I found this article an interesting read. I'm not sure I agree with all of what it says, but I thought it might be of some interest to the members here. It seems as if it could be an effective way to start a discussion. It is obvious the writer has never gone to Sax On The Web that has had as many as 85,734 users online at one time. (Granted Cafe Saxophone doesn't get as many participants, but they are certainly a higher class of people. He he he.)
Where Have All the Saxophones Gone
Referring back to the start of this thread, the article mentioned by
@jbtsax actually encapsulates what I have felt for at least 25 years, that the saxophone has little or no place in contemporary pop music. In my twenties (during the 70s and 80s) I did quite a bit of studio and live work on other people's pop tracks (Billy Ocean, Catherine Howe, Sally Oldfield, Talk Talk, Ali Thomson, Nick Heyward etc etc) and made two albums of my own. As I gradually moved away from commercial music to classical, due to my association with John Harle and Michael Nyman,
I had time to think about this change within music and I've come to my own conclusions.
Firstly, every generation rejects the previous one to some extent, especially as regards pop music which is by definition 'style' orientated. We sax players didn't have to do anything but grow older and have kids for our tastes and ways to become passé and to be rejected. What was raw and gutsy and cool in the 70s became 'cheesy' (very hurtful
😉)
Secondly, as producers moved to using sample based music via the Fairlight, Acorn. Akai samplers etc etc. the musical and technical problems of using a sax on a track started to stand out. By this I mean the humanity of the instrument became a problem. I was told by a producer that he would never use a saxophone if he could avoid it - why would he have an instrument that almost nobody could play as well in tune as a sample messing up his perfect track?
And to add to this my own experiments at blending a live sax performance with computerised tracks has proved frustrating - I no longer like to make a very bright sound on the instrument and IMO this makes things more difficult because you have to carve out a space for a complex acoustic sound amidst all that shallowness. And play spot on in tune.
But also, there was a backlash from both Jazz & Classical players during the mid 80s. Players were frustrated with the shallowness of pop sax and turned to the greats of the mid 20C as their role models, and finally the sax became viable as a classical instrument. When I went to Music College in 1974, the sax was not available as a 'first study' ('major' in USA) and only became so in around 1976 so I studied the Oboe for 4 years with sax as 'second study'. At last a player could find a viable official (grant assisted) course on which to follow his or her particular calling. This has made an enormous difference to our world. Players going through a 3 or 4 year college course emerge with the conviction that it should be possible to find employment either as a Jazz player or a Classical player - unfortunately not often realistic.
And of course there's the reality of financial considerations.
I consider myself extremely fortunate to have been a musician at a time when live work was still abundant - West End, National Theatre, TV, Orchestras, Tours, Film Scores and Commercial Sessions etc. etc. were all regular and viable gainful employment when I joined the profession after college. I even make some money in a Saxophone Quartet.
So, things have changed very radically and for a number of reasons. That's life. I'm OK with it because there was a huge amount of rubbish music made for the sake of creating product that we are better off without. But it's REALLY tough for players who want to play live though. I have a good friend who makes most of his living playing Jazz and writes his own music which was an inconceivably tough route to take before the present health situation, and on the face of it, it's certainly not going to be easier when all this is over.