real rubb in this age of technical advancement there is no reason why they cannot be made as just that especially when plastic moulding and plastic science could have bodies flying off a machine all perfect and identical to each other in there millions made of a material that would be very robust in everyway.And likewise with the key work also in plastic or aluminium alloy as previously mentioned, these can be produced to fine tolerances so they fit together with the body with very little adjustment required, the pads could easily be replced with rubber or plastic and provide a much better and less varying seal than leather. Now everybody shouts the cost the cost,but in truth once set up the production costs would probably be far less than working with maleable brass which as a material is a bit old fashioned...john
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Doesn't all this talk of varying weights of different saxes just show what a wonderful piece of kit the human body is, that it can recognise these slight variations in these weights and react to them instantly...john
 
Doesn't all this talk of varying weights of different saxes just show what a wonderful piece of kit the human body is, that it can recognise these slight variations in these weights and react to them instantly...john

Yes, amazingly discerning the human body is, in so many respects.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,550
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom