Saxophone beginners Where do I start? (complete beginner)

I have an alto saxophone.
That's what I started on and still prefer.
What make and model is it? Did you buy new or used? If either, has it been serviced recently?
What make and model mouthpiece?
What reed/s do you have, make, model, strength?
These may seem unimportant but the better the equipment the less you have to worry about these being part of any learning issues.
 
... I want to sit in my own house, and play for fun.

So, I don't want to have a tutor - my guess is that I can get to where I want to be just learning online. ...
So you prefer flailing about doing things wrong, developing bad habits and getting frustrated, instead of taking some lessons from an actual human and learning how to do this thing correctly so it'll sound good and be easy? All righty then.
 
So you prefer flailing about doing things wrong, developing bad habits and getting frustrated, instead of taking some lessons from an actual human and learning how to do this thing correctly so it'll sound good and be easy? All righty then.
Having a bad day?
Go easy... we're supposed to be the friendly forum!
I'm sure there are many famous players who picked up a sax and never had a lesson let alone t'internet to (mis)guide them. Bad habits included. Am I correct?
 
did Eric Clapton have guitar lessons, or George Harrison, for example?!
Clapton was self taught, Harrison had some lessons from "a friend's Dad" when starting. The crux though: if I pluck a guitar string it sounds nice, especially if it's a nice guitar. When a beginner blows in to a saxophone, it really doesn't sound nice, if they're able to make a sound at all.

So I guess a more pertinent question would be to identify the sax players you like, and see whether they were taught.

Personally, I don't understand why having a tutor prevents you from exploring the instrument yourself, either. By having a teacher you aren't limited to playing in their presence, or only the things they prescribe....
 
I'm sure there are many famous players who picked up a sax and never had a lesson let alone t'internet to (mis)guide them. Bad habits included. Am I correct?
Probably fewer than you think. I know that pretty much everytime someone stated "well so and so was self taught and didn't have lessons" it invariably turns out that they actually did.

Acan_9526 on here is self taught, and very very good. I don't know whether that stemmed right to the very start. And Pete, as per the above.
 
Re - learning the basics like blowing into the mouthpiece: that's why I bought several beginner courses on Udemy from a variety of sax players - to teach me the basics - they will all say similar things, but in different ways, and I'm sure I will pick up something valuable from them all.

I know lots of people who can play an instrument competently but have never had formal tuition - in the old days, it wasn't affordable for many people - this was before online courses and youtube, people bought music books and taught themselves - did Eric Clapton have guitar lessons, or George Harrison, for example?!

I guess I am (and have always been) a rebel at heart! I get your point about the distinction between being able to play and playing nicely though - so maybe a few lessons at the start wouldn't hurt.
Non blowing instruments are a poor example as neither you or anyone else can see inside your body. An experienced player/teacher can hear the effect of things that need correcting without being able to see it.

Terrific player as Clapton is, are you sure that he wouldn’t be telling you that you’d do better with a teacher?
 
So you prefer flailing about doing things wrong, developing bad habits and getting frustrated, instead of taking some lessons from an actual human and learning how to do this thing correctly so it'll sound good and be easy? All righty then.
Maybe it's just my preferred learning style - to make mistakes and learn from them. I don't find that frustrating, I find it satisfying.

But you know, maybe you are right, and I'm being pig-headed by daring to think I could do okay (okay being the level I am aiming at) by myself.
But I really can't believe that every single musician who can play at an okay level has had lessons.

I'm open to experimenting and trying lessons as a way forward, as well as having a go myself.
 
Thank you: that is my gut feeling - to dive in and have a go, and get help from a teacher if I need it later - although everyone seems to be telling me I need one at the start for all the basic stuff, so I'm confused now.🙁
No you don't need one.
Maybe if after a few weeks you are getting nowhere, can't blow a note, don't know where to put your fingers, play a simple tune, maybe but otherwise do it your own way.
It's your sax and your time.
 
Non blowing instruments are a poor example as neither you or anyone else can see inside your body. An experienced player/teacher can hear the effect of things that need correcting without being able to see it.

Terrific player as Clapton is, are you sure that he wouldn’t be telling you that you’d do better with a teacher?
Maybe Clapton would be more formulaic if he had a teacher? Did experimenting and teaching himself actually make him a better guitarist?

I don't know the answer to that: but I can see the benefits of having a teacher, and of having a go at teaching yourself; and learning through your mistakes, and growing from doing things the way that the narrow "proper way" tells you that you shouldn't.

Maybe I'm talking through my hat - who knows 😉 . But the more people pile into this thread and tell me that there is only one correct way, and that is with a teacher, the more my heels are digging in - maybe to my detriment, I appreciate that!
 
No you don't need one.
Maybe if after a few weeks you are getting nowhere, can't blow a note, don't know where to put your fingers, play a simple tune, maybe but otherwise do it your own way.
It's your sax and your time.
Thank you, you seem to be the only one on my wavelength!
 
Maybe Clapton would be more formulaic if he had a teacher? Did experimenting and teaching himself actually make him a better guitarist?
You mean Clapton isn't forumulaic?!? 😀

As I said earlier, the thing I don't understand is that you're quite happy to go and learn from books/tutorials/online courses etc, but have the visceral aversion to a teacher. Who I think would likely get through the content of those books/courses/tutorials, but with the benefit of seeing and hearing you play to be able to see how you're getting on with them.

As a beginner, I think a teacher will help sort a load of stuff out that's very open for early misinterpretation, and help avoid some stuff that gets peddled that's just plain wrong (well assuming you get a good teacher of course). Afterall, the people that write those books, create those course and tutorials are just teachers, after all.
 
I play for myself but the first thing I did was get a tutor and have fortnightly lessons.

Doing this you'll avoid bad practice and can be set on your journey.

Did you learn to drive by yourself or did you have instruction?
You pretty much have to have lessons of some sort as you cannot be on the road without an experienced driver.
I had 15 lessons, no other practice, passed first time.
Taught myself to ride a motorbike, passed first time.
 
everyone seems to be telling me I need one at the start for all the basic stuff, so I'm confused now.🙁
You probably don't need a teacher! Ignore the unadventurous!

I haven't needed a teacher to achieve similar goals to yours. I'm a rebel like you. I find challenges inspiring, not frustrating. I find most teachers (of any subject) quite annoying. I've always progressed much faster by myself than with any syllabus so why not saxophone, too!?

I bought my soprano at about age 60, supposedly the hardest sax to start on. I have never had a lesson and six or so years later I have advanced far further than I ever expected. I have broken most of the accepted teaching "rules" and, IMO, greatly benefited by going my own way.

On the other hand, 50 years ago I did learn the clarinet from a teacher for 3 years. And I still remembered how to read music quite well.

I started with Pete's books and CDs that accompany TTS mentioned earlier.

In hindsight I think one lesson to demonstrate a saxophone embouchure would have helped me. My default clarinet embouchure held my progress back I think and it is difficult to learn from conflicting videos. On the other hand, teaching myself meant that my embouchure can easily cope with any mouthpiece and any tip size and still get amazing tone. Most students are told to keep practising on one mouthpiece for years. I did the opposite of course. LOL. An old man has no time for such a boring approach lest we die an untimely death before the sax fun overflows!

6 years later my goal of playing romantic ballads for my wife is more than satisfied. I've even given concerts for my friends which I never expected to do. And I now write my own ballads to romance my wife. I play soprano, tenor, clarinet, flute and aerophone with better facility than my childhood clarinet standard.

The biggest bonus is I now enjoy listening to saxophone music far more than when I started. I've greatly broadened my knowledge of history's greatest players and listen to my influencers daily.

You're beginning an exciting musical journey! All the best for your future. I know you have determination and that's all you need. 😀
 
I have an alto saxophone. I'm not sure of the difference between them, I just know one is smaller and one is bigger than mine!
There are 4 main types of saxophone, alto and tenor are the most common of those 4.
From high (smallest) to low (biggest instrument) these are the types:
  • soprano
  • alto
  • tenor
  • baritone
But there are some more exotic types of saxophone with a higher voice (sopranino and soprillo) or a lower voice Bass and contrabass. Those are transposing instruments in either Eb (like your alto) or Bb, that means that if you play a C on a saxophone, it will sound like Eb or Bb on the guitar.
And then there are some types that are either in C (like the guitar) or even in F, but those last ones are very exotic.

As for your determination to go for it without a teacher, you certainly are old enough to choose for yourself.

When I started with the saxophone (a bit before getting to 40) a friend of mine (a very good guitar player) advised me to get a sax and start blowing, not wait until the lessons started in September. I didn’t think that would be a good idea because I know that it is far harder to unlearn bad habits than to learn it the right way from the start.
 
A few words on the importance of determination as a beginner:

1. I estimate it took me 6 months to be bearable on Soprano.

2. Flute took 3 weeks just to make a sound, any sound!

3. Tenor was instantly playable ( but I have big former athlete lung power) but bell notes took probably a year to be reliably responsive.

4. Clarinet was instantly back to my childhood level.

5. Really good ballad play (awesome tone and professional level expressiveness as judged by wifey) has taken about 4 years for me and then another two to learn to write music well enough to make wife happy.

6. I will never be able to play "wall of sound" speed Jazz as I'm still relatively slow technically (scales, chords etc) despite 6 years of diligent practice. But I never expected to either. I've set my goals at ballads as achievable for an old man with not much time left. Anything beyond is a bonus.
 
You probably don't need a teacher! Ignore the unadventurous!

I haven't needed a teacher to achieve similar goals to yours. I'm a rebel like you. I find challenges inspiring, not frustrating. I find most teachers (of any subject) quite annoying. I've always progressed much faster by myself than with any syllabus so why not saxophone, too!?

I bought my soprano at about age 60, supposedly the hardest sax to start on. I have never had a lesson and six or so years later I have advanced far further than I ever expected. I have broken most of the accepted teaching "rules" and, IMO, greatly benefited by going my own way.

On the other hand, 50 years ago I did learn the clarinet from a teacher for 3 years. And I still remembered how to read music quite well.

I started with Pete's books and CDs that accompany TTS mentioned earlier.

In hindsight I think one lesson to demonstrate a saxophone embouchure would have helped me. My default clarinet embouchure held my progress back I think and it is difficult to learn from conflicting videos. On the other hand, teaching myself meant that my embouchure can easily cope with any mouthpiece and any tip size and still get amazing tone. Most students are told to keep practising on one mouthpiece for years. I did the opposite of course. LOL. An old man has no time for such a boring approach lest we die an untimely death before the sax fun overflows!

6 years later my goal of playing romantic ballads for my wife is more than satisfied. I've even given concerts for my friends which I never expected to do. And I now write my own ballads to romance my wife. I play soprano, tenor, clarinet, flute and aerophone with better facility than my childhood clarinet standard.

The biggest bonus is I now enjoy listening to saxophone music far more than when I started. I've greatly broadened my knowledge of history's greatest players and listen to my influencers daily.

You're beginning an exciting musical journey! All the best for your future. I know you have determination and that's all you need. 😀
Clive, I feel we are soulmates! And so glad to hear it is perfectly possible. It sounds like 6 years ago you started on a similar pathway to my chosen one - "the road less travelled"!

I'm going to go my own way, and see where it leads. If I need help from a real human in the future, I can always ask, but for now, I just want to enjoy the journey and see where it takes me. I don't have a road map, I don't have a timescale, and if I can blast out a few tunes on the sax for my own enjoyment before I reach my deathbed, I will have succeeded, in my eyes.

Thank you for your fun and inspiring post. And I will check out Pete's books....but CD's? What are they?😉
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,428
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom