Playing the saxophone When is the right time to double?

Mix O Lydian

Member
Messages
219
Location
England
Last November, still relatively early in my saxophone journey, I bought a flute, in the belief that as a smaller, more portable instrument, with similar fingering to the sax it would be easy to learn! Hah! How wrong was I?

Let's just say, it's been a steep learning curve. My progress is inconsistent. I'm finding it frustrating. :confused2: perhaps I'm just not a flutist.

(I've never felt that way about the sax.)

Meanwhile, I have recently changed sax teachers and it's given my sax playing a boost. I'm wondering whether I should just focus on the saxophone and ditch the flute?

So, when is the right time to double? When you've become competent your first instrument? Or is it possible to learn both side by side?
 
When the chart says "FLUTE".

Seriously, it just totally depends on what you're being called to do and what you want to do. I've known a few fine woodwind players who simply refuse to double.
 
Yeah we got a bit lumbered really. The woodwind family might all be narrow, pipey things but when the method of producing the sound is so different it's a tall order (though accepted in many a scenario).

Trumpets in a big band double flugelhorn - big deal. Strings are split into upper and lower - different tuning, clefs - again, big deal, the method of sound production is still the same. Some players play all woodwinds (very well!) - and they are single reed/double reed, and blow across a hole. Treble clef, tenor clef and bass clef. Concert, Bb, Eb (the most common) in pitch. So yes, we got the short straw. And no, it isn't easy.

Nestico and other 60's big band arrangers had sax, clarinet, flute and piccolo (occasionally).
 
Yeah we got a bit lumbered really. The woodwind family might all be narrow, pipey things but when the method of producing the sound is so different it's a tall order (though accepted in many a scenario).

Trumpets in a big band double flugelhorn - big deal. Strings are split into upper and lower - different tuning, clefs - again, big deal, the method of sound production is still the same. Some players play all woodwinds (very well!) - and they are single reed/double reed, and blow across a hole. Treble clef, tenor clef and bass clef. Concert, Bb, Eb (the most common) in pitch. So yes, we got the short straw. And no, it isn't easy.

Nestico and other 60's big band arrangers had sax, clarinet, flute and piccolo (occasionally).
As did arrangers in the 80s 70s 50s 40s 30s and even back in the 1920s.
 
Last November, still relatively early in my saxophone journey, I bought a flute, in the belief that as a smaller, more portable instrument, with similar fingering to the sax it would be easy to learn! Hah! How wrong was I?

Let's just say, it's been a steep learning curve. My progress is inconsistent. I'm finding it frustrating. :confused2: perhaps I'm just not a flutist.

(I've never felt that way about the sax.)

Meanwhile, I have recently changed sax teachers and it's given my sax playing a boost. I'm wondering whether I should just focus on the saxophone and ditch the flute?

So, when is the right time to double? When you've become competent your first instrument? Or is it possible to learn both side by side?

If you choose to take up the flute, recognize that it is sufficiently different to require a different set of skills and get a teacher for flute. If you're not up for that, then set it aside for later.

Many years ago I was an active doubler - meaning that I maintained proficiency on bassoon, clarinets, flutes, etc. in pit orchestras and big bands. Once I stopped maintaining that proficiency, I refused to double on those parts.

Doubler vs dabbler. My perspective is that if you cannot commit, it's not a double. For a real double, the listener should not be able to determine which is your primary instrument. That also demands a healthy and regular attention to practice on each instrument.

Set your own goals. I suggest you be realistic, but others will say "Do whatever is fun".
 
So, when is the right time to double? When you've become competent your first instrument? Or is it possible to learn both side by side?
That depends on the versatility of your embouchure. When the embouchure for two different instruments have a negative impact on each other it is not the right time. I can double on tenor sax and picolo flute, but not on bari and picolo.
 
Hah! How wrong was I?
Probably not be depends how mauch time you have to learn two things.,
So, when is the right time to double?
At the point when one does not impede progress in crucial initial stages of the other (primary instrument)
Or is it possible to learn both side by side?
yes once you have got over the initial struggles. There is no "when" that fits all. For me I think after a couple of years of embedding a saxophone sound/embouchure was about the right time.
 
If you choose to take up the flute, recognize that it is sufficiently different to require a different set of skills and get a teacher for flute. If you're not up for that, then set it aside for later.

Many years ago I was an active doubler - meaning that I maintained proficiency on bassoon, clarinets, flutes, etc. in pit orchestras and big bands. Once I stopped maintaining that proficiency, I refused to double on those parts.

Doubler vs dabbler. My perspective is that if you cannot commit, it's not a double. For a real double, the listener should not be able to determine which is your primary instrument. That also demands a healthy and regular attention to practice on each instrument.

Set your own goals. I suggest you be realistic, but others will say "Do whatever is fun".
Thank you. That's useful. I like "doubles Vs dabbler". I know which one I currently am!
 
Thank you. That's useful. I like "doubles Vs dabbler". I know which one I currently am!
I found flute embouchure really difficult, but it's something that some people find a lot easier. You never know until you try. The fingering being sort of similar is usefulish, but the main advantage I got was that the flute called for proper air support just to get a sound, wheres with the saxophone you can coast (for a while) without. Obviously it's crucial that you doo sooner or later but yes, you can "coast." Flute forces you to get the old diaphragm going.
 
Probably not be depends how mauch time you have to learn two things.,

At the point when one does not impede progress in crucial initial stages of the other (primary instrument)

yes once you have got over the initial struggles. There is no "when" that fits all. For me I think after a couple of years of embedding a saxophone sound/embouchure was about the right time.
Yes the time I spend on the flute naturally takes me away from the sax and therefore impedes progress. So I definitely feel that I should focus on one thing, especially now that I have a really good teacher. I will probably sell the flute!
 
I found flute embouchure really difficult, but it's something that some people find a lot easier. You never know until you try. The fingering being sort of similar is usefulish, but the main advantage I got was that the flute called for proper air support just to get a sound, wheres with the saxophone you can coast (for a while) without. Obviously it's crucial that you doo sooner or later but yes, you can "coast." Flute forces you to get the old diaphragm going.
I had hoped that the air support needed for flute would benefit my sax playing. I just can't get it though. Makes me hyperventilate!
 
Flute does help your air support on saxophone. It’s just that you have no resistance to push against. So you have to regulate your air yourself, while still maintaining strong support from your core. Concentrate on having the resistance in your belly muscles. Once you get over the hyperventilation stage (it took me about 4 months) it will help your sax support.

[EDIT] I agree that ALL woodwinds are quite different. Fingerings have similarities, but you do have to learn a different way to blow for each. And in the case of flute, a different posture.
 
As something to think about, one late starter to another and acknowledging everyone's strengths and weaknesses are different. If you feel you have time in the week you want to spend on music but resting the sax...

I found mucking around with totally different instruments more of a benefit than just other blowy-tubes. Being more musical generally is probably good for the sax, irrespective of instrument.
Eg (for me)
Although it's on the back burner now, some basic ability to navigate the piano helped understand "music theory" - chords, their variations and sequences, voice leading etc.
My hand drum is a key tool for improving my timing and rhythm feel.
My newly acquired inability to sing is good for the ears and ear-voicing coordination; and breath control.
Oh, and listening with intent; also time well spent away from the instrument.

There are certainly other directions.
 
From Johns Hopkins Medicine:
What is hyperventilation?
Hyperventilation is rapid or deep breathing.
This overbreathing, as it is sometimes called, may actually leave you feeling breathless.
When you breathe, you inhale oxygen and exhale carbon dioxide. Excessive breathing may lead to low levels of carbon dioxide in your blood, which causes many of the symptoms that you may feel if you hyperventilate.

The, deep breathing, is a common mistake caused by not studying the flute, from lesson one, with an accomplished flute player who knows how to teach correctly.

You don't need a lung full of air to learn the correct embouchure, to excite the column of air, in a flute/piccolo.
Unless you're trying to play the Syrinx
or Pure Imagination with only,
one gulp of air. 😵‍💫

The Yamaha YRF-21Y is great to carry around.

Lots of great doublers, sax/flute, but most often their tone in "different" than a flute/picc only orchestra level musician, who's day job consists of classical literature, studio and the early years of TV.

Practice, is to do something correctly, repeatedly.
First you learn to do something correctly, then you can practice that.
Was advised to practice the flute prior to sax practice.
 
Yes the time I spend on the flute naturally takes me away from the sax and therefore impedes progress. So I definitely feel that I should focus on one thing, especially now that I have a really good teacher. I will probably sell the flute!

I can empathise, but I wouldn't yet sell the flute quite yet! I played (amateur) guitar for 25 years before renting my 1st sax. I couldn't maintain my level of practice on both instruments so I focused on learning (tenor) sax. I've stuck with tenor sax for 35 years.:
a) I still love the sound, the range and the feel of the tenor sax; from time to time, I've tried out Bari, alto and Sop. but the tenor still feels like ''my sax'.b) Over the past 20 years, I've sold my 3 (acoustic) guitars. For the past few years. Mostly because I wasn't using them. And also becaue I needed the money Now, I still wish that I had a guitar and I intend to buy one!
c) A couple of years ago, I bought a bass guitar and I'm enjoying playing it once a week alongside my sax sessions twice a week.
d) my daughter played flute in her teenage years, which I've tried out from time to time; yes I can play some tunes (as if if was a metal 'descant recorder' but based on my learning experienc with the sax, I realize that it would take a lot more practice (and perhaps tutoring) to learn to play a flute well.

So my personal advice is:
- if you like the sound of the flute and if you have a good model, keep it (unless you need to sell it)
- focus for the comimg year or 2 (or 3) on learning to play sax.
- Once your'e confident playing sax, you can start to learn to double on flute

Best wishes,

Mike
 
On your second instrument, learn to play it well. Learn to easily move back and forth (i.e., play both) for performances. Then, you can add colour to the band when needed. People like to hear what's good and will take note when you play the other.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,436
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom