Saxophones Who have a saxophone in High pitched ????

The timbre is a bigger problem than the tone height/pitch. Even if you can get a HP sax to play in ok pitch you will have a different timbre compared to a LP sax. A HP Bb is c a quarter tone above an LP tenor. Maybe is better to accept that a HP tenor will be high and tune a A= 440 HZ by tune a C instead of a B. So one and a half tone step above A=440 Hz. I don't know, were the mouthpieces that came along a new HP sax different to a LP sax? Some guys says it was different than a LP piece. Shorter with smaller chamber and bore. To play in a high distorted guitar band can be a way to use your HP sax? To add an extra piece to the tube is not helping much.
 
The timbre is a bigger problem than the tone height/pitch. Even if you can get a HP sax to play in ok pitch you will have a different timbre compared to a LP sax.

Apples and ducks. Timbre is a function of the cone; pitch is a function of length (and placement of tone holes).

If you adjust the mouthpiece to get one pitch in tune, the rest of the notes will not follow evenly. You cannot just add or subtract length at the neck and expect the rest of the horn to be predictable in tune because the distance between tone holes remains the same.

I expect that HP vs LP timbre will be much the same for a given concurrent model. The cone will be the same, but the overall length and the distance between tone holes is different.
 
Yes, being in tune does sound better.

You can play whatever music you like on a HP horn - until you have to play in tune with an instrument that is not HP.
Yes, that's right. I met a high pitch sax player that use to play along with a BM "Victor" (4 stroke and 2 cylinders) tractor. Steady as a rock. Enterantaing and good. Better than a boring big band that is searching for perfect pitch. So to say/write that a HP sax is useless and unplayable is not true. It's how you use your HP sax that's important.
 
So to say/write that a HP sax is useless and unplayable is not true.
To be fair, nobody has said that. I think anyone discussing the unsuitability of HP instruments has qualified it by saying the instrument itself may be playable, but will not play in tune with modern low pitch instruments that are tuned to A=440.

If you are playing with a tractor, then a decent HP insrument will play well.

If you are playing with instruments that can are able to alter their tuned pitch significantly (such as electronic keyboards, guitars, singers) then it can also play - provided you can persuade the players/singers to tune to your high pitch.

The. HP issue is only relevant when you need to play A=440, but in most cases that is going to be a necessity at some stage in your playing.
 
To be fair, nobody has said that.
Not on this thread but I have read that often.
If you are playing with instruments that can are able to alter their tuned pitch significantly (such as electronic keyboards, guitars, singers) then it can also play - provided you can persuade the players/singers to tune to your high pitch.
To hear Rockabilly HP sax with a guitar ("tuned up"), bass and drums is refreshing. Ok, it's subjective.

The. HP issue is only relevant when you need to play A=440, but in most cases that is going to be a necessity at some stage in your playing.
I'm not going HP. I'm searching for an ok pitch (my ears) on old LP saxes with relatively modern mouthpieces. If we all sound the same the saxophone world would be even more predictable?

I have some questions that I have "talked" with guys over the years. I have overwhelmed a sax player and saxophone designer with questions about resonators/reflectors, "large bore" saxes, tone holes, HP mouthpieces, ..... . I'm not going to write about this questions. But I write down my thoughts, I have reached the point/age.
 
Have we talked the OP out of this yet? I guess just to collect and say you have one its fine. Then again, I like Pete’s plan to play in a tractor band.
 
Last edited:
Yes, that's right. I met a high pitch sax player that use to play along with a BM "Victor" (4 stroke and 2 cylinders) tractor. Steady as a rock. Enterantaing and good. Better than a boring big band that is searching for perfect pitch. So to say/write that a HP sax is useless and unplayable is not true. It's how you use your HP sax that's important.

You could play marches on it as you stroll into the sunset. Ever played “Far, Far Away”?
 
Here she is. All this time I thought HP was "horsepower". It's really "high pitch". Good to see these old HP horns being put to good use on the farm. In this case, being "put out to pasture" is actually a good thing.
449a3be6_65f2_4128_b89e_e21b61e8d9dc_a0a3c5f463.jpg
 
I have two HP C-melodies: an Oscar Adler, needing some work; and a Hawkes & Son in fair, but not currently playable, condition.
If you're interested I'll let you know more - photos, price, condition, etc - at the weekend, and if you want to proceed it would be via the forum yardsale.
I would be interested
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,538
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom